Thunderstone FAQ
498 questions players ask · Updated Nov 19, 2026 · Full rulebook
General
- Can a card that makes you discard or destroy a card, like Scroll of Chaos, affect itself?
- In solo play, can you attack a Monster you cannot defeat?
- Can I play Thunderstone solo with only the base game?
- In solo play, does the Dungeon Hall start filled with Monsters?
- In solo play, do Monsters advance on a turn when you do not fight?
- In solo play, do Monsters advance on the turn after you defeat one?
- In solo play, do you refill the Dungeon Hall after you fail to defeat a Monster?
- Can you use Banish or other monster-moving abilities in a solo game?
- In solo play, do consecutive defeats give you extra free turns?
- What is the difference between original Thunderstone and Thunderstone Advance?
- Which rules version should I print, and what changed in version 1.4?
- What happens if the XP or Disease supply runs out?
- In what order do all players resolve an effect that every player performs?
Setup
- How are Hero cards arranged into stacks at setup, and are all levels used in a first game?
- Which Monster set should a first game use, Doomknights or Undead Doom?
- What cards does each player start with in the Party Deck?
- Why does the rulebook count 90 Basic cards when only 75 seem to be Basic?
- Where does the Thunderstone card go when I set up the Dungeon Deck?
- What are the 50 extra-wide card dividers in the Thunderstone box for?
- Is the Village setup fully random, or must certain cards be included?
- Should Hero decks be reduced in a two-player game?
- Does the order of the first Monsters placed in the Hall matter at setup?
- Where do leftover Basic cards go, and are all Militia used in a five-player game?
Playing the Game
- Must I reveal my whole hand when I enter the Dungeon or visit the Village?
- Can you look at your hand before choosing to visit the Village, enter the Dungeon or rest?
- On your turn, can you visit the Village and also enter the Dungeon or rest?
- What is the exact order of steps when entering the Dungeon to fight a Monster?
- Can you enter the Dungeon, fight a Monster or cast a Spell with no Hero in hand?
- Can you level up, use the Village effects and buy in any order on your turn?
- When I rest, do I have to reveal the rest of my hand?
- What can you destroy when you rest, and is destroying a card required?
- Does resting end your turn?
- Can you keep cards from one hand and add them to the next turn's hand?
- When do you reshuffle your discard pile into your Party deck?
- If an effect reveals cards from your Party deck and the deck is empty, do you shuffle the discard pile?
- Must you play every card in your hand when entering the Dungeon?
- When does the Dungeon Hall refill?
- Can you take no action on your turn, or end it without buying or destroying anything?
- Are Dungeon, Village and Spoils effects mandatory?
- How do you claim the Thunderstone, and when does the game end?
- After the Thunderstone reaches Rank 2, do empty Dungeon ranks still refill and Monsters still advance?
- Is there a rule for players attacking one another?
- Do Heroes and Weapons stay on the table between turns, or only work when drawn?
- Can you use a card you just bought this turn?
- When buying in the Village, are the gold cards played or discarded?
- Can I use cards drawn with Town Guard in the Dungeon on the same turn?
- Where do cards go after an effect reveals them with no destination specified?
Village Cards
- Do Basic cards such as Militia, Torch, Iron Rations and Dagger count as Village cards?
- What counts as a Village card when a card effect refers to Village cards?
- Can you use only some abilities on a revealed card, use the same ability on two copies, or use several actions in one turn?
- Can you use a card's effect and then destroy that same card for a second effect in one turn?
- Does Pawnbroker add the destroyed card's own gold value to its bonus?
- Can you destroy Pawnbroker together with another card in one turn?
- Can Pawnbroker destroy a Militia, and can it destroy a card with no gold icon such as Disease?
- Can Pawnbroker destroy a card outside your hand, such as one in the Village or your deck?
- How many cards can you buy in a turn, and does a Barkeep's extra buy add gold?
- Can a Barkeep buy two copies of the same card in one turn?
- Which number on a Village card is its purchase cost, and can you buy a Militia with no gold?
- If a Village card is destroyed mid-turn, do its earlier effects still apply, and does its gold count?
- Can one Militia pay for two Trainers, and can you use both Trainer abilities in one visit?
- Do two Town Guards draw four cards, and how many can you draw with both destroyed?
- If another card destroys a Town Guard, do you still get its extra draw?
- Can you use a Village or Dungeon ability of a card you drew with another card-draw effect?
- Does the Warhammer's bonus against Doomknights also apply to combined classes such as Doomknight-Guardian?
- If several Heroes gain attack for destroying Food, does one destroyed Food give them all a bonus?
- Can you play several Banish cards before choosing which Monster to attack?
- Can Banish rearrange the Hall so the Thunderstone moves to Rank 1?
Hero Cards
- Are Militia Heroes?
- Can a Militia be destroyed to satisfy a monster's effect that makes you destroy a Hero?
- Which cards get Selurin's Magic Attack +1 bonus?
- Does Selurin's Magic Attack +1 apply to a Dagger or other Weapons?
- What does an Amazon's 'attack +2 at rank 2 or 3' refer to?
- Do Items have to be carried or equipped by a hero to be used?
- If a hero loses its weapon, can it equip a different weapon in the same turn?
- Is a hero still equipped if a Dungeon or Battle effect removed its weapon?
- Does Drunari Vagabond's 'worth 3 or more gold' mean a card's gold value or its cost?
- When Dark Champion makes you discard a card, does it come from your newly drawn hand?
- Is a hero destroyed when its Strength drops to 0 or less?
- Does Selurin's item bonus still apply if she is prevented from attacking?
- If Selurin is unequipped and the Monster is immune to unequipped heroes, do her items still get Magic Attack +1?
- Can a hero equip a weapon, and how do Strength and Weight compare?
- Is the Chalice Defender's extra Attack from light items physical or Magic Attack?
- If two Chalice Paladins are in your party, do you get two purchases after a won battle?
- Can you buy a level 2 or level 3 hero from the Village directly?
- Can you buy a level 2 or 3 hero before the lower-level copies are gone, or when it is not on top of its pile?
- Do two or more Clan Sergeants' attack bonuses stack on each other?
- How many weapons can one hero equip?
- Is there a limit on how many Heroes I can buy?
- Does one Edged Weapon give the attack bonus to every Dwarf in hand?
- Can you use the ability of a hero you borrowed with a Selurin Theurge?
- Does Selurin Theurge's discard make the active player discard a hero too?
- Where does a hero borrowed with a Selurin Theurge go when it is returned?
- Does an Additional Attack bonus add to a hero's attack, or give a second attack?
- How many cards does Divine Prophet draw when you use its ability?
- Can a Faeyn Archer attack a rank 1 monster if it holds a weapon such as a Dagger?
- Can a hero borrowed with Selurin Theurge be destroyed in battle, and does it go back to its owner?
- How does Selurin Warlock's double Magic Attack apply to the party?
- Can an unequipped hero attack or contribute benefits to a battle?
- Do unequipped weapons add attack, or give any benefit?
- Can several Outlanders each use the same revealed Monsters for their Attack bonus?
- Does a Dwarf still get its Edged Weapon bonus against a Monster immune to Edged Weapons?
- Does a Dwarf keep its bonus if its Edged Weapon becomes unequipped?
- Does a Hero's Strength add to its attack in battle?
- Does Chalice Defender's +1 Attack per light item count an equipped weapon such as a Flaming Sword?
- Can a hero carry more than one weapon, or share weapons with another hero?
- Can a hero that cannot attack still be destroyed by a Battle Effect?
- If a hero cannot attack, do its Dungeon Effects or traits still apply?
- Does a Faeyn keep its Light bonus if a Dungeon action makes it not attack?
- Does a Dwarf's Edged Weapon bonus add to its base Attack or replace it?
Leveling Up
- Must you level up a Hero before buying or using other Village cards in the same turn?
- When in the Village visit can you level up Heroes, before or after the purchase?
- Can you spend the gold of a Hero you are about to level up?
- Can you level up several Heroes in one Village visit, including two Militia?
- Can you buy a Hero in the Village and level it up on the same visit?
- Is a Militia a Hero for leveling up and for effects that target Heroes?
- How is buying a Level 2 or 3 Hero with gold different from leveling it up with XP?
- Can a Level 1 Hero level up straight to Level 3, skipping Level 2?
- How do you level up a Militia?
- Are Militia level 0 Heroes?
- Can a Militia be leveled up to a Level 2 Hero?
- What does it cost to level up a Hero, and do you pay gold?
- Do XP tokens go into your deck or into a separate pile?
- When you level up a Hero, what happens to the old card?
- Can you look through the Hero piles before deciding to level or buy?
- Can you level a Hero into a next-level card that is not on top of its stack?
- Do you gain XP for losing a battle in the Dungeon?
Monster Cards
- When does Breach resolve relative to Spoils and drawing a new hand?
- Does a Breach effect trigger if a Breach monster starts the game in Rank 1?
- Where does a defeated monster go, and do its Battle effects happen again when I draw it?
- Do you get a defeated monster's XP every time its gold comes up in your hand?
- Does the monster deck act as a timer in multiplayer?
- When Tyxr the Old reaches Rank 1, do players discard two cards before or after the active player refills his hand?
- Can you pick a hero that cannot attack a Rank 1 Haunt to be the one its effect excludes?
- Do Spoils abilities trigger when a monster is drawn, or only when you defeat it?
- How are the Succubus and Noxious Slag half-attack effects calculated?
- Does Iron Rations' Dungeon effect let a hero attack a Stone Golem?
- Can the Sphinx's Spoils destroy more than one of the six revealed cards?
- Do you still score a monster's victory points if you destroyed it by resting?
- When Chulian Scavenger makes other players reveal their hand, do they lose those cards?
- Is a monster you cannot attack while a spell is active the same as one immune to spells?
- Can an Orc Warlord be damaged by unequipped Heroes?
- Must you still go to the Dungeon next turn if you defeat the Guardian of Revenge?
- Can Ogre Mage's Battle discard target Summon Storm?
- Do Guardians always come in pairs in the Dungeon, and what do the two Guardian randomizer cards mean?
- When Pyre Viper says each player must show a curse, can a curse in the draw pile count?
- Can I attack a monster that cannot be attacked while spells or weapons are in hand by choosing not to use them?
- What does 'revealed' mean in the Hungry Dead's battle effect?
- What counts as a hero class for Skywyrm Overlord's effect?
- When a Breach removes the top cards of each deck in the Village, does that include the Hero stacks?
- If the Thunderstone enters Rank 1 and the monster there is not defeated, what happens?
- Do a monster's Trophy effects work while it is still in the Dungeon Hall?
- Does a solo breach that makes me discard cards affect me when I have no cards left to discard?
- Does rank 3 keep populating after the Thunderstone moves into rank 2?
- When two Stones are in play and one is claimed, do monsters skip ranks?
- What is the difference between Magic Attack Required and Magic Attack Only on a monster?
- Against a Magic Attack Only monster, does a hero's normal Attack count or only its Magic Attack?
- Does the Ghost's halved attack apply when a Magic Attack is in the fight?
- Does a -1 Attack effect reduce Magic Attack as well as regular Attack?
- Does a Flaming Sword work against a Noxious Slag, which is immune to edged weapons?
- What does Blink Dog's cannot-attack effect mean for your party, and can you still choose a Monster?
- How many Diseases do Monsters with a global Gain a Disease effect cause over several Dungeon visits?
- When a Dryad is revealed in the Hall, do you draw another Monster?
Battles
- Do multiple copies of the same effect stack, such as several Feasts or Battle Fury?
- If a monster's Battle effect says destroy a card type I do not have in hand, can I still fight it?
- Do cards destroyed by a Battle effect still count toward your attack total and stay in the fight?
- Does the gold value of a card destroyed by a Battle Effect count toward Spoils?
- How is a Spoils purchase paid for after winning a battle?
- If several Spoils abilities trigger in one battle, how many Spoils do you get and is the gold limit per Spoils or total?
- Do Spoils that name a card type give you a free card, or must you buy it with gold?
- For a Battle effect that destroys the Hero with the highest Total Attack, do weapons count, and who picks on a tie?
- Can you deliberately lose a Dungeon battle to get rid of a Monster?
- If a Monster says unequipped Heroes cannot attack, does an unequipped Magician's item bonus still apply?
- If my Strength drops below what I need to equip a weapon, do I keep its bonus?
- If a battle effect makes a hero's Strength too low, does the hero still fight?
- Does a hero die when their Strength is reduced to zero?
- Can you re-equip a Weapon to another Hero after a Battle Effect lowers the first Hero's Strength?
- If I destroy my equipped Spear for its bonus, does it still count as equipped for battle effects like Gray Ooze?
- When a Magi Staff or other weapon is destroyed by an effect, does its bonus stop immediately?
- When do battle effects resolve, relative to the total Attack value?
- When do battle effects that destroy cards resolve relative to the fight?
- When are cards destroyed by a Battle effect actually removed from the game?
- Are defeated Heroes removed from the game or put in the discard pile?
- If you attack a monster and fail to defeat it, where does it go, and does the hall still refill?
- Must you fight a monster you cannot defeat once you enter the Dungeon?
- Can you keep a hero or card out of the fight to avoid a Battle effect that destroys cards?
- Does a battle effect still hit a hero that cannot attack or does not attack?
- Can you attack a monster your party cannot attack, to move it to the bottom of the Dungeon deck?
- Can a Repeat Dungeon effect like the Regian's be used several times in one dungeon visit?
- Does REPEAT mean you can repeat the whole Dungeon turn, or only that one effect?
- Can a battle effect that destroys one weapon hit a weapon I did not equip or use?
- Can you still use a weapon to defeat a monster whose battle effect destroys it?
- What does a 'destroy one fighter' battle effect require you to destroy?
- If a Dwarf loses the Strength to wield his edged weapon, does he still get the edged-weapon Attack bonus?
- Does Greedblade's '+1 Attack for each 2 gold' count its own gold value, and how is an odd total rounded?
- Does the Sphinx's discard effect still trigger if I attack it and fail?
- Do Ambrosia and Border Guard protect heroes from Raid, Trap, or Breach effects after a battle ends?
- If a borrowed hero is discarded rather than destroyed, is it returned to its owner at end of battle?
- Do weapons need to be assigned to a hero before their Attack counts?
- Do Aftermath effects happen even when you lose the battle?
- Does a battle effect that destroys a hero also destroy the weapons attached to it?
- Can I use each village effect on a revealed card, and in what order?
- Can food or items that raise a hero's Strength stop a battle effect that destroys heroes with low Strength?
- Can two simultaneous Battle effects, such as two Banish spells, both target the same card for discard?
- Can one hero be destroyed by two different Battle effects in the same battle?
- Where does a card you gain during battle go, and can you use it in that same battle?
- Can I choose an unequipped hero to suffer Haunt's battle effect?
- When you lose a battle, are the cards you revealed from your hand destroyed?
- What is the order of steps when a monster battle is resolved?
- Can you fight a monster with only Fireball cards and no hero?
- If a battle effect asks you to destroy something you do not have, such as food, can you still attack?
Dungeon Effects
- Do two copies of Battle Fury each add their bonus in one Dungeon battle?
- Are Dungeon Effects mandatory, or can you skip them?
- Can a Food card give one Dungeon bonus and then be destroyed for another, or the reverse?
- Can a Hero eat several Food cards, such as Iron Rations plus Feast, to raise its Strength?
- Do Dungeon Effects resolve before Battle Effects?
- Do Dungeon Effects resolve before you choose which monster to fight?
- Does Power Word: Kill trigger the defeated monster's Battle Effects?
- When several Creeping Death cards are played in one Dungeon visit, are their Health reductions combined?
- Does Creeping Death reduce monsters that enter the Hall after a refill?
- What happens to a monster that Creeping Death reduces to zero Health?
- Can I still attack a monster that Creeping Death has weakened but not reduced to 0?
- When Banish moves a Breach monster into Rank 1, does its Breach resolve before or after Banish's destroy-and-draw?
- Does a Breach effect trigger again when its monster leaves Rank 1 and later returns?
- If a Breach effect forces a discard, is the card taken from the hand you were already going to discard?
- Where do cards go after a Breach, a Trap or another effect reveals them from your deck?
- If a reveal-until-you-find effect runs out of cards in your draw pile, do you shuffle and keep revealing?
- Can a revealed Hero be kept out of the attacking party when you enter the Dungeon?
- Do you need a Hero in play to cast attacking spells such as Fireball or Magic Missile?
- Can a Dungeon Effect destroy a card that has already been used for another Dungeon Effect?
- Must you do every part of Banish's Dungeon Effect, including the destroy and the draw, even if Banish destroys itself?
- Can Banish or the Elf Sorcerer or Archmage move the Thunderstone to the bottom of the monster deck?
- When do you refill the Dungeon Hall after an Elf Sorcerer or Archmage returns a monster to the bottom of the deck?
- Can you still attack after using the Thyrian Lord's Dungeon ability?
- When an effect makes other players discard, do they choose which card to discard?
- Does a Dragon Words trap stop the player who defeated the monster from keeping its Experience?
- Where do you reveal a Thief from when a trap such as Dragon Words requires one?
- How does Dragon's Teeth apply when several players reveal Heroes?
- In what order can you use several Dungeon Effects, and are cards they destroy still available for the battle?
- What does a Repeat Dungeon ability let you do?
- If you hold several copies of a Repeat ability, such as Chalice Quester, does each copy add more uses?
- Do Dungeon Effects like Attack +1 still apply to Heroes drawn later in the same Dungeon turn?
- Can cards drawn by a Dungeon Effect be used right away in battle?
- When a Trap forces a shuffle, is your hand included in it?
- Does Ambrosia's strength and attack bonus reach Heroes drawn after it is used?
- Can Ambrosia's discard-instead-of-destroy be used to pull a Hero out before a battle, or protect it from a trap?
- If I destroy the Spear for its Dungeon bonus and then my Strength is reduced, do I still get the +5 Attack?
- Can a Hero equip two Magi Staffs, destroying the first to move a monster and then equipping the second?
- If a monster destroys food in battle, does a Thyrian Squire's food-destroying Dungeon Effect happen first?
- Can a Dungeon Effect that destroys Heroes stop you fighting a Bandit that needs several Heroes?
- Can a Battle Effect destroy a Banish spell you already cast this turn?
Light and Darkness
- How is a monster's Light Penalty worked out?
- How much Attack do you lose for each missing point of Light?
- Does extra Light give your party an Attack bonus?
- Is the Light Penalty applied once per battle, or once for each Hero?
- Is the Light Penalty taken off before or after Battle Effects and halving?
- Does a Light Penalty reduce Attack or Magic Attack separately?
- Can Attack from other cards offset a Light Penalty against a Magic-Attack-only monster?
- Does an unequipped weapon give its Light or Attack bonus?
- Does a Hero that cannot attack, or is left out of the fight, still provide Light?
- Do light items such as a Torch, Lantern or Fireball have to be equipped to give Light?
- Does a monster's Light icon count while it is in the Dungeon, or only after it is defeated?
- Does the Blind ignore light penalties for the whole party?
- Does Light from a card destroyed for a Dungeon Effect still count toward the Light Penalty?
- Do monsters spawned by a Dryad get Light Penalties in their new ranks?
- How does Lord Mortis's Light −1 interact with the Light Penalty?
- Can you attack a Blink Dog when you do not have enough Light?
Attack and Magic Attack
- Does an Attack bonus, such as Battle Fury, a Dagger or a trophy's +1, add to Magic Attack?
- Does a monster's Attack −X penalty reduce a hero's Magic Attack?
- How does a Disease's −1 Attack apply when the monster allows only Magic Attack?
- Can a Disease reduce Magic Attack when the monster is immune to Magic Attack?
- Does Judgement's Attack −1 also reduce a hero's Magic Attack?
- Do Attack and Magic Attack add together into one total?
- Does a monster immune to Magic Attack still take the non-magic bonuses?
- Against a monster that takes only Magic Attack, such as the Sphinx, do non-magic values count?
- Does a single point of Magic Attack stop a monster's halving effect from applying to the whole attack?
- When a monster halves your attack, is the halving applied to the total, and which way does it round?
- Do Goodberries turn an equipped weapon's bonus into Magic Attack too?
- Does Arcane Energies turn all of a hero's attack, including weapon bonuses, into Magic Attack?
- If a Magic Attack hero wields a physical weapon, does the weapon's bonus become Magic Attack?
- How is a doubling effect such as Magic Attack ×2 calculated?
- Do multiple Selurin Wizards multiply Magic Attack, and do their doublings stack?
- Does a monster immune to edged weapons also stop an unarmed attack, like Thyrian's?
Traits
- Against a Magic Attack Only monster, does my physical Attack count toward defeating it?
- Are Weapons Items?
- Does a Torch in my hand give Light even when I would rather it did not?
- Does Selurin Magician's +1 Magic Attack apply to Weapons like the Dagger, to trophies, or to all Items?
- Do several Selurin Magicians stack their Magic Attack bonus on each Item?
- Does a Dwarf's Edged Weapon bonus still apply when fighting Noxious Slag, which is immune to Edged Weapons?
- If a monster is immune to Magic Attack, can a Disease or minus modifier still lower Magic Attack?
- If a monster halves the attack, is it half the combined total or only part of it?
- Can spells alone attack a monster that heroes without weapons cannot attack?
- What is the difference between a monster that cannot be attacked and one that cannot be defeated?
- Does a hero that I choose not to attack with still contribute its Light or Attack to the battle?
- Can you attack a Revenant without Magic Attack?
- Can a hero without a weapon attack at all?
- Does Magic Attack Required mean I need only Magic Attack to defeat the monster?
- Do a monster's Spoils trigger when it is in my hand, or only when I defeat it in the Dungeon Hall?
- Can a Spoils (Village) effect let me use Village cards such as Barkeep to raise gold for the purchase?
- If I have several Spoils effects after a battle, can I buy several cards with the same gold?
Disease Cards
- Can a Cleric destroy a Disease in the Dungeon, and does its -1 still apply once it is gone?
- Does a Disease gained during a battle affect that battle, or can I destroy it then?
- Can a Disease reduce Magic Attack instead of Attack, and what if my Attack is zero?
- Does a Disease apply before or after a doubling effect such as the Selurin Theurge's?
- What happens when the Disease deck runs out, and can base and expansion Disease cards be used together?
Winning the Game
- Do unspent Experience Points count as victory points at the end of the game?
- Is the Thunderstone collected automatically when it reaches Rank 1?
- Do victory point cards destroyed by a card effect still count at the end of the game?
- When does the game end after the Thunderstone breaches into Rank 1?
- Where is the Thunderstone in the Dungeon Deck, and when does the game end?
- Can the game stall when nobody wants to fight the Rank 1 monster in front of the Thunderstone?
- Does a defeated monster's battle effect still apply once it is in my hand or deck?
- If an Elf Sorcerer or Archmage moves the Rank 1 monster away and the Thunderstone enters Rank 1, do I claim it?
- If I lose to the Rank 1 monster and the Thunderstone moves into Rank 1, who claims the Thunderstone?
- Is the Thunderstone worth victory points, or is it only a tiebreaker?
- Can a final score be negative, and can a player win with 0 VP?
Rules Clarifications and Variants
- In solo play, do monsters advance when I rest or visit the Village, and what does advancing do?
- In solo play, does entering the Dungeon to fight advance the monsters, whether I win or lose?
- In solo play, do monsters advance on the turn after I defeat one?
- In solo play, what happens to the other monsters when I defeat the monster in Rank 2?
- How is the winner decided in solo play, and does the Thunderstone break a tie?
- Which cards should be left out of a solo game?
- Can you play the original Thunderstone with the solo rules from Advance?
- Can I enter the Dungeon if no monster there can be attacked?
- What does 'party' mean in the Cannot Attack rule?
- If a monster says heroes cannot attack, do those heroes still provide Light and Dungeon effects?
- Must I be able to pay for a card bought with a Spoils (Village) effect?
- When a breach makes me reveal cards and my draw deck runs out, do I reshuffle the discard pile?
- What does Repeat Dungeon mean on a hero card?
- Does a Barkeep's extra purchase need enough gold for both cards combined?
- If a card destroys another card that has gold value, do I still get that card's gold for buying in the Village?
Card Glossary
- Can Banish destroy itself, or discard itself, as part of its own effect?
- Does Arcane Energies turn an equipped weapon's attacks into Magic Attack?
- Can Arcane Energies draw a card when no hero has an equipped weapon?
- Can you cast Fireball when you have no heroes in hand?
- Did the Thunderstone card reprint change any card rules?
- Can a card with a discard effect, such as Scroll of Chaos or Border Guard, discard itself?
- What does Ignore mean on a card?
- Does Goodberries turn a weapon's Attack bonus into Magic Attack?
- Can I play two Spirit Blast spells in the same battle?
- Do multiple Feast cards stack, and do they boost Militia too?
- Do I need a Cleric or Wizard to cast spells, and is there a limit on how many spells I can use?
- Does the Selurin Theurge's discard effect make the player who uses it discard?
Thunderstone: Wrath of the ElementsExpansion
- Can Thunderstone with Wrath of the Elements be played with six players?
- If Gangland Heavy and Selurin Theurge are both in the same Dungeon, which Dungeon effect resolves first?
- Does Blood Torment's Breach destroy step apply only to the cards revealed and discarded in the first step?
- Where must the card come from when Sage destroys a card to gain XP?
- Which cards go into the Dungeon Deck when a Trap randomizer is drawn?
- What happens when the Monster randomizer draws a Dungeon Feature card?
- What is the Pick Two special randomizer?
- If two Guardian randomizers are drawn but only one Guardian card exists, what happens?
- Which Hero does Tavern Brawl compare against, and what happens to the revealed Hero that loses?
- Do card effects that target Victory Points, such as Thyrian Lord, Claymore or Power Word Kill, affect Horde or Swarm monsters?
- Does Gohlen Hunter's same-type condition need an exact match of creature type, such as Undead Spirit against Undead Doom?
- Can a spell, weapon or hero stand in for an Item when a Blind hero destroys a Light Item?
- Does a light-giving weapon or spell cancel a level 3 Blind hero's bonus for having no Light Items?
- Does each Runespawn Witch's Magic Attack bonus also apply to other Runespawn Witches in play?
- Do Creeping Death's Dungeon effects resolve before I choose which monster to attack?
- Does casting Creeping Death count as attacking a monster in the Dungeon?
- Does Creeping Death still kill a Basilisk whose Health is raised by Battle effects?
- Does Creeping Death count as Magic Attack for conditions like '1/2 Attack Without Magic Present' or 'Magic Attack Only'?
- Does Creeping Death's damage to a monster stay after my turn ends?
- Can I attack the Thunder Wrath monster with my weapons equipped?
- If a Cage traps a hero, who places the hero in the Cage and who rescues it?
- If two Cage traps are revealed but I have only one hero, what happens to the second Cage, and are both heroes released together?
- Do trap effects resolve against the hand that was just played?
- How are Horde monsters handled in solo play, and do I advance the hall when I defeat one?
- Is each Horde worth VP equal to the number of Hordes in the deck when it is in the monster pile at the end of a solo game?
- If two Diin Beguilers copy a hero's ability onto a Militia, does the Militia get both copies?
- Can an opponent discard a card with a printed gold value of 0, such as a Militia, to satisfy a 'discard a card with gold value' effect?
- Does 'each player' in Tax Collector or Toryn Gladiator include the player who played the card?
- When I attack a Guardian in Rank 0, do I say I am going to the Village or the Dungeon?
- Can an Archer attack a Guardian in Rank 0?
- In Facing the Darkness Alone (Normal), do monsters advance the turn after I defeat a monster, including the rank-0 Guardian?
- In solo play, what happens to a monster I fail to defeat, and what happens to the Dungeon after each fight?
- If a Diin Beguiler copies a Militia as a hero, can I destroy the copied Militia when a destroy-hero effect triggers?
- Is a card I borrow for a turn, such as an Illusory Blade, considered to be in my hand?
- If an Illusory Blade is used as a Spear, does destroying the Spear for its bonus satisfy the Illusory Blade's destroy-after-battle requirement?
- Can I play Foresight Elixir during another player's turn or trap, including from my deck or discard pile, and what does return mean?
- Is 'Spell used this turn' the same as 'Spell activated' for the Air Wrath and Thunder Wrath traits?
- Why does Cursed Mace only give a disease when it is equipped?
- Does a non-equipped Claymore's Dungeon effect still work?
- When does the Claymore's effect of moving a 1- or 2-VP monster to my discard resolve?
- When does the Dark Champion's destroy-a-card effect happen?
- Can Short Bow's +2 Attack bonus be used against a Rank 1 monster?
- Can a Blacksmith drawn by a Blacksmith be used again, and how many extra cards can I buy?
- Can one monster in my hand satisfy the attack bonus of several Gohlens?
- Can a Toryn Scrapper equip several weapons, and is the limit their combined weight?
- Can Iron Rations boost a hero's Strength before a Tavern Brawl?
- Does a Dwarf keep its own listed Attack bonus when a Spear is destroyed for its +5 Attack?
- Does Steam Torment's global effect stay active while it is in the hall, even if I hold a Claymore?
- Can Torches, Lightstone Gems or a Flaming Sword reduce the Light Penalty from Water Wrath?
- Can a hero destroyed by a monster's battle effect be placed in the Cage when the hall refills?
- Does Gangland Crook's gold bonus add to its base Attack?
- Can Illusory Blade's copy come from the Village, and does it need a Short Sword in the Village?
- Does a weapon created by Illusory Blade count as a Spell or as a Weapon against monsters that cannot be attacked by Spells?
- Do Thunder Wrath and Air Wrath block attacks once a Spell is activated, including the weapon from Illusory Blade?
Thunderstone: Doomgate LegionExpansion
- Are Mercenaries Heroes?
- Is Flask of Oil an Item, a Weapon, or both?
- If you destroy Flask of Oil at end of battle, do you get +3 Attack and +3 Light?
- Does Arachnea gain Health for a Disease destroyed earlier in the Dungeon step?
- Does a Hero's Total Attack Value include the weapon bonus when The Bloodless destroys the hero with the highest Total Attack?
- Does Slynn Bowman's bonus against a monster type apply when the monster shares only some of its types?
- Does a Trophy's Humanoid attack bonus apply against a Humanoid monster that also has another type?
- Can a Leprosy disease's +3 buy cost apply to a purchase made through a Spoils effect?
- Can a hero go into negative strength from multiple Fatigue cards?
- When handing out several Special Diseases, do you give them one at a time around the table?
- Can a Sidhe's disease be given after looking at the disease type?
- If a Sidhe Spirit's monster carrying a disease is sent to the bottom of the deck by Banish, does the disease go with it?
- If a monster with a Sidhe-placed disease is taken into a player's discard pile (for example by Claymore), does that player gain the disease?
- Do Spoils effects require you to enter the dungeon and defeat a monster?
- If the Unholy Guardian breaches while the Thunderstone is already out, does the Thunderstone stay put?
- How does the Special Disease deck behave when it runs out?
- Can Doomgate Legion cards be mixed with the Advance starter set?
- Can Pious Chaplain's disease-destroying ability be used again on a disease drawn later in the same turn?
- Can Ulbrick's Armor destroy the revealed non-Hero cards of your opponents?
- Can you save Treasure cards and use several at the same time?
- Can you use two Strength Amulets in the same turn?
- Does Greed Blade count its own gold value toward its attack?
- Can the Sidhe Druid's disease come from the player's hand?
- Does a monster count as the same type only if it is from the same monster stack?
- What happens to a Swarm or Horde card placed under the monster pile?
- Does Hellstorm's Breach destroy heroes with conditional Magic Attack?
- Can Tempest's Spoils trigger after he has been discarded?
- What level are the original Thunderstone monsters for Advanced play?
- Can a Tempest Reaver or Warden secondary ability trigger when its hero did not attack the monster that was destroyed?
- How much Magic Attack does Spirit Blast give, and does it count XP cards in your deck?
- How does the Dragon's Teeth trap resolve when you reveal heroes?
- What does the Usurper's reward do if you defeat it?
- Does Drunari's 'worth 3 or more gold' refer to the buying cost or the gold value?
- Can you use Ulbrick's Helmet to draw three cards at the start of your turn, before choosing Village or Dungeon?
- When Ulbrick's Gauntlets gives you a bonus turn, do you draw a new hand?
- How does Tholis Clairvoyant's return-to-the-top effect work?
- Can one Flask of Oil be destroyed to pay both a Blind Neophyte's cost and the Flask's own Dungeon bonus?
- Does Tempest's spoils effect apply when the defeated monster is a Swarm?
- Does Monarch Druid count herself when checking for the +3 Lifepoints bonus from an Evil Druid?
- Can Border Guard discard itself to meet its own discard requirement after it has been used to draw a card?
- Where do XP cards go when Doomgate Squire's Repeat Dungeon effect says to discard 1 XP?
- Can Glowberries be used outside the dungeon, such as with Tavern Brawl?
- If two Verdan effects both trigger in the dungeon, in what order do they resolve?
- Do you use all 25 Special Disease cards when playing with Doomgate Legion?
- Does a Verdan Minstrel's discard effect resolve once for each Minstrel revealed?
- When two Doomgate Squires are in hand, does their Destroy 1 XP for +1 Attack ability stack?
- Does Border Guard protect heroes from traps and Breach effects?
- Can Border Guard prevent a hero from being destroyed by an opponent's battle effect?
- Does Tempest Warden join a 6-card draw, making 7 cards, when added to the newly drawn hand?
Thunderstone: Thornwood SiegeExpansion
- Does a monster defeated by Power Word: Kill still give you XP?
- How does the Thunderstone card in Thornwood Siege work, and does its Magic Attack +1 affect every player?
- When a hall refill triggers a Stalk effect after you defeat a monster, who is the active player that receives it?
- What new rules does Thunderstone: Thornwood Siege add?
- Does the Sidhe's trait apply to every disease you gain, and can you split them among players?
- Can a card's repeated ability, such as Highland Officer's, be applied more than once per turn?
- Are Dungeon Feature randomizers placed in the monster randomizer deck, and how are the features chosen?
- If you leave out an expansion, should you also remove its Dungeon Feature cards from the randomizer mix?
- Do Hero stacks and Basic cards count as Village cards for Raid and other Village-targeting effects?
- Can Power Word: Kill defeat a monster whose trait blocks defeat, such as a Bandit?
- Does Power Word: Kill need light, and does it end the turn?
- Is Power Word: Kill a Repeat Dungeon effect, and must you still choose a monster to fight afterward?
- Does one equipped Plaguesmiter stop every disease gained in a battle, or only one?
- Does Elite Militia's extra buy require destroying a Militia?
- If an effect refills the Hall without advancing monsters, what happens to the monsters already there?
- How much Attack do multiple Village Mobs give together?
- Can a hero whose attack applies only to Ranks 2 or 3 attack a Rank 1 monster?
- Does an edged weapon give the Nightblade extra Attack, and does Magical Aura change that?
- When Unicorn Steaks makes attack magic, does it apply to one attack source or to all of them?
- Can Power Word Kill's dungeon effect defeat several monsters, with the hero still fighting a fourth?
- If two Highland Officers trigger in the same dungeon phase, are their Militia-count draws resolved together?
- Does Power Word: Kill still let me battle another monster in the same turn?
- Does Veris Enchanter's Magic Attack count light from weapons and tokens as well as light items?
- When does the Guardian of Virulence's global effect apply during a Village visit?
- Do Siege Tower and Ballista destroy cards from the player's hand, and what if the player has none?
Thunderstone: Heart of DoomExpansion
- Does Heart of Doom destroy Monsters that are drawn after you enter the Dungeon?
- What happens to a Gem Treasure after you use it?
- Do Dryads count toward the three filled ranks needed in the Dungeon Hall?
- Can both dungeon effects on Swamp Provisions be used in the same turn?
- Does destroying Ulbrick's Armor for its Attack bonus also give every player a Disease?
- Does False Scout's ban on Dungeon Deck effects stop rearranging the hall?
- Can you reveal a Sidhe to pass a disease that a monster gave another player on their turn?
- Can a Highland Sergeant be bought repeatedly with leftover gold, and where does a hero bought by Highland Captain go?
- Do you need an equipped hero to attack the Heart of Doom with Thunderstones alone?
- Does defeating the Heart of Doom end the game, and can you chain treasures to get there?
- Can you use both destroy-for-attack Dungeon effects, from Isri Thrower and a Spear, in one battle?
- Does Jondul Seer ignore light penalties against all monsters, or only Undead?
- Does the Mournwater setting replace the extra rank that the Dryad adds to the Dungeon Hall?
- What does 'revealed monsters' mean in the Heart of Doom Guardian's global effect?
- Can a Dungeon Effect level up a hero that has already used an effect this turn?
- Can effects like Creeping Death or Banish move an Abyssal Darkspawn out of the dungeon hall?
- Does Jondul's Level 3 ignore-light-penalty effect apply to the whole party or only to Jondul?
- If a dungeon ability moves a monster with a Breach effect into Rank 1, does Breach trigger?
- Do Militia count as heroes for Spider Queen's breach that destroys all cards in the hero stack with the most cards?
- Does a Spoils effect count as buying a village card?
- How do you fight the Souleater, which requires discarding 3 cards when you choose it?
- Does the Heart of Doom global effect remove my monsters before the Divine's bonus resolves?
- Does the False Sergeant's global effect still apply if I defeat the False Sergeant?
- When a Basilisk makes me destroy two cards, are the destroyed cards removed before or after the battle?
- Can Isri destroy a weapon heavier than its Strength for the Attack bonus, and can Isri still equip a weapon?
- What does the Stone of Fate do when it is held and I attack the Heart of Doom?
- Does a Dark Necromancer's Dungeon-effect magic attack still count if she is excluded from the battle?
- Does the Village Robber's extra card apply when I take a Spoils card?