RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Windmill Valley thumbnail

Windmill Valley FAQ

104 questions players ask · Updated Nov 14, 2026 · Full rulebook

Game ComponentsGame SetupTurn StructureTulip Bulbs and PlantingLowering the Water LevelEnhancing the WheelsBuilding WindmillsVisiting the MarketHelpers and Farm EnhancementsStarting Farm EnhancementsGame End and ScoringSolo PlayWindmill Valley: Blooming Sails

Game Components

  • Can you shuffle a promo Wheel Enhancement into the base game's enhancement stacks?
  • Are Tool tokens limited, and where do extra ones come from?
  • What happens when the Farm Enhancement deck runs out?

Game Setup

  • Where should the windmill board's wheels be positioned during setup?
  • In the three-player setup, where does the neutral marker go in the Market area?
  • In a two-player game, which row of the Calendar does the Limit tile cover?
  • Does each player start with a Tool token?
  • Can you lose Victory Points, since you start with 5?

Turn Structure

  • Can you take the Unique and Common Calendar rewards in any order during one turn?
  • Can you take the 2 Guilder fallback when you could perform an action but choose not to?
  • When a wheel space shows a plus sign, can you do both actions, and in what order?
  • What is a round?
  • Can Tool tokens reduce how far the Action Wheels move, and do they change the Floodgate?
  • Can Tools move the Action Wheel backwards, or move one wheel without the other?
  • How do you keep track of many chained bonuses and Helper triggers within one turn?
  • Can you still take a Windmill or Plant action after your Windmills are used up or your flower bed is full?

Tulip Bulbs and Planting

  • Must you keep the Tulip Bulbs you gain, or can you discard them?
  • When you exchange a Tulip Bulb in your storage, do the other bulbs slide left to close the gap?
  • Does the order of Tulip Bulbs in your storage matter?
  • Can you plant a black Tulip Bulb taken from the general supply, or only from your own storage?
  • When a Plant action says plant two bulbs, must you plant both?
  • Does a Helper that triggers on a Plant action still trigger if you have no bulbs to plant?
  • Does planting through a Market space count as a Plant action for Helpers that trigger on planting?
  • Does a Market action that plants several bulbs count as one action for a Helper that needs two or more plantings in a turn?
  • If you place the fourth tulip on a Foreign Trade card, can you still take the tulips already on that card?

Lowering the Water Level

  • Can you still take the Lower the Water Level reward when the Water Level is already at 0?
  • When you lower the Water Level by more than one step, when do you receive the rewards?
  • Does a wheel enhancement that lowers the Water Level and pays both Guilder and VP give both at each strength point?
  • Can you lower the Water Level twice in one turn when one Helper triggers a reduction and another adds +1 strength?

Enhancing the Wheels

  • Can you exchange a Wheel Enhancement for one of a different rarity, such as a common for an uncommon, and where does the new tile go?
  • Can you discard or swap an enhancement in the active area during an Enhance the Wheels action?
  • Does a promo tile that exchanges a Wheel Enhancement count as an Enhance the Wheels action for Helpers?
  • Can you spend the money from an enhancement's reward to pay for the action it comes with?
  • When you cover a bulb icon that grants an action, on your board or the Main board, do you still pay that action's costs?
  • What does the +3 eye icon on a promo card mean?
  • Can you own two copies of the same Wheel Enhancement, such as the remove-a-Windmill tile?

Building Windmills

  • If my new Windmill connects to the Market through other players' Windmills, do those players score?
  • When a card lets you place a Windmill anywhere, can you place one that is not connected to the Market?
  • If two market-connected Windmills sit in the north and two similar ones in the south, are all four connected through the Market?
  • Does a Build a Windmill placed without a Market connection still pay the cost, follow the placement rules, and give the Guilder?
  • If a Windmill is placed beside a field with two colours of flowers, do you get both tulips?
  • Does a Helper that triggers on Building a Windmill also trigger when a wheel enhancement returns one of your Windmills to the box?

Visiting the Market

  • Can you stack your marker onto a neutral marker, or onto a Market area that already has a stack?
  • If a third player stacks onto a Market area that holds a neutral marker and another player's marker, must they pay both players?
  • Can you both pay to stack onto another player's marker and pay to move a neutral marker in the same turn?
  • Can you pay to move a neutral marker more than once in a turn when two Market actions are aligned?
  • When you pay to move a neutral marker, must it move only one space clockwise, and can it go onto an area that already holds a neutral marker?
  • If you pay to move a neutral marker, must it happen before any Market movement in the turn?
  • Can you move a neutral marker to an area you will not visit, so that you can skip over sections?
  • If the Market space you land on is full and you skip it, can you use the remaining movement to land on the space you started from?
  • Are the rewards from a Market area or Windmill space mandatory, and must you take every reward when several markers share an area?
  • What does the trowel-and-tulip Market icon mean: plant a chosen-colour bulb, or gain one and plant it?
  • Is Market movement an exact count, or up to the number shown on the wheel?
  • Can a Market movement end on another space in the same Market area?
  • If a Market stack's bottom marker moves away, do the markers stacked on top stay together?
  • On card B02, does 'adjacent to your marker' mean the Market area your marker is in, or the areas next to it?

Helpers and Farm Enhancements

  • Does Helper C02 give its 2 VP once per turn or once per bulb planted, and does planting from a Market or a bonus count?
  • Can a Helper or a starting Farm Enhancement trigger more than once per turn?
  • Does Helper A07 give points for each Floodgate step, or once per turn?
  • Do Helpers trigger from any action, including rewards, other Helpers, patch bonuses and chained enhancements?
  • Can a Helper you gain during an action be used later in the same turn?
  • Can you activate a Helper on the same turn you acquire it?
  • Can you trigger a Helper and then replace it on the same turn, and does a newly gained Helper trigger right away?
  • Can you take a Helper's reward before moving the Action Wheels on your turn?
  • Can a Helper's extra bulb be gained before a Plant action, so that you can plant it? What does a colon like 'plant : gain a bulb' mean for timing?
  • Do you get a Helper's reward when a reward you receive shows the same icon as that Helper?
  • When does a Helper's Market reward trigger during a Market action?
  • If you land on a Market space with several planting markers, do you get a planting Helper's bonus once or once per bulb planted?
  • If a Plant action plants two bulbs, does a Helper that gives a free bulb per Plant action give you two?
  • If a Helper gives an adjacent Market reward and you choose a planting reward, can you plant more than one bulb when several markers share the area?
  • What does the C01 Market Helper give you when you visit the Market?
  • Can you refresh the Farm Enhancement offer more than once in a turn when you take two Gain actions?
  • Does the Gain a Farm Enhancement Helper that lets you see three extra cards let you keep more than one card, and can you refresh the offer to see more?
  • Can the Enhance the Wheels Helper's extra three Enhancements come from more than one stack?
  • Can you replace a Helper or Contract before all six Farm slots are full?
  • Where do Helpers and Contracts go when they are swept away or replaced?
  • Does a Helper that triggers on gaining a Farm Enhancement trigger on the card you just gained?
  • When you exchange a Farm Enhancement from your board, where does the removed card go, and what must replace it?

Starting Farm Enhancements

  • Does the starting Plant ability's extra bulb apply once per Plant action or once per bulb planted?
  • Does the starting Plant ability work on constrained plant actions, such as a Market plant of one colour, and must the extra bulb match?
  • Are starting Farm Enhancement abilities limited to once per turn like Helpers?
  • Does the starting Gain a Farm Enhancement draw of three extra cards cost a Guilder, and how do the cards work?
  • What does the Dice Tower Kickstarter promo do, and when does its power activate?
  • With the Market starting Farm Enhancement, how many rewards can you take from your Market area in one action?

Game End and Scoring

  • For the Queen's Wish connected-Windmills condition, can the path run through other players' Windmills, and must it reach the centre?
  • When do you collect a Queen's Wish reward?
  • Do extra Tulip Bulbs planted outside the pictured pattern stop a Queen's Wish from scoring?
  • Does the border colour of Contract cards matter?
  • Is each tucked Contract scored separately, regardless of its colour?
  • How do Tulip columns score when the tulips in them are different colours?
  • What does the P017 promo Contract score?
  • Does Contract A08 (red tulip fields) count a two-colour field if only one colour is red?
  • Does the Contract on card B05 (2 VP per Farm Enhancement card) count your starting Farm Enhancement?

Solo Play

  • In solo play, does the game end immediately on the Gardener's turn once the endgame is triggered?
  • On a solo Gardener Market action, how many bulbs does the Gardener plant, and do skipped full areas count?
  • How do the SA1 to SA5 Queen's Wish cards work in solo mode, given the automated Gardener gets no Tools?

Windmill Valley: Blooming SailsExpansion

  • Does the Gardener in Blooming Sails get anything besides victory points for a Lower the Water Level action or a gained Move a Ship action?
  • Where does the Gardener's ship move after placing a crate, and which tier counts when a port straddles two tiers?
  • What does 'gain a random single patch tile' mean on a Blooming Sails port tile?
  • What does the windmill-with-arrow port tile do?
  • In a three-player Blooming Sails setup, how many Trade tiles show 3 Crates and how many show 2?
  • Is a Blooming Sails double Tulip tile stored before planting, and do you need a spade action to place it?
  • Why do you remove the base-game starting Enhancement tokens and cards when playing Blooming Sails?
  • How does the Blooming Sails Lower the Water Level wheel upgrade that gives two rewards at full strength work?