RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
The Battle of Mackinac Island thumbnail

The Battle of Mackinac Island

The Battle of Mackinac Island Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

  • 1. Introduction
    • 1.2 Design Note
    • 1.3 Components
      • Map Board
      • Game Pieces
      • Play Sheets
    • 1.4 Important Concepts
      • Area Limitations
      • Control and Superiority
  • 2. Solitaire Rules
    • 2.1 Victory
    • 2.2 Setup
    • 2.3 Sequence of Play
    • 2.4 American Orders
    • 2.5 American Special Actions
      • Artillery
      • Officer Bonus
    • 2.6 Take No Action
    • 2.7 British & Menominee Orders
      • Target American Officer
    • 2.8 British Receive a False Report
  • 3. Two-Player Rules
    • 3.1 Victory
      • A Draw?
    • 3.2 Setup
    • 3.3 Modified Play Sheet
    • 3.4 Sequence of Play
    • 3.5 Initiative
    • 3.6 American Orders
    • 3.7 British & Menominee Orders
    • 3.8 British & Menominee Special Actions
      • Artillery
      • Officer Bonus
  • References
  • Easy Reference Charts
    • Victory Conditions
    • Combat Chart
    • Rally Chart

1. Introduction

1.2 Design Note

Many Native groups were present with the British at the Battle of Mackinac Island. However, because the Menominee were specifically mentioned by sources as playing a key role in preventing the Americans' flanking maneuver in the woods, we chose to feature this group in the game.

1.3 Components

Map Board

The front side of the board has the playing map that covers the farmstead, fields and woods where the battle was fought. The starting positions for each of the different units are marked on the map. So too are the woods to either side. The terrain art on the map is purely decorative and doesn't affect play. Along the side of the map is the turn track.

The opposite side of the board has an informational map showing the events immediately preceding the battle on the island.

Game Pieces

There are two types of game pieces: units and markers. Unit pieces indicate the different combatants: American soldiers, British regulars and Menominee warriors. Marker pieces are used to track your Turn, Orders and Special Actions.

Play Sheets

The play sheets are designed to help you play the game by providing succinct bits of important information and space to keep track of certain important actions. There are separate sheets for the American and British & Menominee sides, in both solitaire and two-player modes.

1.4 Important Concepts

Area Limitations

Not all areas on the map can be moved into or attacked by every type of unit. That's because this game is designed to be a quick and concise illustration of the battle on Mackinac Island, not a gritty simulation with infinite possibilities. The list of orders on each play sheet will make clear which unit can make the move or attack you want to carry out.

Areas on the map also have a limit for the total number of units (from one or both sides) that can occupy them:

  • Wooded area, five units maximum
  • American wing, eight units maximum

When an area has reached its maximum limit, no more units can move to that area.

Also, you need to keep at least one American unit on each wing of your formation at all times during the battle – otherwise cohesion breaks down and you suffer immediate defeat.

Control and Superiority

Here are two important battlefield conditions that apply specifically to the wooded areas and which will that will determine who wins the battle.

Control of a specific woods occurs when one side has at least one unit in those woods without any enemy units also being present. This is one of the paths to American victory. The British & Menominee are trying to prevent this.

Superiority occurs when both sides have units in the same woods, but one side has more units present than the other. This will alter the results rolled on the Combat Chart:

  • On a roll of 4, if the Americans have superiority, one Menominee is removed instead of "no effect".
  • On a roll of 3, if the Menominee have superiority, one American is removed instead of "no effect".

2. Solitaire Rules

In solitaire mode, you take on the role of the American commander. The game system controls the British & Menominee forces.

2.1 Victory

To win the game, you must either:

  • Gain Control of one of the woods. Victory occurs on Turn 10 if you have this position.
  • Or remove all British regular units from their central positions on the map. Victory is immediate.

You lose if any of the following occur:

  • Neither of the two victory conditions above are achieved by the end of Turn 10.
  • All American units are removed from one wing in your starting formation – either by enemy actions or by your own orders. Defeat is immediate. The Americans must keep at least one unit on each wing for the entire game.

2.2 Setup

  • Place the four British regulars and eight Menominee units on their starting positions on the playing map.
  • Place the ten American soldiers on the two wings of their starting formation on the playing map. Split up the soldiers between the wings as you see fit. However, each wing is limited to eight units and the Americans must maintain at least one unit on each wing throughout the entire game – or suffer immediate defeat. (See the image below.)
  • Place the Turn marker on number 1 of the Turn track on the playing map.
  • Put the solitaire play sheets for both sides where you can easily see them.

[Figure: Units set up on the map at the beginning of a game. This is an example of how the Americans can be divided between the two wings.]

  • Put the American markers – Orders, Officers and Artillery – in front of you.
  • Put the British & Menominee Orders markers in a place where you can blindly draw them: in a small cup or in your hand. Artillery is included in these orders but Move to Center is not.
  • Get one six-sided die (1d6) ready to roll. All rolls in the game are made with this single die.

2.3 Sequence of Play

Step 1 Select one order from the American Orders list on the play sheet by placing the corresponding marker in front of you. If there is a choice of left or right, flip the marker to the side showing the correct arrow. Special actions (Artillery and Officer Bonus) can be declared.

Step 2 Blindly select one of the British & Menominee Orders markers. Implement and resolve the action immediately according to the description on the solitaire British & Menominee play sheet.

Step 3 Implement and resolve your American order according to the description on your own solitaire play sheet. British & Menominee action could affect your orders – or prevent them from happening entirely. Implement your orders as affected. Special actions can be declared and implemented.

Step 4 False Report: On turns 4 through 7, determine if the British Receive a False Report and leave the field. If the false report has already been received, determine if the British units return to the field. This leave-and-return event can only happen once a game.

Step 5 Move the Turn marker ahead one space. Return the order markers back their respective pools. Begin the next turn and repeat the sequence of play.

2.4 American Orders

[Order markers, as printed: Direct Attack | Attack Woods | Attack Woods | Move to Woods | Move to Woods | Move to Wing | Move to Wing]

There are two basic types of orders you can issue: move or attack. On the play sheet, each type of order is described with a specific destination or target location, and will have rules for implementing the orders in those different locations.

On the order pieces, there are triangular arrows indicating the direction of the move or attack. The arrow direction is based on the perspective from the American side of the map, with the text oriented so you can read it. These arrows will help you commit to your orders, keep track of your decisions, and determine if the British & Menominee side takes action in the same direction.

Moves occur between adjacent areas. Attacks can occur between adjacent areas or within the same area. For example, if you want to move American soldiers into the eastern woods, they'd need to come from the left wing of the American formation. If you want to attack some Menominee warriors in the western woods, you could do so with American soldiers from your right wing or with soldiers already in the western woods.

Attacks can only be targeted at areas that have enemy units. Any losses will apply to the area from which attack was launched.

A key part of issuing your orders in Step 1 of the turn is to identify the specific area that the movement or attack is coming from and where it is going to (the arrows on the pieces will help you keep track of this). This might seem ridiculously obvious. However, making this commitment is important because the subsequent British & Menominee action in Step 2 could affect your orders – or prevent them from happening entirely. If this is the case, implement your orders and any special actions as affected or, if they can't be implemented, move on to the next step.

2.5 American Special Actions

In addition to the list of orders, you can also declare two special actions. You only have a limited number of each, so use them wisely. You may declare both special actions in a single turn but you can only declare each action once per turn. (No, you can't use your Artillery three times in one turn.) You may declare these special actions during Step 1 or 3. Once you declare these actions, you can't take them back.

Special actions are never prevented as a result of gameplay like orders can be.

Artillery

You have artillery that you can fire three times during the battle. You can fire the artillery either before or after you implement your orders in Step 3. Follow the description on the play sheet to resolve artillery fire. Each time you fire your artillery, move the marker to the corresponding number in the Artillery box on play sheet. After the third use, flip the marker to the Depleted side.

If you fire artillery when British regulars have left the field in response to a false report, those regulars immediately return on the fourth step of the same turn. See British Receive A False Report.

Officer Bonus

You have three officers you can deploy to help carry out your orders. You may only use one officer during a turn. Each officer counter has two sides:

  • +1: Add 1 to any single die roll. The +1 bonus only applies to a single order in a single turn. The bonus is not cumulative and doesn't continue over subsequent turns.
  • Rally: This bonus allows you to recover American soldiers that have been removed from the board. Roll 1d6 and consult the following results:
    • 1-2 Recover one soldier
    • 3-5 Recover two soldiers
    • 6 Recover three soldiers

When you declare an officer bonus, you must also pick which bonus you will be using; you can't declare an officer and then wait to see which bonus to use based on how the turn develops. If used for the +1 modifier, you must declare the officer before the roll is made.

When you declare an officer will be used, immediately move the marker to the Committed box on your play sheet with the chosen bonus side showing. If the orders for the turn are prevented by British artillery or musket fire, you may return the officer to your available pile.

American officers who are still available for use can be permanently removed from the game when the British & Menominee Target American Officer order is selected.

2.6 Take No Action

At some point you may find yourself in a strong position on the field and simply wanting to hold tight. If this is the case then select no orders for the turn. If you've already chosen orders, you must implement them – you can't change your mind. Select and implement the British & Menominee orders as usual.

2.7 British & Menominee Orders

[Order markers, as printed: Artillery (cannon icon, unlabelled) | Musket Fire | Attack Woods | Attack Woods | Move to Woods | Move to Woods | Target Officer]

On Step 2 in the turn, blindly select a British & Menominee order (close your eyes if you need to). In solitaire mode, the order pool includes Artillery but not Move to Center. Each marker has two sides; whichever side is facing up when you look at it is the action you've chosen. (Note: The Artillery marker has a "Depleted" side. This doesn't apply in solitaire mode. Drawing the Artillery piece, either side, means the British fire their cannons.) Some pieces also have triangular arrows on them to indicate the direction of the move or attack; in solitaire mode, these arrows are based on the perspective from the American side of the map, with the text oriented so you can read it.

Implement the order immediately according to the British & Menominee play sheet. If the order can't be implemented, select another order.

Target American Officer

If this order is selected, immediately remove one American officer who is still available for use. This officer is permanently out of the game. Once there are no more available American officers, remove the Target American Officer marker from the game so that it can't be selected any more.

2.8 British Receive a False Report

On Turns 4 through 7, determine if the British receive a false report about American activity to their rear. On Step 4 of these turns, roll 1d6. On a result of 4-6, the British received the report.

When the report is received, half the British regulars still on the field (rounding down) will leave the map. For example, if there are four regulars on the field, two will leave; if there are three or two regulars on the field, one will leave. Move the counters to the first False Report box on the British & Menominee play sheet. On Step 4 of subsequent turns, follow the explanation on the play sheet to determine when the British regulars return to the map.

After the fourth turn of being off the map, the British regulars immediately return at the end of the next turn.

If the Americans fire their artillery while the British regulars are off the map, those regulars will immediately return to the map on Step 4 of the same turn the artillery was used.

The false report event can only happen once a game.

3. Two-Player Rules

The two player rules are easy to implement. The British & Menominee player will take on a similar role as the American player. The American rules are basically the same as solitaire mode. However, there are some modified orders and actions for both sides in two-player mode. Be sure to read through this section of the rulebook and look over the two-player play sheets before getting started.

3.1 Victory

The conditions for victory and defeat are always assessed at the end of a turn so that both players have the opportunity to implement their orders and any special actions.

American victory and defeat conditions are the same as in solitaire mode.

For the British & Menominee player to win the game, they must either:

  • Prevent the Americans from gaining Control of a woods by Turn 10.
  • Or remove all Americans from one of their wings. Victory is immediate at the end of the turn.

The British & Menominee player loses if any of the following occur:

  • Neither of the two victory conditions above are achieved by Turn 10.
  • All British regular units are removed from their central positions. Defeat is immediate at the end of the turn.

A Draw?

It's possible that both sides could meet victory or defeat conditions at the end of a turn. This draw results in a technical victory for the British & Menominee because the Americans simply could not definitively overcome the defenders.

3.2 Setup

  • Place the British, Menominee and American units on their starting positions and the Turn marker on the Turn track just like in solitaire mode.
  • Each player puts their own two-player play sheet where they can easily see it. The British & Menominee players will use a Modified Play Sheet.
  • Each player puts their markers – the Orders, Officers and Artillery – in a place where they can't be seen by the other player: in a small cup or cupped in a hand.
  • Each player gets one six-sided die (1d6) ready to roll.

3.3 Modified Play Sheet

The American player uses their two-player play sheet.

The British & Menominee player will use a modified player aid sheet. To make this, cover the orders list on the left side of the solitaire British & Menominee play sheet with their two-player play sheet but leave the False Report information on the right side visible.

3.4 Sequence of Play

Step 1 Each player secretly selects the marker for the orders they want to implement this turn. Special actions are declared in the same way as solitaire mode.

Step 2 The players reveal and declare their orders at the same time.

Step 3 Determine which player has the Initiative and implement the orders in sequence.

Step 4 Check for and resolve the False Report just like in the solitaire game. The British & Menominee player may use an Officer Bonus to modify rolls related to a false report.

Step 5 Move the Turn marker ahead one space. Return the order markers back their respective pools. Begin the next turn and repeat the sequence of play.

3.5 Initiative

After the players reveal their orders for the turn, one player rolls 1d6. When possible, the player who won the initiative the previous turn should roll the die for the current turn.

A result of 1-3 means the British & Menominee have the initiative, and 4-6 means the Americans have the initiative. Officers can be used to modify this roll – but must be declared before the roll is made. The player with the initiative decides whether to implement their orders first or second that turn.

Similar to solitaire mode, the first orders implemented in a turn could affect the second player's orders – or prevent them from happening entirely. If this is the case, the second player should implement their orders and special actions as affected or, if they can't be carried out, move on to the next step.

3.6 American Orders

All American orders and special actions remain the same in two-player mode, except for Move to Woods. Follow the descriptions on the two-player play sheet.

3.7 British & Menominee Orders

The British & Menominee player will select orders from their own markers just like the American player does. Obviously, these orders have been modified for a two-player game, and they are fully described on the play sheet. The arrow direction is based on the perspective from the British & Menominee side of the map, with the text oriented so the British & Menominee player can read it.

In two-player mode, Artillery is a special action and Move to Center is added to the orders.

3.8 British & Menominee Special Actions

In two-player mode, the British & Menominee player can also declare two special actions in conjunction with their orders. You may declare both special actions in a single turn but you can only declare each action once per turn. Once you declare these actions, you can't take them back.

Special actions are never prevented as a result of gameplay like orders can be.

Artillery

Your have artillery you can fire three times during the battle. You can fire the artillery either before or after you implement your orders in Step 3. Each time it's fired, move the Artillery marker to the corresponding number in the Artillery box on the play sheet. After the third use, flip the marker to the Depleted side. Follow the description on the play sheet to resolve Artillery fire.

Officer Bonus

The British & Menominee side has three officers – the British commander, a British lieutenant, and a Menominee chief. You may only use one officer during a turn. These officers are used similarly to American officers. However, there are some modifications and limitations specific to the British & Menominee officers.

  • -1: Subtract 1 from any single die roll. The -1 bonus only applies to a single roll in a single turn. The bonus is not cumulative and doesn't continue over subsequent turns.
  • Rally: This bonus allows you to recover British & Menominee units that have been removed from the board. Roll 1d6 and consult the following results:
    • 1 Recover two regulars or three warriors
    • 2-4 Recover one regular or two warriors
    • 5-6 Recover one regular (commander only) or one warrior

When you declare an officer bonus, you must also pick which bonus you will be using; you can't declare an officer and then wait to see which bonus to use based on how the turn develops. If used for the -1 modifier, you must declare the officer before the roll is made.

When you declare an officer will be used, immediately move the counter to the Committed box on the play sheet with the chosen bonus side showing. If the orders for the turn are prevented by American actions, you may return the officer to your available markers.

There are also certain limitations on how the British & Menominee officers can be used:

  • The Menominee chief can only modify rolls that involve Menominee warriors and can only recover lost Menominee warriors.
  • The British lieutenant can only do the same for British regulars.
  • The British commander can modify rolls and recover both British and Menominee units.

All British & Menominee officers can be used to modify false report rolls.

3.9 Take No Action

Just like in solitaire mode, a player can choose to reveal no piece during Step 2 of the turn. However, the other player will still implement any orders and special actions they have chosen.

References

  • Pierre Berton (1981). Flames across the border 1813-1814. Anchor Canada.
  • Mackinac State Historic Parks (2021). A Deeper Look: The Battle of Mackinac Island. https://youtu.be/bPtzCUw06R8
  • Mackinac State Historic Parks (2020). Battle for Mackinac Island. https://youtu.be/J8yAPan_NCM
  • George S. May (1962). War 1812. Mackinac Island State Park Commission.
  • Craig Wilson, Chief Curator, Mackinac State Historic Parks (2023). Personal communication.
  • Morris Zaslow (1964). The Defended Border: Upper Canada and the War of 1812. Ontario Historical Society.

Easy Reference Charts

Victory Conditions

American (solitaire and two-player modes)

  • Gain Control of one of the woods. Victory occurs on Turn 10 if you have this position.
  • Or remove all British units from their central positions on the map. Victory is immediate.

British & Menominee (two-player mode)

  • Prevent the Americans from gaining Control of a woods by Turn 10.
  • Or remove all Americans from one of their wings. Victory is immediate at the end of the turn.

Combat Chart

Roll 1d6. Apply any roll modifiers.

  • 1: Two Americans removed
  • 2: One American removed
  • 3-4: No effect unless one side has superiority*
  • 5: One British or Menominee removed
  • 6: Two British or Menominee removed

* For combat in the woods only. On a roll of 4, if the Americans have superiority, one Menominee is removed instead of "no effect". On a roll of 3, if the Menominee have superiority, one American is removed instead of "no effect".

Rally Chart

Roll 1d6 and consult the following results:

American Officer

  • 1-2 Recover one soldier
  • 3-5 Recover two soldiers
  • 6 Recover three soldiers

British & Menominee Officers

  • 1 Recover two regulars or three warriors
  • 2-4 Recover one regular or two warriors
  • 5-6 Recover one regular (commander only) or one warrior
3.9 Take No Action