That's Not a Hat
← All That's Not a Hat questions
Can the game go on forever if every player remembers every card?
The rulebook says play continues until a refusal; players who met the loop report it and agree it is not a real problem. No official ruling.
- That's Not a Hat rulebook · Rulebook · Accept a Gift
- Clive Staples · Community · 2024-10-14
- EvilCheesypoof · Community · 2024-10-14
In theory, yes. The rulebook says play continues until a player refuses a gift, so if everyone keeps accepting and passing cards they remember, the cycle can go on. It is most likely with three players and the four distinct arrow backs. In practice someone refuses a gift or bluffs to break it, and repliers do not treat it as a design flaw.