RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Carson City thumbnail

Carson City FAQ

202 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook

Game ContentsGame SetupHow to PlayBuilding ConstructionActionsEnd of the GameBuildingsPersonalitiesVariantsCarson City: Gold & GunsCarson City: Horses & HeroesCarson City: A New Beginning

Game Contents

  • Are cowboys and parcel tiles limited to what is in the box?
  • Are roads limited, and what do you do if you run out?
  • Does adjacent mean all eight surrounding parcels, including diagonal ones?

Game Setup

  • Does each player start the game with a revolver chip?
  • Do you pay for parcels taken during the initial setup?
  • Can you claim the starting town centre or a mountain parcel during setup?
  • Can you buy the starting Carson City parcel?
  • Can characters from the yellow and red sides be mixed in one game?

How to Play

  • How many cowboys can you place in a turn, and in what order?
  • Once you have no cowboys left, do you still have to take a turn to pass?
  • How many cowboys does each player receive during the game?
  • Do cowboys you did not place carry over to the next turn?
  • Where do cowboys go after completing an action or losing a duel?
  • Is there a limit on how many cowboys a personal reserve can hold?
  • Are players' reserve cowboys, revolvers and cash open information?
  • How is turn order set for the next round?
  • Does passing change the turn order during the current turn, or only the next round?
  • At the end of a turn with more cash than your limit, can you discard the excess?
  • In what order do players pay down their cash at the end of a round?
  • Are the victory-point spaces behind the round marker still usable?
  • Where does action resolution start on the board?
  • When do you move your victory-point marker?
  • How does a duel work?
  • How is a duel with three or more players, or several players on one space, resolved?
  • When does a duel happen, and does it come before the actions?
  • In a duel, how is a tie resolved?
  • Is a duel mandatory once your cowboy shares a space with another player's cowboy?
  • Can the last player to place cowboys attack a building before the owner can answer?
  • After losing a duel, does your cowboy still add firepower later that round, and can you place it again?
  • Do cowboys on the board count toward firepower in a duel?
  • Where does firepower come from besides revolver chips and reserve cowboys?
  • Are revolver chips discarded after a duel?
  • How much income does a cowboy take from another player's building after winning a duel there?
  • Can you duel to take over a parcel or building another player already owns?
  • When does the winning cowboy leave a building after a duel over it?
  • Who decides the order when several duels are fought in one phase?
  • What happens when a cowboy is placed on an opponent's building during estate income?
  • When is estate income collected, and does it need a cowboy?
  • How do unbought buildings shift at the end of a turn?
  • How much income does each parcel pay in the parcel income action?
  • Which cowboys count toward cowboy income?
  • How do you replace the duel tiles once you have used them all?

Building Construction

  • Which buildings need a house placed when they are built?
  • Do Mines and Ranches need a road or a house to be built?
  • When is the required house placed, and what if no house spot is free?
  • Where can the house for a new building go?
  • Can you build a building on a parcel you do not own?
  • Can you place your house on another player's parcel with their permission?
  • Can you place a building on top of a house?
  • Must a newly placed road connect to the existing road network?
  • Can you place roads from your personal reserve at any time, even during another player's turn?
  • Does a road touching only a parcel's corner, including diagonally, connect a building?
  • Is there a separate action for building roads?
  • Does a road between two mountains cost extra?
  • Does the house-and-road icon on the reference card give a free road?
  • Can you keep a bought building and build it later, and when can it be placed?
  • Do you need a cowboy to place a deferred building?
  • Can you place several buildings in the same turn, including reserved ones?
  • Can a building or a house be placed on a mountain?

Actions

  • Which action squares have no duel?
  • Can you duel for a building square or a parcel purchase?
  • Do you place a cowboy on the Parcel Purchase square to buy a parcel?
  • In what order are several parcel-purchase duels resolved?
  • Does your own cowboy on your building stop opponents from attacking it?
  • Can you place a cowboy on another player's owned parcel that has no building?
  • Where can the Sheriff's white cowboy be placed?
  • Can you start a duel against another player?
  • If you win a duel for an action or building but cannot afford it, what happens?
  • Can you place a cowboy on an action you cannot afford, and where does it go?
  • What happens when several players place cowboys on the same building or space?
  • How is firepower counted in a duel, and do cowboys already on the board add to it?
  • Does the 3-gun Ammunition bonus apply to every duel that turn?
  • Can you buy several parcels in one turn?
  • How much does a parcel cost to buy?
  • Do the Parcels Income and Parcels Victory Points actions count parcels that have buildings?
  • On the Cowboy Victory Points action, do you count total firepower or only revolvers?
  • Can you buy several victory points in one turn at the $2 per VP space?
  • Are all four victory-point purchase squares open every turn?
  • Does winning a duel let you take over the other player's property?
  • Does the Mercenary's extra firepower count on the Cowboy Victory Points and Cowboy Income actions?
  • Can several players, or several of your own cowboys, share a no-duel action square?
  • Do extra cowboys of your own on a duel square give its action more than once?
  • In what order are the actions on the board resolved?
  • When is building income collected?

End of the Game

  • How is leftover money converted to victory points at the end of the game?
  • Does the cash limit still apply at the end of round 4?
  • How do bridges score victory points at game end?
  • Do owned parcels without a building score victory points at game end?
  • How are tied scores broken at the end of the game?
  • Are hotels, ranches and churches worth 2 victory points each at game end?
  • Does a cowboy sent to reserve after losing a duel in the final round score anything at game end?

Buildings

  • How is Ranch income calculated?
  • Do neighbouring parcels include the diagonal ones for income and church protection?
  • Do you get revolver counters from a Ranch, Mine or Prison when you build it?
  • Can a building earn more than the highest number printed on its tile?
  • How do you show a building's current income on the board?
  • Does a Hotel count as two houses for a neighbouring Drugstore, Bank or Saloon?
  • Do Church, Prison and Hotel count as buildings for the end-game building points?
  • Do buildings, houses and mountains on a player's parcel benefit only that player?
  • What does the red house icon on a building tile do?
  • Which neighbouring houses count for Drugstore, Bank and Saloon income?
  • Do a Drugstore or Bank pay for every Ranch or Mine you own, or only neighbouring ones?
  • Is a duel needed to rob a building whose owner has no cowboy on it?
  • Does a Church protect every building next to it, or only its owner's buildings?
  • What happens if you build a Church beside a building that is under attack?
  • Can you attack a Church or a Prison?
  • Can you build on a mountain, and what does owning one do?
  • Does a Mine next to the river get its $3 bonus once or for each river parcel?
  • Do unplaced buildings give their benefits, such as income boosts or firepower?
  • Can you buy more than one building in a single round?

Personalities

  • Does the Sheriff's white cowboy replace one of my cowboys or is it an extra?
  • What is the difference between the yellow and red sides of the Sheriff card?
  • If the Grocer doubles a building type and one of those buildings is robbed, what does each player get?
  • Does the Grocer's doubling apply only to the Grocer's own buildings?
  • When must the Grocer choose between $8 and doubling a building type?
  • Does the Grocer's doubling apply to every building of the chosen type?
  • When a Grocer's doubled building is attacked, does the rest of the doubling still apply?
  • Does the Chinese Coolie's half price apply to every building bought in a turn, or only one?
  • What does the red-side Settler (Farmer) earn per mountain: dollars or victory points?
  • When must the Captain's extra cowboys be bought?
  • Do cowboys bought with the Captain stay with you after the round?
  • How does the Indian get its two random parcels when the rolled parcel is already owned?
  • When you take the Settler role, is the free parcel chosen immediately or later in the round?
  • Does the parcel from the Settler cost money, and must it be empty?
  • Where do the roads from the Chinese Worker go, onto the board or into your personal reserve?
  • Can a cowboy healed by the Doctor be placed on a building or unowned parcel to steal income?
  • Must the Doctor heal another player's cowboy when that player asks?
  • Can the Sheriff's white cowboy be placed on a space that already has a cowboy?
  • Does the Sheriff's white cowboy add an extra cowboy to your supply?
  • Can the red-side Sheriff defend a building, or join a space where another player's cowboy already stands?
  • Can the Sheriff cancel a duel once it has started?
  • Can the player who picks the Sheriff place the white cowboy right away when choosing the personality?
  • Does the red-side Sheriff give you a white cowboy?
  • Can the player holding the red-side Sheriff start a duel?
  • When does the red Sheriff score 3 victory points?
  • Can another player place a cowboy on the Sheriff's square?
  • Do the Mercenary's revolvers and ammunition tokens count toward firepower?
  • What cash limit does the Paperboy use on its yellow side?
  • Can you choose the same personality again in the next round after passing with it?
  • Can you buy victory points at turn end when your cash is under your personality limit?
  • Must cash over your personality's cash limit at turn end be spent?
  • When must you decide which personality benefit to use?
  • Does the Banker's end-of-round VP buying happen before the cash limit is enforced?
  • Does the red-side Settler earn $1 per mountain?

Variants

  • Is the new official solo mode compatible with the older Carson City edition?
  • In the Carson River variant, do bridges connect to parcels diagonally?
  • In a duel under the Might Is Right variant, when do players declare their gun counts and reveal duel tiles?
  • In the Might Is Right variant, does the turn-order bonus score every round or only at game end?
  • In a two-player KiT Carson game, do you start with $15 on top of the duel tiles?

Carson City: Gold & GunsExpansion

  • Can an opponent gain victory points by attacking your Train Station?
  • Can a house next to the river be upgraded to a townhouse?
  • Can you build townhouses on the same back side to deny a rival an income type?
  • Do you need the owner's permission to upgrade another player's house to a townhouse?
  • Does a townhouse upgrade need surrounding parcels that are owned, or only non-free ones?
  • Can a house with an outlaw on it be upgraded to a townhouse?
  • Does a house with an outlaw on it still count as a red house symbol for estate income?
  • What strength does an outlaw left on the board from an earlier turn have?
  • Does a prison protect adjacent buildings from outlaws?
  • Can you fight an outlaw on a free parcel, or buy that parcel?
  • If an outlaw sits on an opponent's building, can its owner join the duel?
  • When an outlaw's building ties with an adjacent building in value, does the outlaw move?
  • After winning a duel against an outlaw in your own building, can you take half the building's income instead of victory points?
  • Can an outlaw move across a river that has no bridge?
  • Does an outlaw move when no building next to it earns income?
  • Does a prison stop an outlaw that is already robbing a building?
  • Does an outlaw that wins a duel leave the building?
  • Does an outlaw on a parcel or estate stop its parcel income and parcel or estate victory points?
  • Can you build on a parcel where an outlaw appears at the start of a round?
  • Can Indians take the City Hall parcel when they claim neutral parcels?
  • Can the Auctioneer put an unowned house or mountain up for auction?
  • Must the Auctioneer have the full price on hand to buy his own auctioned parcel?
  • Can a townhouse be built on the outer edge of the board?
  • Does the weapon tax apply to the 3-gun ammo chip if the Auctioneer sold it before the Governor raised the tax?
  • In a shared action space with the Singer, who resolves first?
  • Can the Singer place a no-duel meeple on the white Sheriff's space when the yellow Sheriff is in play?
  • Does the General Store's house+ symbol earn more from neighbouring houses than a standard house symbol?
  • With the Marksman ability, do you draw new duel tiles during a duel or only for later duels?
  • With the Marksman ability, can you keep your last two duel tiles and discard only the very last one?
  • Can you buy a Station or School now and place it later?
  • Does an owned townhouse count as two houses for a neighbouring building's income, and is the payout capped?
  • What is a townhouse worth at game end: 2 or 4 victory points?
  • When a red-side Gunsmith plays Might Is Right, who selects and reveals a duel tile first?
  • Does holding the City Hall raise the income of your buildings once, or every round?
  • Is the City Hall duel resolved before Estate Income pays out?
  • Does the red house on the City Hall count for everyone, and does it count double for the General Store?
  • When you lose a duel for the City Hall, where does your cowboy go?
  • Can the white Sheriff take control of the City Hall, and when does that control end?
  • Does holding the City Hall change how many cowboys you get at the end of a round?
  • Can a red-side Sheriff start a duel with an outlaw sitting on a building?
  • Can a dynamite chip triple another player's mine after you win a duel on it?

Carson City: Horses & HeroesExpansion

  • Can you use a horse bought from the Wages action to pass?
  • Can a horse placed in the second stable during cowboy placement be used to pass?
  • Can you buy more than one horse per round from the Wages action?
  • Can a horse placed in the second stable move a cowboy that is already on the board?
  • In the rodeo, does the fifth enclosure get an extra +5 on top of horses times hat value?
  • Do cowboys placed in a rodeo enclosure stay there after the round?

Carson City: A New BeginningExpansion

  • Does the cowboy from the A New Beginning starting option add to the usual three starting cowboys?
  • How does the A New Beginning sheet work?
  • In A New Beginning, are starting workers only used in the first round?
  • On the A New Beginning sheet, can you buy more than one option in a row?
  • How much do extra cowboys cost on the A New Beginning sheet?
  • How many property tiles does each player start with in A New Beginning?