Tragedy Looper FAQ
211 questions players ask · Updated Nov 19, 2026 · Full rulebook
Components and Game Overview
- Are Goodwill or Paranoia counters removed after an ability is used or after a character panics?
- Which tokens can the Forensic Specialist and Scientist abilities move or remove?
- Does a dead character keep the Paranoia and Goodwill counters it had?
- If a character loses Goodwill during a loop, does it still count at the start of the next loop?
- Does a character keep receiving Paranoia after it reaches its Paranoia limit?
- Is there a maximum number of Intrigue counters a location can hold?
- Do the examples in the Mastermind's Handbook match a real script?
- Who resolves a passive ability, such as the Scientist's counter at loop start?
- Can cards be played on a dead character?
- Can the protagonists look at the player aid overview sheets during play?
Card ListExpansion
- Does the Cultist cancel a Forbid Intrigue card, or only ignore its effect on its location?
- Does the Cultist's Forbid Intrigue ability apply at a location it moves into, or only at its starting location?
- Must the Mastermind reveal when the Cultist's forbid does nothing because there is no Intrigue?
- Can the Nurse remove Paranoia from herself with her ability?
- If the Nurse is also a Cultist, can the Mastermind refuse her Goodwill ability?
- Can the Police Officer put his protection counter on himself?
- Who chooses which incident the Police Officer reveals the culprit of?
- How long does the Police Officer's Extra Marker stay on a character?
- Can the Police Officer's Goodwill ability reverse a death he is causing himself?
- When can the Police Officer use the ability to prevent a death?
- Does one use of the Police Officer's prevention ability stop every death in that phase?
- Can the Police Officer's ability protect the Protagonists from a death?
- Can the Mastermind use the Doctor's Goodwill ability?
- Once the Doctor has three Goodwill, does the Patient leave the hospital automatically?
- Can the Mastermind use a character's Goodwill ability?
- Does a Serial Killer's kill need Paranoia, or does it count as a Murder incident?
- If a Serial Killer becomes alone only after the Killer's kill, does it still kill?
- Does a corpse count as the other character for a Serial Killer's kill?
- If two Serial Killers are alone together at day end, do both die?
- When does a Person become a Serial Killer under the Paranoia Virus subplot?
- How much Intrigue does the Killer need to kill the Key Person or the protagonists?
- Can the Alien use her kill ability on herself?
- Can the Brain place Intrigue away from its starting location?
- Can the Conspiracy Theorist place Paranoia on itself?
- Does a dead Friend end the loop early, and when is its role revealed?
- Does a Friend start each new loop with Goodwill once its role is revealed?
- How does the Mastermind declare a Time Traveler loss on the final day?
- Does a loss condition that names the Godly Being still apply before it enters the board?
- Can the Mastermind stop a Coward's mandatory move by giving it a second Paranoia with the Ghost?
- Can the Coward move to an illegal location, or can the Mastermind name one?
- Can a 3 Goodwill Henchman still be the target of an incident he is not the culprit of?
- When a 3 Goodwill Henchman stops the incident he would have caused, what does the Mastermind say?
- How does the Transfer Friendship ability work when the target has 0 or 1 Goodwill?
- Can the Transfer Student's Goodwill ability be used on a character with no Intrigue?
- What are the abilities of the Examiner promo character?
- Can the Examiner promo character be used in any Tragedy Set?
- Can the Class Rep's Goodwill ability be used while its once-per-loop card is unused?
- Can the Class Rep's Goodwill ability return another player's card to a hand?
- Where can the Journalist's Goodwill abilities place Paranoia or Intrigue?
- Can the Boss's Goodwill ability target the Boss himself?
- Who decides whether the Boss counts as being in his turf, and how does it change a Serial Killer Boss's kill?
- Does the Boss's always-in-his-turf passive apply to other characters' abilities that target him?
- Does the Key Person have Goodwill Refusal, given the dash in the summary table?
- Which roles have Goodwill Refusal?
- Can the Shrine Maiden reveal her own role with her Goodwill ability?
- Can the Girl Student or Boy Student ability be used on a student with no Paranoia?
- If the Hospital Incident kills both the Rich Man's Daughter and the Servant, does the Rich Man's Daughter survive?
- How does the Informer reveal a subplot?
- Can a male character be a witch?
- Can the A.I.'s Goodwill ability resolve an incident named on the open card if that incident is a Fake Incident?
- Is a Forbid Intrigue card used up after one cancellation?
- If the Factor is already dead, does 2 Intrigue on the City still make the Key Person ability trigger?
- Must Mystery Boy's role be one that no chosen plot or subplot uses?
- Does the Poisoner's end-of-day ability kill any one character in its location, including the Poisoner himself?
- Does the Dance of Fools plot need a Fool and a Friend?
- Do Tricky Twins and Isolated Institution Psycho include a Paranoiac role?
- Where do the new Midnight Circle characters start, and can any of them not move?
- Is the Illusion character tagged Construct or Fabrication?
Game Rules
- Does the loop end immediately when the Key Person dies?
- Does a death other than the Key Person's end the loop at once?
- Does the death of the Protagonists end the whole game or only the loop?
- If a Friend dies, do the Protagonists lose right away?
- What does the Mastermind announce when a character dies?
- Must the Mastermind say what caused the loss when the Protagonists lose?
- Can the Mastermind pick the order of simultaneous deaths to spare another character?
- Do mandatory abilities resolve before optional ones?
- Does a Serial Killer kill a Killer before the Killer can use its optional day-end ability?
- What happens when two Serial Killers are alone together at day end?
- What does the Mastermind announce when an ability tries to kill the Time Traveler?
- When does the Time Traveler's loss condition resolve?
- If a Time Traveler and a Serial Killer both end the loop in the same day-end step, can the Protagonists tell which one did it?
- When does a loop end, and which loss conditions are checked then?
- Does the Place to Protect loss happen as soon as the School has two Intrigue?
- Does the Light of the Avenger loss condition require the Brain to be alive?
- Must the Protagonists name Incident culprits as well as roles in the Final Guess?
- In the Final Guess, must the Protagonists name characters who have no role?
- Can the Protagonists use the Final Guess in a First Steps script?
- How do you choose between a two-loop and a three-loop game?
- What is script creation, and who is the script writer?
- Do the Protagonists know which plots, roles and loss conditions are in play?
- Are Incidents tied to the plots and roles in a script?
- With Table Talk off, what may the Protagonists discuss during a loop?
- Can the Protagonists agree in advance who plays Forbid Intrigue each loop?
- Should the Mastermind read the script's story aloud to the Protagonists?
- Can one character be the culprit of more than one Incident in a script?
- Who chooses an Incident's culprit, and can a character with a plot role be one?
- Must an Incident happen once its conditions are met?
- Can an Incident happen on a day other than its scheduled day?
- How does the Mastermind announce an Incident that does not happen, or happens with no effect?
- If the Hospital Incident's culprit is at its Paranoia limit but the Hospital has no Intrigue, does anyone die?
- What does the Mastermind announce when a Hospital Incident with 2 or more Intrigue kills everyone, including the Protagonists?
- Does the Hospital Incident's culprit have to be in the Hospital?
- Can the culprit of a Murder be the character who dies, making it a suicide?
- Who does the Mastermind choose to kill in a Murder Incident, and must it be the Key Person?
- Can the culprit of a Faraway Murder Incident be the character who dies?
- What does a Suicide Incident do, and how can the Protagonists stop it?
- Can the Missing Person Incident move the culprit into a location the character normally cannot visit?
- Can the Missing Person culprit stay in its own location, and must the Mastermind still declare who went missing?
- If no character has 2 Goodwill, what does the Spreading Incident move?
- Can the Shrine Maiden reveal a corpse's role, or Spreading move Goodwill to a corpse?
- Does the Protagonist choose which role the Shrine Maiden reveals?
- Can the Police Officer reveal the culprit of an Incident that occurred but had no effect?
- Can the Police Officer reveal the culprit of an Incident from an earlier loop?
- Do Goodwill counters reset at the start of each loop?
- How often can a Goodwill ability be used, and does using it spend Goodwill?
- After the Mastermind refuses a Goodwill ability, can the Protagonists try the same ability again that day?
- Can a Goodwill ability with no effect be used to test whether a character has Goodwill Refusal?
- What does Goodwill Refusal stop?
- Can the Mastermind choose whether to refuse Goodwill from a character with Goodwill Refusal?
- Does Goodwill Refusal stop Goodwill tokens from being placed on that character?
- Does Paranoia affect whether a character can refuse Goodwill, or whether its Goodwill ability can be used?
- Can a dead character's role ability still be used, and do its counters stay on it?
- Can Goodwill be placed on the Patient?
- Can a character's Paranoia go above its Paranoia limit, and is there a maximum?
- What happens when a Paranoia +1 and a Paranoia -1 card are played on the same character?
- Can Intrigue be placed on characters, not only on locations?
- Does Intrigue on a character count toward the Intrigue on its location, or the other way round?
- Is there a maximum amount of Intrigue a location can hold?
- What happens when two Forbid Intrigue cards are played on the same day?
- How long does a Forbid Intrigue last?
- Does a Forbid card on a location cancel Intrigue on a character there, or affect the characters standing in it?
- Does a Forbid card stop a character's role or Goodwill ability, such as the Brain's Intrigue ability?
- How do Protagonist and Mastermind movement cards combine when they point in different directions?
- What happens when two Movement cards together would send a character into a forbidden location?
- Is a once-per-loop Protagonist card limited to once per loop across all Protagonists?
- If a once-per-loop card is forbidden, is it still used up?
- In what order are played cards resolved each day?
- How many cards can be played on one character or location each day?
- What are the Killer's two abilities, when do they trigger, and does a Murder Incident need to happen first?
- Must a Serial Killer kill when it is alone in a location with one other character?
- When does a Lover's death affect the Loved One, and when can the Loved One kill the Protagonists?
- Does any role require a particular gender?
- What is a Person, and is a character with no hidden role the same as a Friend?
- Can a script give a role to more characters than its Max Limit?
- What does the word 'tap' mean on a character card in the Mastermind's rulebook?
- What are Paranoia, Intrigue and Goodwill each used to trigger?
First Steps
- Is there a Final Guess in First Steps scripts?
- Can the Killer kill the Key Person on its own, and is that the same as the Murder incident?
- If a Murder culprit is at their paranoia limit, must they kill someone else in their location?
- Where does a script say which characters are in play and what their roles are?
Basic Tragedy
- Does Sign With Me! need a Girl or any female character as Key Person?
- Does Sign With Me! still win for the Mastermind with 3 or more Intrigue on the Key Person?
- Does Paranoia Virus turn plot-relevant roles into Serial Killers?
- Does Paranoia Virus turn a Person into a Serial Killer at 3 Paranoia or at more than 3?
- Does a Paranoia Virus Serial Killer revert to a Person when its Paranoia drops below 3?
- What happens when two Serial Killers created by Paranoia Virus are alone together at the end of a day?
- Is Threads of Fate's loop-start Paranoia mandatory?
- Does a character who lost its Goodwill during the loop still get Threads of Fate Paranoia?
- Does a dead character with Goodwill at loop end still get Threads of Fate Paranoia when revived?
- Do Persons without a role get Threads of Fate Paranoia if they had Goodwill?
- If a Factor dies before gaining the Key Person ability, does the loop end?
- Does a Factor that gains a role's ability count as having that role?
- Can Increasing Unease place its Intrigue on a location?
- Does 'any other character' in Increasing Unease mean any character other than the one who received Paranoia?
- If the target has fewer than 2 Goodwill, what does Spreading do?
- Can a Missing Person be moved to the location they are already in?
- If the Lover dies in a Hospital Incident that also kills the protagonists, does the Loved One still gain 6 Paranoia?
- Is losing to the Time Traveler at the end of the last day the same timing as the loop-end check?
- Does An Unsettling Rumour place Intrigue on any location or on a character in that location?
Turn Summary
Tragedy Looper: Cosmic EvilExpansion
- Does the Show-Off lose Unkillable at 2 Paranoia, or only at more than 2?
- Do The Noble Bloodline and The Key Girl require the Key Person to be a girl and the Vampire to be the opposite sex?
- Does The Executioner incident have a Paranoia limit -1 modifier?
- Do Night of Madness werewolf kills and zombie kills happen at the same time?
- Does Night of Madness always kill the Protagonists when a Werewolf is in play?
- When a spell reveals Twisted Truth, what does the Mastermind announce?
- Do Intrigue counters on locations count as Intrigue and as corpses in Prime Evil?
- Do Intrigue counters on characters count as corpses?
- Does a dead character keep its Intrigue for corpse-based Nightmare or Vampire checks?
- Can cards be played on a corpse?
- How does The Ones From The Grave change corpses into Zombies?
- What does 'if this card is a corpse' mean on the Ghost role?
- Does Cosmic Evil need a previous expansion to play?
- Can a character with Unkillable be killed, and what does the Mastermind say when it would die?
- Does the Spell of Sympathy get around Goodwill Refusal?
- Do corpses count toward the Choir to the Outside God's loss of Intrigue on five or more characters?
- When the Deep One dies, must the Mastermind reveal the character's name together with the role?
- Can two Witches each start with a Curse on their location under Witch's Curse, even when they share a location?
- If an Alien resurrects a character whose corpse still has a Curse attached, is it killed again?
- Does a Curse on an Unkillable character stay out of play for the rest of the loop?
- When Noble Bloodline and Key Girl both apply, who can be the two Key Persons?
- When Evangelium of the Dead kills everyone in the culprit's location, do the Protagonists also die from its second effect?
- When does Cursed Land resolve relative to a Serial Killer's kill?
- Do generic victims count as Zombies when the main plot is The Ones From the Grave?
Tragedy Looper: Midnight CircleExpansion
- What is the Black School loss condition in Midnight Circle?
- How does the Poisoner's kill work when the Extra gauge is at 2 or more?
- Where is a Twin considered to be when it triggers an incident?
- If the Boss is the Twin, does his turf ability still apply when he triggers an incident?
- What does Faked Suicide stop the Protagonists from doing?
- Are Extra cards removed when the loop resets?
- Does a character who receives a Faked Suicide Extra card under Fated Connections become a Key Person?
- If a Poisoner and a Serial Killer are alone together and the Poisoner is ready to kill, what happens?
- Can a Poisoner target itself, or the Detective, and does targeting the Detective use up its ability?
- Does Bestial Murder add one Extra gauge step or several when it triggers?
- Can the Therapist use its ability on a character with zero Paranoia, and must the Mastermind tell the Protagonists?
- If the Obstinate and the Prophet are in the same location on a day the Obstinate is culprit, does the incident occur?
- In Secret Record, does the loss condition trigger when the Ninja falsely claims a role during Confession?
- When does the Fool's ability to remove its Paranoia resolve relative to an incident, and does it still resolve when the incident kills the Protagonists?
- Does a Fake Incident kill the characters in the location named on the open information card?
- Can the Ninja use his own Intrigue ability to kill himself?