RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage thumbnail

Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage FAQ

317 questions players ask · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · Full rulebook

General and EditionsComponents, Glossary and Sequence of PlaySetting Up the GameReinforcementsThe Strategy PhaseStrategy CardsStacking and SubordinationMovementNaval MovementInterceptionAvoiding Battles and PursuitBattlesRetreatsWithdrawalsElephantsConsuls and Consular ArmiesPolitical ControlSieges and SubjugationAttritionVictory Check PhaseSpecial AbilitiesStrategy Card List

General and Editions

  • Does the Phalanx edition of Hannibal change the rules?
  • Can the Valley Games 2nd edition rulebook be used with the original Avalon Hill board?
  • What material rule differences separate the Valley Games and Avalon Hill editions?

Components, Glossary and Sequence of Play

  • What does OC mean on a Strategy card's event text?
  • Which provinces count as Africa for battles fought there?
  • Can a player count or look at the opponent's CUs and stacks at any time?
  • Is the CU limit counted by tokens or by total value?
  • Are the Balearic Islands a province?
  • What do the round tokens with Roman general names on them do?
  • What does DE mean in Hannibal rules discussions?

Setting Up the Game

  • Do Carthaginian generals Mago and Gisgo start in play, or displaced?
  • How do displaced Carthaginian generals return to the map?
  • Does it matter whether Hanno and Hasdrubal are inside or outside their city at setup?
  • Where do Carthage's three friendly tribe markers go at setup, including the Bruttium marker?

Reinforcements

  • Can reinforcements go into Rome or an unbesieged walled city when an enemy army is outside it?
  • Where may Roman reinforcement CUs go in Italy: any Italian space, or only Rome and Roman generals?
  • Can reinforcements be placed in a walled city that is already under siege?
  • Where do Roman reinforcements go when Rome is besieged, or when no legal space is left?
  • When does Scipio Africanus arrive, and can a card bring him in earlier?
  • Can Scipio Africanus replace a dismissed Proconsul, or be elected Proconsul, before turn 6?
  • How many generals can each side have in play at once?
  • Can Scipio Africanus be placed inside a walled city such as Rome?
  • Can a Roman Proconsul be drawn again as one of the two new Consuls?
  • How long can a Roman Proconsul stay on the map, and can you change him each turn?
  • How does the Roman player choose a Proconsul and draw the new Consuls in the Reinforcement Phase?
  • If Rome is empty and no other space can make a five-CU stack, must all five Roman reinforcements go to Rome?
  • If no Roman general is on the map, how are Consuls chosen, and when does a Proconsul return?
  • Do Roman generals held in reserve count as being in Rome for a siege?
  • Does a displaced general need a Strategy card to come back onto the map?
  • Does an enemy general with no combat units stop reinforcements being placed in his space?
  • How many allies can Carthage have in Italy, and is the seven on the summary sheet correct?
  • Which Carthaginian reinforcement CUs come from Baetica and New Carthage, and does the summary sheet match?
  • Does Carthage keep its New Carthage and Baetica reinforcement CUs after Rome captures New Carthage, with no Carthaginian general in Spain?
  • Can Fabius Maximus be placed outside Italy, including as a replacement for a dismissed Proconsul?

The Strategy Phase

  • Who decides which side moves first in the Strategy Phase, and can Rome override it?
  • If Rome takes the first move with a Campaign card, must the card be used to move generals?
  • Can a Campaign card played to take the first move of the turn be used to place Political Control markers?

Strategy Cards

  • Can a Campaign card move a general and also place or flip Political Control markers in the same card play?
  • Can a card's Operation Number be turned into extra movement, or used to flip enemy PCs while a general moves?
  • Can a card's Operation Number be used to place or convert Political Control markers?
  • Does a card's event still happen if the card is played for its Operation Number?
  • Can strategy cards be played in the middle of a move or battle as Counter Events?
  • Can Hostile Tribes be played as a counter-event on the opponent's turn?
  • Can a strategy card be played like a battle card, and must it be declared at the start of the battle?
  • Can players look through the discard pile?
  • Can a discarded Strategy card be used again later in the game?
  • Can a card's event be skipped or banned on the last turn?
  • Can a Truce be played repeatedly so the deck reshuffles every turn?
  • What breaks a Truce, and can a siege roll be made while one is in effect?
  • Does Cato's counsel card stop units already in Italy or Africa from moving?
  • When Spy in Enemy Camp reveals up to half the cards, how is an odd number handled?
  • Who chooses which Roman PC markers are removed when Grain Shortage is played?
  • Does playing Siege Train as an event remove Carthage's siege penalty?
  • After a Carthaginian naval victory, can Rome still move by sea with a 3-Ops card?
  • Can a Raise Troops card place a CU with a general who is besieging a city?
  • How many generals can one Campaign card activate, and does the general's rating matter?
  • How many generals can make a naval move on one Campaign card?
  • Does a card giving a general 6 movement points add to his base movement?

Stacking and Subordination

  • Can a general change the army's commander after activation, when the army is attacked later and another general of equal rank is present?
  • Can the non-active player change the commanding general when his army is attacked or intercepts?
  • When an activated general moves into a space with an equal-rank general, who commands?
  • When two Consuls share a stack, which one commands, and can the Carthaginians change it?
  • Which general outranks which when two generals share a space, and do battle ratings matter?
  • What happens when a Proconsul moves into a Consul's space?
  • Can a lower-ranked general pick up CUs from a higher-ranked general in the same space?
  • Can another general pick up Hannibal when he moves?
  • How do you separate a subordinate in a commander's Holding Box, such as Mago under Hannibal, and move him off with CUs?
  • Is there a limit on how many CUs or generals can share a space?
  • Can CUs stay on the map without a general, and how few CUs can a Consul be left with?
  • When an enemy army enters a walled city with an unattended Roman stack, can some CUs go inside the walls and others stay outside?

Movement

  • When does a general become displaced?
  • Is a general displaced if he loses his last CUs in battle, and the retreat table then removes a CU he no longer has?
  • What happens to a general who loses all his combat units?
  • What happens to Carthage if Hannibal is displaced?
  • If CUs were left inside a walled city after an enemy army left, can they rejoin a general who later enters the space?
  • Does leaving or entering a walled city cost a movement point?
  • Does a general have to be inside a walled city on his own turn to protect the CUs there?
  • Can a general leave a walled city, or sail to or from one, when the city is not besieged?
  • How many CUs can a walled city hold?
  • Can a general with no CUs join a sortie from a besieged city to attack the besiegers?
  • Can two generals combine their attacks, or merge separately activated armies, against one enemy army?
  • Can two generals move to the same city in one turn and attack or besiege it?
  • During a Campaign card, can units moved by one general be picked up by another, and how far can they go in total?
  • Can a general drop CUs partway along its move and let the rest keep going?
  • Can an activated general with subordinates move more than 10 CUs, or get 15 CUs across one space in a single activation?
  • How many times can one army be activated in a Strategy Phase, including after it avoided battle earlier?
  • Must all interception and avoid-battle attempts be declared before any dice are rolled?
  • What is the order of steps when an army moves, is intercepted, avoids battle and fights?
  • Is attrition taken for crossing a mountain pass before the enemy can intercept?
  • Do hostile tribes stop movement, or only cause attrition?
  • Must a moving army stop when it enters a space holding only a hostile tribe marker?
  • Can an army keep moving after it has won a battle or been intercepted?
  • Can a Proconsul besiege a city before he is subordinated to a Consul leading the same army?

Naval Movement

  • Where are the ports on the Hannibal map, and can an army stop on a port symbol?
  • Can an army move by sea directly into a Walled City, and can it do so when the city is besieged?
  • Can a general sail to an intermediate port, pick up units and sail again on the same card?
  • How many Combat Units can sail by naval movement, with or without a Campaign card?
  • Can an army leave an unbesieged Walled City by sea when enemy armies are outside?
  • Can an army leave a besieged Walled City by sea?
  • Who rolls for naval movement, and are Roman sea moves rolled for too?
  • Can a Carthaginian army moving by sea be sunk, and what happens if it is?
  • Does the Syracuse −1 naval modifier stay after Rome retakes Syracuse?
  • Can an army cross the Strait of Massena without naval movement?
  • Do Naval Combat Table modifiers for both the departure port and the destination port apply?
  • What is the Naval Combat Table modifier when a general sails with one CU or with none?
  • Can a general sail out of a walled city, and can he be intercepted on the way?
  • Can an army that landed by sea in the battle space retreat to a friendly space if it loses?
  • Can an army that avoided battle in a port then make a sea move?
  • While Hanno Counsels Carthage is in effect, can Carthaginian armies still sail between African ports?

Interception

  • Can an army inside a Walled City intercept an enemy moving into an adjacent space?
  • Can an army inside a Walled City intercept an enemy army that has just left the city?
  • Do units already inside a Walled City join the battle when an enemy army intercepts into that space?
  • When an army intercepts into a space that already holds units, do those units fight in the battle?
  • If an interception and an Avoid Battle are both attempted against the same move, in what order are the rolls made?
  • Can one army both avoid battle and intercept in the same reaction phase?
  • If one army avoids battle while two others intercept the same moving army, who fights, and can the moving army back up?
  • After a successful interception, can the moving army decline battle and back up instead?
  • Can an army that backs up one space after a successful interception be intercepted again?
  • Is there a ten-CU limit on interception and on avoiding battle?
  • When a subordinate general intercepts, how many CUs must stay with the commanding general?
  • When more than one army intercepts the same move, do they combine into one army for battle, casualties and retreat?
  • Does a successful interception give the intercepting side an extra Battle Card?
  • After a successful interception, is the intercepting army the attacker or the defender?
  • After an interception that leads to battle, must the intercepting army retreat back to the space it came from?
  • Can an army intercept an enemy that moves into the interceptor's own space, or one that is already in place?
  • Does a failed interception lift a siege on a walled city?
  • On a Campaign card, must an interception battle be resolved before the second army moves?
  • Can an army use a failed interception against an enemy army again if that army moves to another adjacent space?
  • Can you intercept an attempt to Avoid Battle, a withdrawal or a retreat?
  • If an army is intercepted in a port after a sea move, can it back up across the sea?
  • Does an army in an adjacent space support a friendly army that is attacked?
  • When two Proconsul armies combine through interceptions, who commands the combined army?
  • Does an interception into a space with an enemy PC get the +1 if the friendly CUs there have just avoided battle?

Avoiding Battles and Pursuit

  • Can an opponent cancel a successful Avoid Battle roll?
  • Does an Avoid Battle roll use the Strategy or the Battle Rating?
  • Where can an army that avoids battle move?
  • Can a general leave some CUs behind when pursuing?
  • Does each pursuit step need a die roll, and when does the pursuit end?
  • After a successful avoid battle, can the active army keep moving, pursue, or intercept?
  • When an enemy enters a walled city space, how can units split between inside and outside, and can the outside part avoid battle?
  • Can a threatened army avoid battle by moving into a Walled City in its own space?
  • When an enemy army enters a walled city space, who decides between battle and siege?
  • Is a general without CUs displaced automatically when an enemy army enters his space?

Battles

  • Do Sicilia and Syracuse each give an ally in a battle anywhere on Sicily?
  • Do allies from Massilia, Transalpine Gaul or Liguria count in a battle in the neighbouring Gallic province?
  • Does Sicily count as part of Italy for ally battle cards?
  • How many Battle Cards do Rome's Italian allies and the Latium militia add?
  • Which provinces' allies add Battle Cards to a battle?
  • How many allied Battle Cards does Carthage get in a battle in Africa?
  • Who rolls for battle casualties, and do both sides lose the same number of CUs?
  • What happens when the attacker runs out of battle cards, and can it withdraw or roll for initiative?
  • If one side runs out of battle cards, can the other side still play its last card?
  • What happens to battle cards beyond a hand of 20?
  • Is there a limit on how many CUs can defend a battle, or how many an attacking general can bring?
  • After a battle, who rolls the Retreat Table, and does a Probe win change that roll?
  • Is there a Retreat Table modifier when the attacker loses by running out of battle cards?
  • If a Double Envelopment is matched, does its +2 Retreat Table modifier still apply?
  • Can a Probe card be played as a Double Envelopment?
  • Does a round in which a side has no cards count toward the attrition column?
  • Can a player deliberately lose a battle?
  • Can a force without a general avoid battle, withdraw, or gain the initiative?
  • Is a general displaced when battle attrition removes all of his CUs?
  • Are Battle Cards reshuffled after every battle?
  • When are battle-related Strategy Cards declared during a battle?
  • After a successful counterattack, who is the attacker in the next battle round?
  • Does a general who attacks with more battle cards win the battle at once?
  • Do subordinate generals add Battle Cards to a battle?
  • Can generals other than Scipio Africanus and Hannibal be eliminated when displaced?

Retreats

  • Can a defeated army retreat to any space, or only to one with a friendly PC?
  • Can a defeated army retreat into an empty space with no PC marker?
  • How far can a retreat go, and must the army take the shortest route?
  • Can a retreat end in a space with an enemy general who has no CUs?
  • Can a retreat end in a space that holds an enemy PC marker?
  • How many extra CUs does a retreating army lose on the way?
  • Is a retreating army's size counted before or after the losses taken on the retreat?
  • Can a retreat cross a mountain pass or strait, and where must an original attacker retreat first?
  • What happens to an army that has no legal retreat space?
  • Can a defeated army retreat into a besieged walled city?
  • If more units retreat into a walled city than it can hold, what happens?
  • What happens to an army that debarked by sea into the battle space and then loses?
  • Can an army that landed in a friendly space retreat back to it after losing an adjacent battle?
  • Is a general displaced when his last accompanying CU is lost on the retreat?
  • If a retreat strips a general's last CU but friendly CUs already stand in the destination, is he displaced?
  • Does a general with no CUs left still roll on the Retreat Table, and can a zero result displace him?
  • Can a general stay alone on the map after losing his last CU?
  • What happens when Hannibal or Scipio Africanus is displaced?
  • Who chooses which PC markers the losing side removes after a battle?
  • Does the 10-CU movement limit apply to a retreat?
  • Do Double Envelopment or Probe change the Retreat Table roll?

Withdrawals

  • Do failed withdrawal attempts count as battle rounds for battle casualties?
  • Does a successful withdrawal still cause battle casualties?
  • Does withdrawing from a battle count as losing it for political consequences?
  • Who may withdraw from a battle, and how does the withdrawal roll work?
  • Can the attacker withdraw in the first battle round without playing a card?
  • Can the attacker keep attempting to withdraw if earlier attempts fail?
  • Where can a withdrawing army not go: back where it came from, or into an enemy PC space?
  • Can an attacker with no battle cards left attempt to withdraw before conceding?

Elephants

  • When an Elephant Charge succeeds, does the Roman player discard before or after seeing his battle cards?
  • Can the Carthaginians make an Elephant Charge when they are defending?
  • Is Elephant Fright played before or after the elephant die roll?
  • What does Elephant Fright do to the elephants and the battle?
  • How many elephants can Carthage have in the game, and can they return after losses?
  • When an attrition or retreat result takes elephants, which CU must go first?

Consuls and Consular Armies

  • Can a Proconsul be drawn again as a Consul in the consular election?
  • Must Carthage roll for change of command when it attacks a Roman army holding both consuls?
  • Is a change of command roll made when a consular army successfully avoids battle?
  • Must Carthage roll for change of command when it intercepts a Roman army holding both consuls?
  • Can both new Roman consuls be placed together, and can they share one consular army?
  • Must a new consul be placed in a space with five CUs, and what if Rome is besieged?
  • Do the two consuls need 10 CUs together before they can split into separate armies?
  • Can a consular army with fewer than five CUs still move, and can it leave with all its CUs?
  • Can a consul voluntarily leave fewer than five CUs behind, for example to hide CUs in a besieged city?
  • Does a proconsul's army have the same five-CU minimum as a consul's?
  • Can a proconsul leave a stack with more CUs than the consul keeps?
  • When a consul and a proconsul share a space, who leads, and does the change of command roll include the proconsul?
  • Why does Carthage roll to change the Roman commander when two consuls share a battle?
  • When do displaced generals return to play?
  • Are the two Roman consuls at the start of the game subject to the consular army rules?
  • Can Rome have more than three generals on the map?
  • When a besieged consul sorties to join a relief force with another consul, who commands and is a change of command roll made?
  • Must Carthaginian generals keep five CUs to leave a walled city, as Roman consuls must?
  • After a campaign card attack forces a consul to retreat, can the forces split and re-merge in the same space?

Political Control

  • Can one Place PCs card flip enemy PC markers and also place new ones?
  • Can a space hold more than one PC marker, and how many can one card flip or place?
  • How do you flip an enemy PC marker, and can a general alone do it?
  • Can one card convert several enemy PC markers in one turn?
  • Can a player place PC markers in any empty space on the map?
  • Does a space stay under your control if enemy generals or CUs are also there?
  • Does a player control a province by having more PC markers than the opponent?
  • Do the provinces outside any region (Gallia Transalpina, Liguria, Massilia, Balearic Islands) give an ally only in battles in that province?
  • Does controlling Syracuse count toward a requirement that names only Sicilia?
  • What are all the ways PC markers get removed from the map?
  • How does political isolation trace a PC's supply line?
  • Does a friendly CU in a space stop that space's PC from being isolated?
  • Are Roman PCs isolated when their only link is other PCs, with no CU, city, tribe or port?
  • Are PCs in or linked to a friendly port ever isolated?
  • In what order are isolated PCs removed in the Political Isolation phase?
  • Do walled cities and tribes count as PC markers for control and supply?
  • How many PC markers does the losing side remove after a battle?

Sieges and Subjugation

  • Do you still have to siege Tarentum to play Traitor in Tarentum, and does the siege need 3 CUs?
  • Can a general besiege a walled city using CUs that are already in that space?
  • Can a Major Campaign or other campaign card direct more than one siege against the same walled city?
  • Must you roll the second time when Treachery Within the City allows two siege rolls?
  • If a card gives two siege rolls and the first loss drops the besieger below three CUs, are both results applied?
  • When a card gives two siege rolls, are the two dice added together?
  • Does a sortie need a separate activation of the CUs inside the walled city?
  • Can a sortie be intercepted?
  • Can CUs left inside a besieged walled city sortie on their own?
  • Can an army fight a battle and then siege or subjugate the same city on one strategy card?
  • Can a Campaign card let one general fight a battle and another general siege the same city?
  • Can a general that moves into an enemy walled city siege it with the same card?
  • Can a subordinate general with 3 CUs start a siege without the commanding general being activated?
  • Does each siege attempt need its own card play, and can one general keep besieging the same city?
  • How many CUs are needed to roll for a siege, and does losing CUs end the siege?
  • Is a siege lifted when the besieging army fails an interception, or when it leaves some CUs behind?
  • Does Pestilence apply to an army that attempted a siege but holds no siege points on the city?
  • Can units hidden inside a besieged walled city join a relief attack before any siege points exist?
  • Can an army move into a walled city the enemy controls, or does a city need a siege when no enemy units are inside?
  • When a siege succeeds, are political control markers removed as in a battle?
  • When a walled city falls to a siege, which units are eliminated?
  • Do I have to subjugate neutral tribes, and how do they affect movement?
  • Must the enemy units in a tribe's space be battled before the tribe can be subjugated, and can you skip the tribe?
  • When a tribe is subjugated, is its tile removed from the game permanently?
  • Is there a -1 modifier on Carthaginian siege rolls, and does anything cancel it?
  • Does the Carthaginian -1 siege modifier also apply to subjugation?
  • Can a moving army conduct a siege or subjugation after the enemy general avoids battle and it fails to pursue?
  • Can a subordinate detach 3 CUs to siege after the army has already fought a battle on the same Campaign card?

Attrition

  • What is the attrition modifier for crossing a non-Alps mountain pass: -1 or -2?
  • Is there an attrition modifier for crossing the Alps?
  • Do Pestilence or Storms at Sea change the attrition roll, and by how much?
  • Does an Epidemic result on the Attrition table make you lose an elephant?
  • After a battle, is there one attrition roll for both sides, or does each side roll?
  • Which attrition column applies after a battle: the CU count or the number of battle rounds?
  • When the attacker runs out of battle cards before a fifth round, which attrition column applies?
  • Which attrition column do you roll on when a card orders attrition without a battle, such as Epidemic?
  • Does Mercenaries Desert exempt generals from attrition, and how many attrition rolls apply to units in separate cities?
  • Are generals affected by attrition when attrition eliminates all of their CUs?
  • Does a successful withdrawal in the first round still cause battle attrition?
  • If an army crosses a mountain pass and then crosses back, does it roll attrition each time?
  • When an army crosses a mountain pass, do CUs picked up on the far side roll for attrition, and can they fight if intercepted there?
  • For winter attrition, is one attrition roll made for all spaces or one per space?

Victory Check Phase

  • Are the Roman and Carthaginian victory-point regions balanced at the start?
  • Is there a set number of provinces Hannibal needs to win?

Special Abilities

  • What is Fabius Maximus's special ability: does he withdraw or avoid battle on a die roll of 1-5?
  • Where is Fabius placed when there is no stack of five CUs in Italy?
  • Does Hanno need a Carthaginian CU with him to remove a Roman PC with his special ability?
  • Can Hanno leave Africa, or use his ability when dropped off as a subordinate or after Hasdrubal is activated?
  • Does Hannibal's special ability count as a Double Envelopment for the initiative?
  • If T. Longus is intercepted and then fights, is he still the original attacker for his counterattack?
  • Does Scipio Africanus's special siege ability require him to start on the walled city space?
  • What does Gisco's special ability to avoid battle or intercept on a 1-3 mean?
  • Can Paulus's counterattack ability stop the attacker from withdrawing?

Strategy Card List

  • When can the Ally Deserts card be played during a battle?
  • If Bad Weather sends Hannibal back across the Alps, does the mountain crossing cost stop him before he crosses?
  • Can Bad Weather be played against a naval move?
  • If Bad Weather stops a general, can the subordinate CUs keep moving?
  • Does a Truce stay in effect into the next turn, and is the Truce card reshuffled while its effect continues?
  • During a Truce, does Roman naval supremacy still block or roll on Carthaginian sea movement?
  • During a Truce, can you flip a Political Control marker, or move a CU onto an enemy PC space?
  • During a Truce, can a Roman army enter a blue Carthaginian tribe space?
  • During a Truce, can Carthage play Traitor in Tarentum if its general is already inside the city?
  • Does a Truce stop an army from subjugating tribes?
  • Does an event that only moves an army, such as a Campaign card used to sail units, break a Truce?
  • Does playing Hannibal Charms Italy break a Truce?
  • If Rome retakes Syracuse, does Carthage keep the naval -1 modifier from the Syracuse card?
  • Does the Senate Dismisses Proconsul card remove Scipio Africanus?
  • Can Hostile Tribes be played against an army that is about to leave its space?
  • Do cards marked 'If you use this card as an OC' trigger their event only when played for operation points?
  • Who discards, and which naval modifier is removed, when Philip V of Macedon is played twice?
  • Under Hanno Counsels Carthage, can Carthaginian CUs sail from one African port to another?
  • Can CUs enter Africa and then leave while Hanno Counsels Carthage is in play?
  • When must Storms at Sea be played against a Carthaginian naval move?
  • Are the Iberian Recruits placed together, or may they be split?
  • Does Force March 3 allow a naval move in addition to the normal move of that army?
  • What does Marhabal's Cavalry do, and when can it be played?
  • Can Treachery Within the City's extra siege roll be used for subjugating a tribe?
  • What is the Carthaginian Siege Train, and can it switch generals?