RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Hannibal & Hamilcar thumbnail

Hannibal & Hamilcar FAQ

411 questions players ask · Updated Nov 17, 2026 · Full rulebook

General and ComponentsSetup and Sequence of PlayReinforcementsStrategy CardsStrategy Card NotesStacking and SubordinationMovementNaval MovementLand InterceptionAvoiding Land Battles and PursuitLand BattlesRetreats and WithdrawalsElephantsConsuls and Consular ArmiesPolitical ControlSieges and SubjugationAttritionVictorySpecial AbilitiesOptional Rules

General and Components

  • Who holds Naval Supremacy in Hamilcar, and is it a Politically Significant space?
  • How many rounds can a naval battle last in Hamilcar?
  • Do I need the upgrade pack or new rulebooks to play Hannibal and Hamilcar?
  • Do the revised Hannibal and Hamilcar card wordings change how the game plays?
  • Is Claudius Caudex a 3/3 or a 3/2 General?
  • Can Claudius Pulcher be used in Hannibal?
  • Where on the Miat can a third PC be placed?
  • Which General cards changed between the Anniversary and Golden Geek editions?
  • Which Gisgo is the upgrade: the one that intercepts on a 1-2, or the one that receives two Tactic Cards in a Naval Battle?
  • Are Hamilcar and Hamilcar Barca the same general?
  • Does the circled number on a General card show strategy or battle rating?
  • Is Lipara part of Sicily for province purposes?
  • Is 'Sicily' on a card the province or the wider region?
  • Does a walled city's capacity limit CUs and supply trains separately?
  • Can Hasdrubal's army combine with Gisgo's army before Carthage loses a battle?

Setup and Sequence of Play

  • How many turns does the Campaign: Iberia scenario last, and where does it end?
  • Which generals does Carthage start with in the first Hannibal scenario, and where do they begin?
  • Which Carthaginian generals are used in the Hannibal scenarios, and are the elephant-icon generals used without the Additional Generals option?
  • Is Flaccus used in Hannibal or Hamilcar?
  • Is P. Cornelius Scipio used in Hamilcar?
  • Can a card's Operation Points be spent entirely on placing PCs in the Miat, and can several PCs be placed that way?
  • Can a player activate more than one general with a single strategy card?
  • What happens if the Iberia scenario runs out of strategy cards with only the base deck?
  • Which strategy cards does the Iberia campaign scenario use?
  • Who chooses which side goes first each turn?
  • Can a general activated more than once in a round still move again in the same turn?
  • Does the Price of Failure and Sun of Macedon expansion cards go into the deck from the start?
  • How do I tell which version of a leader or strategy card belongs to Hannibal and which to Hamilcar?
  • Why are there two Syracuse city tiles?
  • Which side of the board is used for the Hannibal and Hamilcar games?
  • How do you match Generals with the same name to their setup tokens?
  • Is Bomilcar used in scenarios 6 to 9 when he is absent from the Carthaginian setup?

Reinforcements

  • Do Xanthippus and Hamilcar Barca leave the board at the end of each turn?
  • When can Xanthippus or Hamilcar Barca be hired in Hamilcar?
  • Is Flaccus removed from play when new Consuls are elected in Hamilcar?
  • Does Duilius need Roman War Chest OPs to become Proconsul?
  • Are generals drawn from the Carthaginian pool in Hamilcar chosen or drawn randomly?
  • Does Carthage get new generals during the game?
  • Can Philippos be placed in a port that holds an enemy army, and does a battle start?
  • How does Philippos enter the game?
  • Are a Roman general or consul removed from play permanently, or can they return?
  • Can the same Consul be elected again in the following turn?
  • Can Carthaginian reinforcement generals that are not on the turn track be drawn before their turn?
  • How many generals does Carthage receive each turn in the Hamilcar game?
  • Are Strategy cards that bring reinforcements onto the map treated as Reinforcement Events even without the helmet icon?
  • Does Manpower Shortage block the Dictator event (card 80) from being played?
  • Can Rome receive reinforcements while Roma is under siege?
  • Can Allied Auxiliaries place CUs in a besieged walled city, or with a besieged general?
  • Where can newly elected Consuls be placed, given that the Golden Geek and 20th Anniversary rulebooks differ?
  • Can a newly elected consul be placed in Rome when no Roman CUs are there?
  • How many Roman CUs must stand in a stack for consular reinforcements, and must each consul have its own stack?
  • When does a displaced general return to play?
  • Can Carthaginian generals eliminated in battle return to the game later?
  • Can a general recruit a CU in a province it does not control at reinforcement?
  • Where can Carthage place its reinforcement CUs when Carthago Nova is Roman-controlled?
  • Does Carthage keep five generals if Hannibal dies?
  • Where can reinforcements be placed in the Iberia and Italia scenarios?
  • Can reinforcements be placed in a besieged Walled City, or in one an enemy general occupies?
  • Can Carthage place a displaced General in a space where another Carthaginian General already stands?
  • Can a Roman proconsul be moved to another 5-CU stack before consuls are placed?
  • Can reinforcements be placed in a walled city where an enemy general sits but no siege points have been scored?

Strategy Cards

  • Which provinces does the Hostile Tribes card cover, and does a province stay hostile after it is conquered?
  • What does it mean to play Hostile Tribes as a Counter Event?
  • Is a space with a neutral Tribe hostile for the Hostile Tribes card?
  • Does adding optional Strategy Cards to the deck reshuffle it and end Cato's or Hanno's effect?
  • What does the Rules Used note '8 Strategy Cards' in Tutorial 1 mean?
  • Does a reserve battle card played as a probe keep the probe's conditions?
  • When is a Strategy Card considered finished for Scipio's Roman Diplomat flip?
  • What does the infantry or mobilization icon in the upper corner of a Strategy Card do?
  • Can one card's Operation Points both move a General and convert an enemy PC under him?
  • What does the R symbol at the bottom of some strategy cards mean?
  • What are the Major Campaign and Minor Campaign cards, and do they let a side go first?
  • Why would you discard a card instead of playing it in the strategy phase?
  • Can a CU already moved in a Major Campaign be moved again by another general?
  • Can a Counter Event card be played against another Counter Event card or cancel a campaign?
  • Can a truce be broken by playing an event that removes your own siege points?
  • Can a 3-OP Strategy Card used to raise troops also provide its OP or trigger its event?
  • Does a Counter Event card that shows the truce symbol end a truce?
  • Are Event cards discarded after use?
  • Can you keep unused Strategy Cards for a later turn?
  • Can the three OPs of a card used for Training or Shipbuilding be split among actions?

Strategy Card Notes

  • Which General becomes Dictator when the Hannibal Dictator card (#80) is played?
  • What happens to the Archimede token and the Citadel when Syracusae is conquered?
  • If Rome conquers Syracusae, is Carthage's naval bonus token removed?
  • Who decides whether Punic Faith cancels a Roman event?
  • Does the Traitor in the City event skip the second die roll?
  • How are Storms at Sea losses assigned among warships, CUs and Supply Trains?
  • Does the Good Omen card's plus or minus 2 apply to any die roll?
  • When are Cruel Sea and Storm at Sea applied during a multi-leg naval move?
  • What marker does the Citadel card (#91) use?
  • Can the Citadel card (91) be placed in a city that already has siege points?
  • Does storm attrition from Storms at Sea (#129) hit only CUs, or other units too?
  • Can the Dictator card (#136) be used for its OPs, shipbuilding or adding a CU?
  • Does Bad Omens apply attrition to warships in a naval battle?
  • How are Mercenary PCs removed from the Miat card (card 100), and does removing them replace a card play?
  • Does Good Omen (card 84) modify siege die rolls?
  • Does the Hostile Tribe event work on a Carthaginian friendly tribe?
  • How many PCs does the Naval Raid card (108) remove, and can the removals be split?
  • Can Gades switch to Roman control under card 71?
  • What happens to a Carthaginian army inside Syracusae when Hiero allies with Rome?
  • Can any general conduct the move in the Hidden Cove strategy card?
  • How do campaign cards let generals move by sea, and how many CUs can they carry?
  • Can two generals on a campaign card move together to get around the 10-CU stack limit?
  • Does Carthage still place a PC on Hidden Cove when the naval move is cancelled by Bad Weather?
  • Is the Siege Train an event card?
  • Do Revolt events flip or remove walled city PCs?
  • Does Maharbal's Cavalry cancel the automatic initiative of Double Envelopment?
  • Does Mare Nostrum need an empty enemy port, or just an enemy-controlled one?
  • If Punic Faith cancels Forced March, can the general still move?
  • Do Siege Train units count as a CU for stacking capacity, and when is the Carthaginian Siege Train destroyed?
  • How can the Carthaginian Siege Train be removed from the map once placed?
  • If Rome retakes Syracuse after Carthage allied with it, does Carthage keep the Syracuse naval bonus?
  • Under the Syracuse Allies card, are CUs and generals in Syracuse eliminated, or only if the city is under siege?
  • During a Truce, can a player move through an enemy PC or CU space?
  • Can Bad Weather be played after a general reaches a third space, and does it change anything over an earlier play?
  • Can Revolt (card 87) be played near a Carthaginian-friendly tribe or walled city inside a Roman province?
  • If Carthage is allied with Syracuse and Rome retakes the city, is the alliance kept, and does the naval bonus still apply?
  • Must an army already be in Tarentum for the Traitor in Tarentum card to apply?

Stacking and Subordination

  • Who commands when two generals of equal rank share a space?
  • Which general commands a stack of two equal-rank generals when it is attacked?
  • How is leader rank decided between generals?
  • When two armies share a space during a reaction, do they merge into one stack right away?
  • Is there a limit on how many CUs can stack in one space?
  • What happens to subordinate generals when their commander's army is wiped out?
  • Can a proconsul take CUs from a consular army and leave the consuls with five?
  • When an evading army holds two consuls, must the Roman player change command to a particular consul?
  • Can a lesser-ranked general move through a space holding a higher-ranked general?
  • Can subordinate generals be left behind, activated separately, and take CUs with them?

Movement

  • Is a General displaced when all his CUs are lost to attrition, storms or the Land Battle Casualties roll?
  • Is a General displaced when all his CUs are lost to the Retreat Die roll?
  • Can an army leave a walled city when enemy CUs are outside it?
  • Which mountain passes are the Alps passes, and how are they marked on the map?
  • Which die modifier applies when an army crosses a mountain pass?
  • Can two generals combine under one campaign card and then attack together?
  • Can a general pick up CUs after already moving, and how far can they go?
  • Can a moving general pick up only some CUs from a space shared with a higher-ranked friendly general?
  • Can a general's subordinate units keep moving under a second general in one campaign card, and does the four-space limit cover the whole card?
  • After a battle, can a second general move into the space and pick up the army's CUs under a campaign event?
  • Can a subordinate general siege the same space after his army fought a battle under the same campaign event?
  • Does the Strait of Messana block land movement when Carthage controls only one of the two spaces?
  • Can a general or army move inside or outside a friendly walled city without spending movement, and who decides its position?
  • How many CUs can fit inside a Walled City?
  • Can CUs inside a Walled City move out during your own turn?
  • Can a force enter an enemy-held walled city without besieging it?
  • Can an army pass through a space containing an enemy walled city?
  • Can an army move through a tribe space without completing subjugation?
  • Can a 3-CU consular army overrun a single enemy CU?
  • Can an army keep moving after it wins a battle, including one that an interception started?
  • Can a lone general with no CUs try to avoid battle before an enemy army displaces him?
  • What happens to Scipio Africanus or Hannibal if displaced in the classic scenario?
  • Can I split a stack and send two generals in different directions with one card?
  • Do elephants count toward the 10-CU movement limit?

Naval Movement

  • Which Strategy cards allow Naval Movement, and how many CUs can an army carry by sea?
  • How many legs of Naval Movement can a General make in one activation in Hamilcar?
  • What is the maximum size of a Roman fleet in Hamilcar, and what limits its growth?
  • In Hannibal, can a Major or Minor Campaign card, or a two-ship card, allow two naval movements?
  • How many generals can make a naval move when activated by one campaign card?
  • How many PCs does the loser remove after a naval battle?
  • After a naval interception battle, can the intercepting fleet keep moving, and who is active if it lands in an enemy space?
  • Does the Mare Tyrrhenum interception ban stop a fleet from being intercepted along its whole path?
  • Can a fleet be intercepted in the port where it embarks?
  • Can a naval tactic card bring in ships that are not part of the battle?
  • Can Carthage intercept a fleet from Carthage when the MIAT is not warlike?
  • If the non-active player skips a possible naval interception, does the mover take Naval Supremacy?
  • When is a general displaced in a naval move or naval battle?
  • How is an intercepting fleet built and tracked in Hamilcar?
  • Can a naval move go directly into a Walled City while some CUs stay outside?
  • Can a naval move into a Walled City space be intercepted?
  • Does a naval battle round continue for a player who has no ready warships?
  • After winning a naval interception, can the moving fleet keep moving or must it stop?
  • Can an army mix land and naval movement in Hamilcar, and how many points can it spend on naval?
  • Is naval interception the only way to start a naval battle?
  • Can a naval move be intercepted by land forces, or a land move by naval interception?
  • Can the initiative player's tactic card end a naval battle early?
  • Does a naval army overrun a lone enemy CU after sailing in?
  • Can a general in a besieged city intercept once the siege is lifted?
  • Are there modifiers on naval interception rolls in Hamilcar?
  • Can an intercepting fleet pick up a higher-ranked general along its route?
  • When a fleet loses a naval battle, where do its units go back to?
  • Can Skilled Crews return a warship that Shoals has spent?
  • Must a sea lane connect the interception location with the intercepting general's station?
  • Which battle rating does Kyklo use in a naval battle when the commanding general is not an admiral?
  • Does the Evasion card cancel a naval interception only if you fail the die roll first?
  • Does a card that cancels a naval interception stop the moving unit from continuing?
  • Can an intercepted naval move back up one space?
  • How are port values and modifiers applied in the naval movement table?
  • After a naval move, how many movement points remain for the general?
  • Can an army move one land space as part of a naval move that costs three movement points?
  • Can a fleet pick up troops at a port mid-naval move and keep sailing?
  • Does naval interception into a friendly space holding your PC need an interception roll?
  • Can a naval move enter a friendly unbesieged city while enemy CUs are camped outside?
  • Can warships be eliminated, not just flipped to their spent side?
  • When do warships become spent?
  • Are thunder symbols used only with the Cruel Sea card?
  • Do storm symbols on sea lanes matter only when the Cruel Sea card is played?
  • Does the naval table's blue dot apply to a fleet carrying more than one CU?
  • Does a naval move require a die roll for Rome, and can a fleet siege a walled city immediately on arrival?
  • Can a fleet sail into an unbesieged enemy walled city outside the walls and start a siege?
  • How are ships allocated when a fleet attempts several naval interceptions?
  • Can a fleet fight a naval battle or intercept without a General in Hamilcar?
  • Does Pulcher's special ability still allow four spaces of naval movement under the seamanship rules?
  • When several generals in a port could make a naval interception, can the player choose which one does?
  • After an inconclusive naval battle, where does the passive player end up?

Land Interception

  • Can a subordinate consul intercept with fewer than five CUs, leaving the other consul below five?
  • If a fleet crosses several sea lanes, can each leg be intercepted by land forces?
  • When an interception makes the other army avoid battle, does the intercepting army still complete its move?
  • Does an army that already occupies a space give the intercepting army a bonus battle card?
  • Can an army that successfully avoided battle join an interception declared from its original space in the same card play?
  • Does a failed interception cost anything, and can the defender still avoid battle against that army?
  • Do an intercepting army and the friendly CUs already in the intercepted space fight together?
  • Does an overrun happen before or after an interception in the same space?
  • Can a second general intercept the intercepting army to join a battle caused by an interception?
  • Can an intercepting general bring only part of his army to an interception?
  • When a subordinate general makes a land interception, whose Battle Rating is used?
  • Can an army inside a walled city intercept an adjacent army?
  • Can an army intercept a sortie made from inside a walled city?
  • Can an army intercept into a space that holds non-moving enemy CUs?
  • Can two armies both try to intercept into the same space?
  • Can an army intercept a retreating General and his army?
  • When an intercept and an avoid-battle reaction are both possible, which is resolved first?

Avoiding Land Battles and Pursuit

  • Does moving into a walled city in the same space cost extra movement points?
  • If an army avoids battle but leaves one CU with its General behind, must the attacker fight?
  • Can a defending army move into its walled city when an enemy army enters the space?
  • Can a force of CUs with no General avoid battle, intercept, or move into a walled city, or can it only retreat?
  • Can an army split its CUs between a walled city and the open space, then avoid battle with the part outside?
  • Can an army avoid a land battle by making a naval move?
  • If an army avoids battle and a friendly general intercepts the attacker, and both succeed, what happens?
  • If an army avoiding battle must leave behind CUs above the 10-CU limit, must the attacker fight them?
  • If Scipio Africanus is displaced, is he removed from the game?
  • Can an army drop CUs off while avoiding a land battle?
  • Can a besieging army avoid a land battle, and can it return by naval movement afterward?
  • Does an enemy army's move stop when it enters a space holding a lone enemy General with no CUs?

Land Battles

  • Can Hamilcar use battle cards instead of dice for land battles?
  • In Hamilcar 1.0, do Romans get extra battle cards in Latium or is there a cap on allied battle cards?
  • When two consular armies attack the same enemy space, do all their CUs fight in one battle?
  • What die level does each army start with in a Hamilcar land battle?
  • Which general's Battle Rating is rolled when changing initiative, intercepting, or retreating?
  • Does Latium count toward Rome's Italian ally battle cards?
  • Which general fights the land battle after an admiral-led naval move lands?
  • Can two generals activated by one campaign card fight a battle together and add their battle cards?
  • If the winning army is reduced to no CUs by casualties, is it still the winner?
  • Is there an official battle-card-less land combat system?
  • How many battle cards does each side receive for allies in a land battle, and does the battle's location matter?
  • When a battle is fought, can the defender refuse to match the attacker's battle card and end the battle?
  • Who commands a combined army when two generals fight a battle together?
  • In a battle after an interception, which side is the attacker?
  • If a defending stack has more than 10 CUs, do all of them fight?
  • How many political control markers does the loser remove after a land battle?
  • Do CUs left inside a walled city fight without a general, and can they join a relief attack?
  • How do retreat die symbols determine CU losses?
  • Can a general who already fought a land battle be activated again on a later strategy card?
  • Can a player play more than one event card before or during a battle?
  • Can a general move with one general and attack with another in the same activation?
  • Must the defender match the attacker's battle card, or lose the battle?
  • After a successful counterattack, who is the attacker?
  • Is there a limit on how often a defender can counterattack?
  • Does the defender automatically gain initiative after a counterattack?
  • Does an elephant unit need its own battle card, and who wins if a player cannot play a battle card?
  • Does a force with no General get battle cards for a general's rating or for allies?
  • When is the change of command roll for a consular army made?
  • Do allies help a land battle only in provinces their side controls?

Retreats and Withdrawals

  • Is an attacking General who withdraws and loses all his CUs to the casualties roll displaced?
  • If a defending army retreats out of reach of the second attacking army, can it still be attacked?
  • Does sea withdrawal need both an Admiral and Naval Supremacy?
  • Can an army retreat by sea into an enemy-controlled port in Hamilcar?
  • How do the retreat dice and last played battle card determine retreat losses?
  • If a retreating army enters an enemy PC or non-friendly tribe, does it lose an extra CU even if a friendly army is already there?
  • After a land interception, who starts the battle with initiative, and when can the winner of initiative withdraw?
  • Can a retreating army retreat into an empty field that has no PC marker?
  • Can an original attacker withdraw to its starting space if that space holds an enemy Political Control marker?
  • Can an intercepting army retreat to a different space than the one it entered the battle from?
  • Can a force that attacked by sea retreat back across the sea after losing?
  • Is withdrawing after winning the initiative roll a valid tactic?
  • Can a sortie attacker disengage to an adjacent space instead of returning to the city?
  • Can a retreating army that landed by sea retreat into a friendly Walled City in the battle space?
  • Can a retreating army overrun a lone enemy CU to avoid the extra retreat loss?
  • Can a retreating force go into a friendly Walled City in a space with no enemy present?
  • What happens to a general who loses all his CUs in a battle but is not displaced?
  • Do you lose the battle automatically if your withdrawal attempt fails?
  • Can the defender attempt to withdraw from a land battle?
  • If your withdrawal attempt fails, can you try to withdraw again?
  • If a general is displaced, are his subordinates displaced too?
  • Can a retreating force retreat into or through a space holding fewer friendly CUs?
  • What is the difference between retreat roll casualties and retreat losses?
  • Does a general become displaced if his CUs are lost to the land battle die roll?
  • Can a losing army retreat into a space where the enemy is besieging a walled city?
  • Can a withdrawing army move more than ten CUs into the adjacent space?
  • When is a General displaced after his army loses units?

Elephants

  • Is the Elephant Fright alternative rule a separate card in the Hannibal deck?
  • Is the Elephant charge die roll resolved before or after Battle Cards are dealt?
  • Does a failed elephant charge against Roman CUs without a general cost Carthage a battle card?
  • Can Rome or Carthage place elephants as ordinary reinforcements?
  • Do Carthaginian elephants count as CUs for battle cards and elephant charges?
  • Are Carthaginian elephant counters limited?

Consuls and Consular Armies

  • After a consul or proconsul is replaced in the Roman reinforcement phase, does the old one return to the general pool or get eliminated?
  • Where are newly elected consuls placed when no space has a stack of five Roman CUs?
  • Can a Roman Consul who cannot leave Italia be placed outside Italia during Reinforcements?
  • Do the proconsul rules apply to Scipio Africanus, and is there a penalty if his troops are short?
  • Can a consul move with no CUs?
  • How many Roman CUs must be in a space to place a consul, and can one join a stack with fewer?
  • Does an Aristocratic Roman Consul remove its PCs only when it is displaced?
  • If two Admiral Roman Consuls are drawn or elected in one turn, can both carry out Naval Reforms?
  • Can an eliminated Proconsul ever come back?
  • In Hamilcar, how does Rome get back a Consul who was eliminated?
  • Can two consuls in one army split up if one would be left with fewer than five CUs?
  • What is the minimum size a Consular Army must keep in Hamilcar?
  • What happens when Rome runs out of Roman generals for consuls?
  • Can a Consul's army move through or join another consular army in the same space without stopping?
  • Can a consular army with fewer than five CUs still move, fight, or besiege?
  • If a consular army with fewer than five CUs meets friendly CUs in a space, must it take them into the army?
  • Must Rome keep a proconsul's army at five CUs during reinforcement?
  • Are consuls returned to the pool before the random draw for next turn's consuls, so they can be drawn again?
  • Can a retiring consul become a proconsul in the Golden Geek edition?
  • Can one consul leave Italy when the other consul must stay with five CUs?
  • Can Scipio Africanus enter the game before turn 6 or be elected consul?
  • Can a proconsul who enters a besieged city with a consul perform the siege?
  • When a consul is appointed Proconsul, does he move to the old Proconsul's space?
  • Can a proconsul move with fewer than five CUs, or split off from a consul's stack?
  • Can a proconsul pick up CUs from a consular army?
  • When a consul's army retreats with only a few CUs left, can the consul leave units behind?
  • Is the larger pool of Roman generals in the Second Punic War scenario mandatory?
  • Is a proconsul the same as a consul for consul rules?
  • Must a moving consular army leave CUs for a consul it passes through?
  • Do displaced Roman generals come back?
  • Does a proconsul need a minimum number of CUs?

Political Control

  • Can a player flip enemy PCs in a space where the flipping side has a CU?
  • How many spaces must a player hold to control a Province?
  • How many Political Control counters make up Sicilia, and do Lilybaeum or Lipara give their own ally battle card?
  • How is the Lipara space treated under the rules?
  • Do enemy PCs change side just because an army moves across them?
  • Is Samnium a Politically Significant Province, and does it give political points?
  • Do PCs placed in the Miat stay there at the end of a turn?
  • How and when does Carthage move PCs out of the Miat, and must it play a card to do so?
  • Are spaces not connected to a sea lane ports for political isolation in Hamilcar?
  • Does Lilybaeum count toward control of the Sicilia province?
  • Can a Roman Political Control marker stay in place when an enemy CU sits on it and the space is isolated?
  • What happens to an enemy CU on a PC removed by political isolation?
  • Does Carthage's political isolation link to a friendly tribe count for a PC?
  • Can Political Control markers be placed anywhere on the map?
  • What does it mean for a Political Control marker to trace a path back to a friendly space?
  • Does a Carthaginian PC on the Balearic Islands vanish without a road connection?
  • After losing a battle, must PC markers be removed near the battle?
  • Is Syracusae allied with Carthage when Carthage conquers it?
  • When I lose CUs in a land battle, how many Political Control markers do I lose?
  • Do units on an enemy PC convert it automatically each Strategy Phase?
  • Can a PC marker on a port use that same port to avoid political isolation?
  • Can either side place PC markers on an unoccupied island such as Corsica or Sardinia?
  • Can a general move and also flip a control marker with the same activation?
  • Is a PC isolated if a friendly CU is in its space but enemy PCs surround it?
  • How many extra CUs and Generals can Carthage gain from the Miat?

Sieges and Subjugation

  • How does a siege or subjugation work?
  • Does a siege continue into the next turn on its own, or must the general be activated again?
  • Can a general already sitting in an enemy walled city siege on a later turn, and what card can start the attempt?
  • Does a siege need three CUs on every roll, and does it end if the besiegers drop below three?
  • What ends a siege, and does a failed siege roll move the general out of the city?
  • Can a general siege in the same activation in which he fought a land battle?
  • Can a general roll for a siege right after moving into an enemy walled city?
  • What happens when a general moves into a walled city held by an enemy force?
  • Can you take an empty enemy walled city by walking in, or overrun a lone unit inside it?
  • Can the attacker enter the walled city right after a successful siege?
  • Do you need to enter the city to besiege it, and does besieging cost extra movement?
  • Can Fulvius roll again after losing a CU on his first siege or subjugation roll?
  • Can a subordinate general dropped off by an activated general siege after that general moves on?
  • Which siege die does each side roll?
  • Does Carthage roll the red die when subjugating a tribe?
  • Does a siege of Carthage get a -1 modifier on the siege roll?
  • Does Capua use a different siege die from other cities?
  • Does Naval Supremacy change the die used for tribal subjugation?
  • Does subjugating a Carthaginian-friendly tribe require converting it to neutral first?
  • Can Carthage flip a neutral tribe to its own side with an operation point?
  • Can a subjugation be stopped partway, and does a tribe stop enemy movement?
  • What is a Walled City or Tribe marker, and how is it converted?
  • Do Rome and Carthage need three siege points to fall, and does losing the capital end the game?
  • What does the Carthaginian Siege Train card do in a siege?
  • Can more than one Siege Train be on the map at the same time?
  • Does a Siege Train stay on the map when the General with it leaves?
  • Can a besieged walled city with CUs but no General sortie?
  • Can a besieged army sortie, and can its garrison join a relief army's battle?
  • When besieged units join a relief army's battle, which general commands?
  • Can units that sortie retreat back into the walled city?
  • What advantage do units inside a besieged walled city give the defender?
  • Does Marcellus have to move his consul, or have eight CUs, to siege?
  • When a consul and a proconsul share a stack and the proconsul is activated, whose siege ability is used?
  • Can a campaign card siege the same walled city twice?
  • With Charles's siege variant, does Carthage still roll the white siege die?

Attrition

  • Does the Epidemic card's attrition count Supply Trains?
  • Does naval winter attrition apply to both players at the end of each turn?
  • Do armies moving through neutral or hostile tribe zones suffer attrition?
  • Do storm icons on the sea lanes cause attrition when Cruel Sea is not played?
  • Which warships suffer naval attrition in Hamilcar?
  • Are Storm at Sea attrition rolls made separately for CUs and ships, and on which sea lane?

Victory

  • Can Rome lose Hamilcar by controlling too few provinces?
  • Does Samnium count toward Rome's three-province requirement in Italia, and when is the count made?
  • Does Year End Political Consequences apply in Hamilcar, and can PCs removed by it be placed again?
  • Who wins ties in Hamilcar?
  • Who wins a tie at the end of a Hannibal game, or what counts as a draw?
  • How is the winner decided when the game ends?
  • Does Massilia count toward Rome's three required provinces?

Special Abilities

  • Can Regulus keep moving after winning a battle?
  • Does Scipio Africanus roll two dice for a siege only when he is activated by a Forced March card?
  • Does Gisgo's interception penalty for entering a Roman PC space still apply?
  • Where must Fabius Maximus be placed when there is no five-CU stack in Italy?
  • Does Marcellus's siege ability require playing a campaign card?
  • Can Hanno use his ability after a battle or an overrun, and does he need a CU?

Optional Rules

  • Can battle cards be used instead of the Hamilcar dice system in land battles?
  • Does the Hercules Pillars optional rule have to be used when Mauretania is in play?
  • Is Mauretania playable in the basic game?
  • Is Bomilcar part of the vanilla Hannibal game?
  • Can the Carthaginian player use the red siege die under the optional siege rules?
  • Does the optional card-removal rule apply to basic cards without an elephant icon?
  • What does an X in the optional cards distribution chart mean?