That's Not a Hat FAQ7 questions players ask · Updated Nov 19, 2026 · Full rulebookSearch questionsSetupHow to PlayAccept a GiftRefuse a GiftSetupWhy does using only one arrow colour make the game harder?How do you make the game more challenging with 3 players?How to PlayWhen you draw a gift from the centre pile, which card do you pass?Do you have to name a gift card exactly, or is a common-sense description enough?Accept a GiftCan you avoid penalty points by always accepting gifts and never refusing one?Can the game go on forever if every player remembers every card?Refuse a GiftWhat happens to the card when a gift is challenged and refused?