Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage FAQ
317 questions players ask · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · Full rulebook
General and Editions
Components, Glossary and Sequence of Play
- What does OC mean on a Strategy card's event text?
- Which provinces count as Africa for battles fought there?
- Can a player count or look at the opponent's CUs and stacks at any time?
- Is the CU limit counted by tokens or by total value?
- Are the Balearic Islands a province?
- What do the round tokens with Roman general names on them do?
- What does DE mean in Hannibal rules discussions?
Setting Up the Game
- Do Carthaginian generals Mago and Gisgo start in play, or displaced?
- How do displaced Carthaginian generals return to the map?
- Does it matter whether Hanno and Hasdrubal are inside or outside their city at setup?
- Where do Carthage's three friendly tribe markers go at setup, including the Bruttium marker?
Reinforcements
- Can reinforcements go into Rome or an unbesieged walled city when an enemy army is outside it?
- Where may Roman reinforcement CUs go in Italy: any Italian space, or only Rome and Roman generals?
- Can reinforcements be placed in a walled city that is already under siege?
- Where do Roman reinforcements go when Rome is besieged, or when no legal space is left?
- When does Scipio Africanus arrive, and can a card bring him in earlier?
- Can Scipio Africanus replace a dismissed Proconsul, or be elected Proconsul, before turn 6?
- How many generals can each side have in play at once?
- Can Scipio Africanus be placed inside a walled city such as Rome?
- Can a Roman Proconsul be drawn again as one of the two new Consuls?
- How long can a Roman Proconsul stay on the map, and can you change him each turn?
- How does the Roman player choose a Proconsul and draw the new Consuls in the Reinforcement Phase?
- If Rome is empty and no other space can make a five-CU stack, must all five Roman reinforcements go to Rome?
- If no Roman general is on the map, how are Consuls chosen, and when does a Proconsul return?
- Do Roman generals held in reserve count as being in Rome for a siege?
- Does a displaced general need a Strategy card to come back onto the map?
- Does an enemy general with no combat units stop reinforcements being placed in his space?
- How many allies can Carthage have in Italy, and is the seven on the summary sheet correct?
- Which Carthaginian reinforcement CUs come from Baetica and New Carthage, and does the summary sheet match?
- Does Carthage keep its New Carthage and Baetica reinforcement CUs after Rome captures New Carthage, with no Carthaginian general in Spain?
- Can Fabius Maximus be placed outside Italy, including as a replacement for a dismissed Proconsul?
The Strategy Phase
Strategy Cards
- Can a Campaign card move a general and also place or flip Political Control markers in the same card play?
- Can a card's Operation Number be turned into extra movement, or used to flip enemy PCs while a general moves?
- Can a card's Operation Number be used to place or convert Political Control markers?
- Does a card's event still happen if the card is played for its Operation Number?
- Can strategy cards be played in the middle of a move or battle as Counter Events?
- Can Hostile Tribes be played as a counter-event on the opponent's turn?
- Can a strategy card be played like a battle card, and must it be declared at the start of the battle?
- Can players look through the discard pile?
- Can a discarded Strategy card be used again later in the game?
- Can a card's event be skipped or banned on the last turn?
- Can a Truce be played repeatedly so the deck reshuffles every turn?
- What breaks a Truce, and can a siege roll be made while one is in effect?
- Does Cato's counsel card stop units already in Italy or Africa from moving?
- When Spy in Enemy Camp reveals up to half the cards, how is an odd number handled?
- Who chooses which Roman PC markers are removed when Grain Shortage is played?
- Does playing Siege Train as an event remove Carthage's siege penalty?
- After a Carthaginian naval victory, can Rome still move by sea with a 3-Ops card?
- Can a Raise Troops card place a CU with a general who is besieging a city?
- How many generals can one Campaign card activate, and does the general's rating matter?
- How many generals can make a naval move on one Campaign card?
- Does a card giving a general 6 movement points add to his base movement?
Stacking and Subordination
- Can a general change the army's commander after activation, when the army is attacked later and another general of equal rank is present?
- Can the non-active player change the commanding general when his army is attacked or intercepts?
- When an activated general moves into a space with an equal-rank general, who commands?
- When two Consuls share a stack, which one commands, and can the Carthaginians change it?
- Which general outranks which when two generals share a space, and do battle ratings matter?
- What happens when a Proconsul moves into a Consul's space?
- Can a lower-ranked general pick up CUs from a higher-ranked general in the same space?
- Can another general pick up Hannibal when he moves?
- How do you separate a subordinate in a commander's Holding Box, such as Mago under Hannibal, and move him off with CUs?
- Is there a limit on how many CUs or generals can share a space?
- Can CUs stay on the map without a general, and how few CUs can a Consul be left with?
- When an enemy army enters a walled city with an unattended Roman stack, can some CUs go inside the walls and others stay outside?
Movement
- When does a general become displaced?
- Is a general displaced if he loses his last CUs in battle, and the retreat table then removes a CU he no longer has?
- What happens to a general who loses all his combat units?
- What happens to Carthage if Hannibal is displaced?
- If CUs were left inside a walled city after an enemy army left, can they rejoin a general who later enters the space?
- Does leaving or entering a walled city cost a movement point?
- Does a general have to be inside a walled city on his own turn to protect the CUs there?
- Can a general leave a walled city, or sail to or from one, when the city is not besieged?
- How many CUs can a walled city hold?
- Can a general with no CUs join a sortie from a besieged city to attack the besiegers?
- Can two generals combine their attacks, or merge separately activated armies, against one enemy army?
- Can two generals move to the same city in one turn and attack or besiege it?
- During a Campaign card, can units moved by one general be picked up by another, and how far can they go in total?
- Can a general drop CUs partway along its move and let the rest keep going?
- Can an activated general with subordinates move more than 10 CUs, or get 15 CUs across one space in a single activation?
- How many times can one army be activated in a Strategy Phase, including after it avoided battle earlier?
- Must all interception and avoid-battle attempts be declared before any dice are rolled?
- What is the order of steps when an army moves, is intercepted, avoids battle and fights?
- Is attrition taken for crossing a mountain pass before the enemy can intercept?
- Do hostile tribes stop movement, or only cause attrition?
- Must a moving army stop when it enters a space holding only a hostile tribe marker?
- Can an army keep moving after it has won a battle or been intercepted?
- Can a Proconsul besiege a city before he is subordinated to a Consul leading the same army?
Naval Movement
- Where are the ports on the Hannibal map, and can an army stop on a port symbol?
- Can an army move by sea directly into a Walled City, and can it do so when the city is besieged?
- Can a general sail to an intermediate port, pick up units and sail again on the same card?
- How many Combat Units can sail by naval movement, with or without a Campaign card?
- Can an army leave an unbesieged Walled City by sea when enemy armies are outside?
- Can an army leave a besieged Walled City by sea?
- Who rolls for naval movement, and are Roman sea moves rolled for too?
- Can a Carthaginian army moving by sea be sunk, and what happens if it is?
- Does the Syracuse −1 naval modifier stay after Rome retakes Syracuse?
- Can an army cross the Strait of Massena without naval movement?
- Do Naval Combat Table modifiers for both the departure port and the destination port apply?
- What is the Naval Combat Table modifier when a general sails with one CU or with none?
- Can a general sail out of a walled city, and can he be intercepted on the way?
- Can an army that landed by sea in the battle space retreat to a friendly space if it loses?
- Can an army that avoided battle in a port then make a sea move?
- While Hanno Counsels Carthage is in effect, can Carthaginian armies still sail between African ports?
Interception
- Can an army inside a Walled City intercept an enemy moving into an adjacent space?
- Can an army inside a Walled City intercept an enemy army that has just left the city?
- Do units already inside a Walled City join the battle when an enemy army intercepts into that space?
- When an army intercepts into a space that already holds units, do those units fight in the battle?
- If an interception and an Avoid Battle are both attempted against the same move, in what order are the rolls made?
- Can one army both avoid battle and intercept in the same reaction phase?
- If one army avoids battle while two others intercept the same moving army, who fights, and can the moving army back up?
- After a successful interception, can the moving army decline battle and back up instead?
- Can an army that backs up one space after a successful interception be intercepted again?
- Is there a ten-CU limit on interception and on avoiding battle?
- When a subordinate general intercepts, how many CUs must stay with the commanding general?
- When more than one army intercepts the same move, do they combine into one army for battle, casualties and retreat?
- Does a successful interception give the intercepting side an extra Battle Card?
- After a successful interception, is the intercepting army the attacker or the defender?
- After an interception that leads to battle, must the intercepting army retreat back to the space it came from?
- Can an army intercept an enemy that moves into the interceptor's own space, or one that is already in place?
- Does a failed interception lift a siege on a walled city?
- On a Campaign card, must an interception battle be resolved before the second army moves?
- Can an army use a failed interception against an enemy army again if that army moves to another adjacent space?
- Can you intercept an attempt to Avoid Battle, a withdrawal or a retreat?
- If an army is intercepted in a port after a sea move, can it back up across the sea?
- Does an army in an adjacent space support a friendly army that is attacked?
- When two Proconsul armies combine through interceptions, who commands the combined army?
- Does an interception into a space with an enemy PC get the +1 if the friendly CUs there have just avoided battle?
Avoiding Battles and Pursuit
- Can an opponent cancel a successful Avoid Battle roll?
- Does an Avoid Battle roll use the Strategy or the Battle Rating?
- Where can an army that avoids battle move?
- Can a general leave some CUs behind when pursuing?
- Does each pursuit step need a die roll, and when does the pursuit end?
- After a successful avoid battle, can the active army keep moving, pursue, or intercept?
- When an enemy enters a walled city space, how can units split between inside and outside, and can the outside part avoid battle?
- Can a threatened army avoid battle by moving into a Walled City in its own space?
- When an enemy army enters a walled city space, who decides between battle and siege?
- Is a general without CUs displaced automatically when an enemy army enters his space?
Battles
- Do Sicilia and Syracuse each give an ally in a battle anywhere on Sicily?
- Do allies from Massilia, Transalpine Gaul or Liguria count in a battle in the neighbouring Gallic province?
- Does Sicily count as part of Italy for ally battle cards?
- How many Battle Cards do Rome's Italian allies and the Latium militia add?
- Which provinces' allies add Battle Cards to a battle?
- How many allied Battle Cards does Carthage get in a battle in Africa?
- Who rolls for battle casualties, and do both sides lose the same number of CUs?
- What happens when the attacker runs out of battle cards, and can it withdraw or roll for initiative?
- If one side runs out of battle cards, can the other side still play its last card?
- What happens to battle cards beyond a hand of 20?
- Is there a limit on how many CUs can defend a battle, or how many an attacking general can bring?
- After a battle, who rolls the Retreat Table, and does a Probe win change that roll?
- Is there a Retreat Table modifier when the attacker loses by running out of battle cards?
- If a Double Envelopment is matched, does its +2 Retreat Table modifier still apply?
- Can a Probe card be played as a Double Envelopment?
- Does a round in which a side has no cards count toward the attrition column?
- Can a player deliberately lose a battle?
- Can a force without a general avoid battle, withdraw, or gain the initiative?
- Is a general displaced when battle attrition removes all of his CUs?
- Are Battle Cards reshuffled after every battle?
- When are battle-related Strategy Cards declared during a battle?
- After a successful counterattack, who is the attacker in the next battle round?
- Does a general who attacks with more battle cards win the battle at once?
- Do subordinate generals add Battle Cards to a battle?
- Can generals other than Scipio Africanus and Hannibal be eliminated when displaced?
Retreats
- Can a defeated army retreat to any space, or only to one with a friendly PC?
- Can a defeated army retreat into an empty space with no PC marker?
- How far can a retreat go, and must the army take the shortest route?
- Can a retreat end in a space with an enemy general who has no CUs?
- Can a retreat end in a space that holds an enemy PC marker?
- How many extra CUs does a retreating army lose on the way?
- Is a retreating army's size counted before or after the losses taken on the retreat?
- Can a retreat cross a mountain pass or strait, and where must an original attacker retreat first?
- What happens to an army that has no legal retreat space?
- Can a defeated army retreat into a besieged walled city?
- If more units retreat into a walled city than it can hold, what happens?
- What happens to an army that debarked by sea into the battle space and then loses?
- Can an army that landed in a friendly space retreat back to it after losing an adjacent battle?
- Is a general displaced when his last accompanying CU is lost on the retreat?
- If a retreat strips a general's last CU but friendly CUs already stand in the destination, is he displaced?
- Does a general with no CUs left still roll on the Retreat Table, and can a zero result displace him?
- Can a general stay alone on the map after losing his last CU?
- What happens when Hannibal or Scipio Africanus is displaced?
- Who chooses which PC markers the losing side removes after a battle?
- Does the 10-CU movement limit apply to a retreat?
- Do Double Envelopment or Probe change the Retreat Table roll?
Withdrawals
- Do failed withdrawal attempts count as battle rounds for battle casualties?
- Does a successful withdrawal still cause battle casualties?
- Does withdrawing from a battle count as losing it for political consequences?
- Who may withdraw from a battle, and how does the withdrawal roll work?
- Can the attacker withdraw in the first battle round without playing a card?
- Can the attacker keep attempting to withdraw if earlier attempts fail?
- Where can a withdrawing army not go: back where it came from, or into an enemy PC space?
- Can an attacker with no battle cards left attempt to withdraw before conceding?
Elephants
- When an Elephant Charge succeeds, does the Roman player discard before or after seeing his battle cards?
- Can the Carthaginians make an Elephant Charge when they are defending?
- Is Elephant Fright played before or after the elephant die roll?
- What does Elephant Fright do to the elephants and the battle?
- How many elephants can Carthage have in the game, and can they return after losses?
- When an attrition or retreat result takes elephants, which CU must go first?
Consuls and Consular Armies
- Can a Proconsul be drawn again as a Consul in the consular election?
- Must Carthage roll for change of command when it attacks a Roman army holding both consuls?
- Is a change of command roll made when a consular army successfully avoids battle?
- Must Carthage roll for change of command when it intercepts a Roman army holding both consuls?
- Can both new Roman consuls be placed together, and can they share one consular army?
- Must a new consul be placed in a space with five CUs, and what if Rome is besieged?
- Do the two consuls need 10 CUs together before they can split into separate armies?
- Can a consular army with fewer than five CUs still move, and can it leave with all its CUs?
- Can a consul voluntarily leave fewer than five CUs behind, for example to hide CUs in a besieged city?
- Does a proconsul's army have the same five-CU minimum as a consul's?
- Can a proconsul leave a stack with more CUs than the consul keeps?
- When a consul and a proconsul share a space, who leads, and does the change of command roll include the proconsul?
- Why does Carthage roll to change the Roman commander when two consuls share a battle?
- When do displaced generals return to play?
- Are the two Roman consuls at the start of the game subject to the consular army rules?
- Can Rome have more than three generals on the map?
- When a besieged consul sorties to join a relief force with another consul, who commands and is a change of command roll made?
- Must Carthaginian generals keep five CUs to leave a walled city, as Roman consuls must?
- After a campaign card attack forces a consul to retreat, can the forces split and re-merge in the same space?
Political Control
- Can one Place PCs card flip enemy PC markers and also place new ones?
- Can a space hold more than one PC marker, and how many can one card flip or place?
- How do you flip an enemy PC marker, and can a general alone do it?
- Can one card convert several enemy PC markers in one turn?
- Can a player place PC markers in any empty space on the map?
- Does a space stay under your control if enemy generals or CUs are also there?
- Does a player control a province by having more PC markers than the opponent?
- Do the provinces outside any region (Gallia Transalpina, Liguria, Massilia, Balearic Islands) give an ally only in battles in that province?
- Does controlling Syracuse count toward a requirement that names only Sicilia?
- What are all the ways PC markers get removed from the map?
- How does political isolation trace a PC's supply line?
- Does a friendly CU in a space stop that space's PC from being isolated?
- Are Roman PCs isolated when their only link is other PCs, with no CU, city, tribe or port?
- Are PCs in or linked to a friendly port ever isolated?
- In what order are isolated PCs removed in the Political Isolation phase?
- Do walled cities and tribes count as PC markers for control and supply?
- How many PC markers does the losing side remove after a battle?
Sieges and Subjugation
- Do you still have to siege Tarentum to play Traitor in Tarentum, and does the siege need 3 CUs?
- Can a general besiege a walled city using CUs that are already in that space?
- Can a Major Campaign or other campaign card direct more than one siege against the same walled city?
- Must you roll the second time when Treachery Within the City allows two siege rolls?
- If a card gives two siege rolls and the first loss drops the besieger below three CUs, are both results applied?
- When a card gives two siege rolls, are the two dice added together?
- Does a sortie need a separate activation of the CUs inside the walled city?
- Can a sortie be intercepted?
- Can CUs left inside a besieged walled city sortie on their own?
- Can an army fight a battle and then siege or subjugate the same city on one strategy card?
- Can a Campaign card let one general fight a battle and another general siege the same city?
- Can a general that moves into an enemy walled city siege it with the same card?
- Can a subordinate general with 3 CUs start a siege without the commanding general being activated?
- Does each siege attempt need its own card play, and can one general keep besieging the same city?
- How many CUs are needed to roll for a siege, and does losing CUs end the siege?
- Is a siege lifted when the besieging army fails an interception, or when it leaves some CUs behind?
- Does Pestilence apply to an army that attempted a siege but holds no siege points on the city?
- Can units hidden inside a besieged walled city join a relief attack before any siege points exist?
- Can an army move into a walled city the enemy controls, or does a city need a siege when no enemy units are inside?
- When a siege succeeds, are political control markers removed as in a battle?
- When a walled city falls to a siege, which units are eliminated?
- Do I have to subjugate neutral tribes, and how do they affect movement?
- Must the enemy units in a tribe's space be battled before the tribe can be subjugated, and can you skip the tribe?
- When a tribe is subjugated, is its tile removed from the game permanently?
- Is there a -1 modifier on Carthaginian siege rolls, and does anything cancel it?
- Does the Carthaginian -1 siege modifier also apply to subjugation?
- Can a moving army conduct a siege or subjugation after the enemy general avoids battle and it fails to pursue?
- Can a subordinate detach 3 CUs to siege after the army has already fought a battle on the same Campaign card?
Attrition
- What is the attrition modifier for crossing a non-Alps mountain pass: -1 or -2?
- Is there an attrition modifier for crossing the Alps?
- Do Pestilence or Storms at Sea change the attrition roll, and by how much?
- Does an Epidemic result on the Attrition table make you lose an elephant?
- After a battle, is there one attrition roll for both sides, or does each side roll?
- Which attrition column applies after a battle: the CU count or the number of battle rounds?
- When the attacker runs out of battle cards before a fifth round, which attrition column applies?
- Which attrition column do you roll on when a card orders attrition without a battle, such as Epidemic?
- Does Mercenaries Desert exempt generals from attrition, and how many attrition rolls apply to units in separate cities?
- Are generals affected by attrition when attrition eliminates all of their CUs?
- Does a successful withdrawal in the first round still cause battle attrition?
- If an army crosses a mountain pass and then crosses back, does it roll attrition each time?
- When an army crosses a mountain pass, do CUs picked up on the far side roll for attrition, and can they fight if intercepted there?
- For winter attrition, is one attrition roll made for all spaces or one per space?
Victory Check Phase
Special Abilities
- What is Fabius Maximus's special ability: does he withdraw or avoid battle on a die roll of 1-5?
- Where is Fabius placed when there is no stack of five CUs in Italy?
- Does Hanno need a Carthaginian CU with him to remove a Roman PC with his special ability?
- Can Hanno leave Africa, or use his ability when dropped off as a subordinate or after Hasdrubal is activated?
- Does Hannibal's special ability count as a Double Envelopment for the initiative?
- If T. Longus is intercepted and then fights, is he still the original attacker for his counterattack?
- Does Scipio Africanus's special siege ability require him to start on the walled city space?
- What does Gisco's special ability to avoid battle or intercept on a 1-3 mean?
- Can Paulus's counterattack ability stop the attacker from withdrawing?
Strategy Card List
- When can the Ally Deserts card be played during a battle?
- If Bad Weather sends Hannibal back across the Alps, does the mountain crossing cost stop him before he crosses?
- Can Bad Weather be played against a naval move?
- If Bad Weather stops a general, can the subordinate CUs keep moving?
- Does a Truce stay in effect into the next turn, and is the Truce card reshuffled while its effect continues?
- During a Truce, does Roman naval supremacy still block or roll on Carthaginian sea movement?
- During a Truce, can you flip a Political Control marker, or move a CU onto an enemy PC space?
- During a Truce, can a Roman army enter a blue Carthaginian tribe space?
- During a Truce, can Carthage play Traitor in Tarentum if its general is already inside the city?
- Does a Truce stop an army from subjugating tribes?
- Does an event that only moves an army, such as a Campaign card used to sail units, break a Truce?
- Does playing Hannibal Charms Italy break a Truce?
- If Rome retakes Syracuse, does Carthage keep the naval -1 modifier from the Syracuse card?
- Does the Senate Dismisses Proconsul card remove Scipio Africanus?
- Can Hostile Tribes be played against an army that is about to leave its space?
- Do cards marked 'If you use this card as an OC' trigger their event only when played for operation points?
- Who discards, and which naval modifier is removed, when Philip V of Macedon is played twice?
- Under Hanno Counsels Carthage, can Carthaginian CUs sail from one African port to another?
- Can CUs enter Africa and then leave while Hanno Counsels Carthage is in play?
- When must Storms at Sea be played against a Carthaginian naval move?
- Are the Iberian Recruits placed together, or may they be split?
- Does Force March 3 allow a naval move in addition to the normal move of that army?
- What does Marhabal's Cavalry do, and when can it be played?
- Can Treachery Within the City's extra siege roll be used for subjugating a tribe?
- What is the Carthaginian Siege Train, and can it switch generals?