Hannibal & Hamilcar
← All Hannibal & Hamilcar questions
Does a failed elephant charge against Roman CUs without a general cost Carthage a battle card?
The elephant rules settle the roll of 1 directly, and forum replies agree the rulebook governs over the older Playbook text.
- Hannibal & Hamilcar rulebook · Rulebook · 17.5. Rampaging Elephants
- Hannibal & Hamilcar rulebook · Rulebook · 17.3. Elephants in Combat
- WRSZS · Community · 2018-03-09
- Nemesis90 · Community · 2018-03-09
- el comandante · Designer · 2018-03-09
Yes. Under rules 17.3.3 and 17.5, a roll of 1 always fails the charge when no Roman general is present, and it costs Carthage one battle card. With a Roman general, the charge must beat that general's Battle Rating (17.3.1). The older Playbook wording is outdated.