Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
← All Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage questions
Does a successful withdrawal still cause battle casualties?
A designer ruling covers the opening-withdrawal case, and the rulebook's 16.2 wording is clarified by it for that case only.
- Simon7itch · Designer · 2009-09-02
- Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage rulebook · Rulebook · 16.2 A Successful Withdrawaldisagrees
- John_B_Firer · Community · 2009-09-05disagrees
It depends on when it succeeds. If the attacker's withdrawal succeeds before any battle round, the designer ruled that no battle casualty roll is made. Once rounds have been played, battle casualties are rolled normally, but the Retreat Table is not used (16.2). The designer's ruling takes precedence over the rulebook's general wording here.