RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Shadows over Camelot thumbnail

Shadows over Camelot FAQ

240 questions players ask · Updated Nov 13, 2026 · Full rulebook

Familiarizing Yourself with Key ComponentsGeneralSetting Up the GameBeginning the GameRecommendations for First-Time PlayGame TurnProgression of EvilHeroic ActionsGame EndAdvanced and Optional RulesShadows over Camelot: Merlin's Company

Familiarizing Yourself with Key ComponentsExpansion

  • Does Excalibur's +1 change card values when you make pairs or three of a kind in a combat quest?
  • Which fights does Excalibur's +1 apply to, and does it help only the knight holding Excalibur?
  • When can Sir Kay's extra Fight card help a fight, and can he use it when he is not on the quest?
  • Can Sir Kay use his special power when fighting a Siege Engine?
  • Which fights does Sir Kay's extra Fight card apply to?
  • Can Sir Kay use his extra Fight card to play a Merlin?
  • Can Sir Bors share in white cards from a quest he is not on?
  • Can Sir Caradoc use his special power on a life point lost during Progression of Evil?
  • Can a Knight use his special power in addition to his Heroic Action?
  • Are the Saxon, Pict and Black Knight quests located in Camelot?
  • Can Sir Lamorak use his ability when the fifth Morgan card makes him lose 2 Life points?
  • Can a revealed traitor who was Sir Percival still use Percival's special ability?
  • Can you drink the Holy Grail to gain life while you still have one or more Life points?
  • Does drinking the Holy Grail count as a Heroic Action?
  • Does drinking the Holy Grail during Progression of Evil end the rest of your turn?
  • When can King Arthur use his card-trading power?
  • Does Lancelot's Armor let you look at the two Black cards you draw?

GeneralExpansion

  • If Vivien and Dark Forest are both in play and you complete a quest, which cards are discarded?
  • Can a revealed traitor play a Black card face down to draw a White card?
  • Do you lose Life points when a quest fails if your Knight is not on that quest?
  • If you make a wrong accusation while no White Swords are on the Round Table, is there a penalty?
  • Do face-up permanent Black cards such as the First Witch's effect get reshuffled into the Black deck?
  • How many White cards can a Knight draw from Merlin, and can two Knights on Merlin's quest each take one?
  • Can you look at a Black card that a Merlin removes from a quest?
  • Can the Knights play three Merlins together to cancel a Special Black card just drawn, and then still take a Heroic Action?
  • Can three Merlins cancel a Witch card in Merlin's Company?
  • Can a Merlin card remove a Pict or Saxon from a quest?
  • Can Knights play several Merlins on the same quest over different turns to remove more than one Black card?
  • What can a single Merlin remove with its ability?
  • Do you draw Travel cards when moving back to Camelot?
  • When the Witches card triggers a reshuffle, is the card itself shuffled back in?
  • When Merlin is on a quest that is completed, does he stay there?

Setting Up the GameExpansion

  • In a 3-player game, when can you look at your own Loyalty card?
  • How many Loyalty cards are used in a base game, and what changes with only 3 or 4 players?
  • Is there always a Traitor, or can a base game be played with none?
  • With Merlin's Company, how many Loyalty cards are used for 7 or 8 players?
  • Can you play the base game with 8 players, and how do you set it up?
  • Do knights start with Evil cards in hand?
  • Must King Arthur be one of the Knights chosen at the start?
  • How many cards does each knight start with?
  • Do players reveal the White cards they discard or play, or keep them hidden?

Beginning the Game

  • Can knights trade white cards with each other during the game?
  • Can you put your Merlin card into the starting share at the start of the game?

Recommendations for First-Time Play

  • Can you tell other players which cards you hold or need?
  • Does signalling that you need help by playing a card face up break the collaboration rule?

Game Turn

  • What is the difference between a round and a turn?
  • Must an unexposed Traitor still take a Heroic Action each turn?
  • Can the Traitor reveal himself at will, or only in specific ways?
  • Can the Traitor play the Fate card on the first turn and reveal himself at once?
  • If a Knight reveals as the Traitor by playing Fate, does his turn continue?
  • Can players talk about the value of a Black card played face down?
  • Are cards discarded as a cost, such as for Excalibur or healing, shown face up?
  • Are played cards shown to the other players before they go to the discard pile?
  • Can you accuse a dead Knight of being the Traitor?
  • When may Knights use their special powers?
  • What are the steps of a turn?

Progression of Evil

  • If you lose your last Life point during Progression of Evil, do you still get a Heroic Action?
  • Do you get an extra Heroic Action when you lose a Life point during Progression of Evil?
  • If a Knight loses his last Life point during another player's Progression of Evil, does he still get his own turn before dying?
  • If a Knight sacrifices his last Life point for an extra Heroic Action, does that action still resolve?
  • Can a Knight at zero Life Points be revived or healed by a quest reward, a white card or a final action other than sacrifice?
  • Does a Knight revived by drinking the Holy Grail keep his White cards and share in the quest spoils?
  • Can a Knight who has died be replaced by a new character?
  • Can you play a Black Knight, Lancelot or Dragon card face down, and does that give you a White card?
  • Which Black cards may be played face down, and must a drawn Black card be read aloud?
  • Can you discuss your Black card choice with the other players?
  • When the White or Black draw pile runs out, do both piles get reshuffled?
  • Can an unmasked Traitor keep placing Siege Engines every turn to rush Camelot?
  • Can Merlin cancel a Special Black card drawn by the third Morgan?
  • If Guinevere is one of the three cards from the third Morgan, does your turn end immediately?
  • If Merlin is on a quest that is no longer in play, what happens when a Black card for that quest is drawn?
  • Where do Mists of Avalon and Vivien go after they are played?
  • Does Mists of Avalon's extra Black Sword go away after the first failed quest?
  • Can a single Merlin cancel a Black card as it is drawn, before it hits the table?
  • Can Merlin undo a Black card that ends a quest, such as a fourth Pict or Saxon?
  • Can a single Merlin card stop a Black card (or the Excalibur Black card's movement) drawn on another player's turn?
  • Do the three Merlins used against a Special Black card have to come from different players, and can they be played out of turn?
  • Can three Merlins remove a Special Black card that is already in play?
  • When Morgan makes the Knights play the next three Black cards, are Lancelot, Black Knight or Dragon cards played face up?
  • How does Sir Kay's power work when a Morgan's three-card effect ends a quest partway through?
  • When Morgan makes Knights discard White cards or lose Life, and nobody volunteers, what happens?
  • Can Sir Percival look at the top Black card and then choose a different evil action?
  • On the Black Knight, Lancelot or Dragon quest, can everyone see the values of the Black cards?
  • Where is the Dark Forest card placed, and what does it do when drawn?
  • What happens when a quest fills with Black cards and no Knight is on it?
  • Can a lost Lancelot's Armor, Holy Grail or Excalibur quest be attempted again later in the game?
  • Do Black cards from the Pict, Saxon or Black Knight quests ever turn into Siege Engines?
  • When a card says to draw a free White card, may you pick it from the draw pile?
  • Can the Traitor place the twelfth Siege Engine to win the game?
  • After the Traitor is revealed, can he still take Heroic Actions or cost the Knights Life, and does exposure change the loyal Knights' turns?
  • If the Traitor dies, does he reveal himself, and does he still win or flip Swords at the end?
  • How do Desolation cards work on the Grail quest, and how is one removed?
  • Can the Excalibur relic cancel a standard Black card as it is drawn?
  • Can Knights lay Fight cards on a quest before Evil has placed any piece on it?
  • How many Black Knight cards are in the game, and what are their values?
  • When a quest's end conditions are met during Progression of Evil, do the Knights on it return to Camelot for free?
  • Is a drawn Mercenaries card played face down or placed in secret?
  • Where do ongoing Special cards stay, and are they reshuffled?
  • Can three Merlins cancel a Special Black card that the Traitor plays?
  • When Guinevere calls the Knights back to the Round Table, do they get White cards, and does that last?

Heroic Actions

  • Can you play the last Black card of a combat quest face down and still draw a White card?
  • Which cards may be played face down on a quest, and what does a face-down Black card do?
  • Are White cards played to a quest or against a Siege Engine face up or face down?
  • How are the White cards from a completed quest shared when several Knights were on it?
  • If only one Knight wins a quest, does he take the reward cards face down, and does he share them?
  • Must a Knight be on a quest to receive its rewards when the quest succeeds?
  • What happens when a group quest is completed with no Knight on it?
  • Do White cards stay on a group quest when the Knights leave it?
  • Are the White cards played on a solo quest discarded when the Knight leaves it?
  • What happens to the cards on a group quest that is lost?
  • Which quests are solo quests?
  • Can you draw White cards while your Knight is on a solo quest?
  • Does abandoning a quest count as losing it?
  • Can a Knight start a quest, such as the Picts, before any Black card has been placed there?
  • On a combat quest, must one set of cards be completed before the next is started?
  • On the Black Knight, Lancelot or Dragon quests, must the pairs and triples use different values?
  • Must the battle cards for the Pict and Saxon wars be played in ascending order?
  • Where must a Knight be to play a Pict or Saxon fight card?
  • When a Pict or Saxon war is won, are its figures and fight cards removed?
  • On a Fight quest, can the Knights win before every card spot is filled?
  • How is the winner of a Black Knight, Lancelot or Dragon quest decided?
  • Who wins a tie in a fight, such as against a Siege Engine?
  • What happens to the Knight, the Siege Engine and the Fight cards after a fight against a Siege Engine?
  • How is the die compared with the Fight cards when a Knight fights a Siege Engine?
  • Does losing a fight against a Siege Engine add a Black Sword, and does beating one count as winning a quest?
  • Can a Knight defeat more than one Siege Engine in one turn by paying a Life point?
  • Can you move between the Round Table and the Siege Area of Camelot without spending a Heroic Action?
  • Must a Knight move to the Siege Area to fight a Siege Engine, or can he fight from the Round Table?
  • Can a Knight draw White cards at Camelot and also fight a Siege Engine in the same turn?
  • Can a Knight finish a quest and then take a second quest-specific action in the same turn?
  • Can you move to a quest and then draw 2 White cards at the Round Table in the same turn?
  • Does moving from one quest to another, or from a quest back to Camelot, count as a Heroic Action?
  • Does returning to Camelot after completing a quest cost a Heroic Action?
  • Can you spend a Life point to take a second Heroic Action in one turn?
  • Can you repeat the same Heroic Action twice in one turn by paying a Life point?
  • If you spend your last Life point on a Heroic Action, does that action still resolve?
  • If a Knight spends his last Life point to finish a quest and the Grail revives him, does he share the spoils?
  • How many White cards can you play to a quest on your turn?
  • Can you play a White card on a quest your Knight is not standing on?
  • Can you play a Special White card while your Knight is on a quest?
  • If you cannot complete your quest, must you take a Heroic Action, and must you move if nothing else is possible?
  • Must you play a card on a quest when your Knight is on it?
  • What Heroic Actions can a Knight take?
  • Does using a Knight's Special Power use up his Heroic Action, and how often can he use it?
  • Can Sir Tristan use his free move after drawing White cards at Camelot in the same turn?
  • Can a Knight with a free-move power like Tristan take three actions in one turn?
  • Can Sir Galahad play Lady of the Lake with his power and still take a Heroic Action?
  • Can Sir Galahad play two Special White cards in one turn, using his power and a Heroic Action?
  • Can Sir Kay play an extra Fight card after a combat quest's Black cards are revealed?
  • Can Sir Kay's extra Fight card change who wins a combat quest?
  • On which quests can Sir Kay use his extra Fight card?
  • Does Sir Palamedes gain a Life point for defeating a Siege Engine?
  • When King Arthur trades a card with another Knight, are the cards exchanged face down and simultaneously?
  • When can King Arthur use his trade power, and does it use up his Heroic Action?
  • Can Knights trade White cards with each other?
  • What does the second option of the Piety card do?
  • How many White cards does the Convocation card give, and who shares them?
  • Is there a limit on how many White cards you may hold?
  • Can you stay at the Round Table for several turns gathering White cards before going on a quest?
  • How do you get White cards?
  • When you heal by discarding three identical cards, must you show them to the other Knights?
  • Can you heal by discarding three cards of different values?
  • Can you heal when you already have 6 Life points?
  • Can leftover Grail cards be discarded to move Excalibur?
  • Can three leftover Grail cards be discarded to heal?
  • What happens when a Grail card is played onto a full Grail track that has a Despair or Desolation card?
  • Does the Dark Forest stop Grail cards being used to move Excalibur or to heal?
  • Can a Merlin card remove a black card from a quest, including the Holy Grail quest?
  • Can Merlin remove a Despair card from the Grail quest when Desolation is the last Black card played there?
  • How do Knights cancel a Special Black card with Merlin cards without revealing who holds them?
  • Can you play a Merlin card to remove a Siege Engine while your Knight is away from Camelot?
  • Is playing a single Merlin card a Heroic Action?
  • Can a Merlin card remove a Saxon or Pict warrior?
  • Can a Merlin card move Excalibur toward the Knights' side?
  • Can Merlin's removal ability be used out of turn?
  • Can a Knight play a Merlin card and a Grail card in the same turn by sacrificing a Life point?
  • If the Knight who plays Lady of the Lake ends Excalibur's quest, does he get Excalibur, and do the other Knights on the quest get cards?
  • Can you win Excalibur without any Black card being played on it?
  • Can you accuse a Knight from anywhere on the board, or only from Camelot?
  • Can a Knight make more than one accusation in a game?
  • Can you accuse a Knight whose Loyalty card is already revealed?
  • What does a wrong accusation cost the accuser?
  • Can you accuse when six Siege Engines are out but no White Swords are on the Round Table?
  • Can you accuse again after Siege Engines or Swords drop below six, if the condition was met on an earlier turn?
  • Can a Traitor reveal himself voluntarily to play openly?
  • Must a hidden Traitor reveal himself when playing the Fate card?
  • Does every Knight present gain the Life point when a quest is won?
  • Can a single Knight attempt a group quest alone?

Game End

  • How does Shadows over Camelot end, and what do the Knights need to win?
  • What happens to the White Swords if the Traitor is still hidden when the game ends?
  • What does a correct or wrong accusation do to the White Swords?
  • Can the Traitor reveal himself voluntarily, without being accused?
  • If the Traitor dies before being revealed, does he still flip White Swords at game end?
  • When does the game end once the 12th Sword is laid?
  • Can more than 12 Swords end up on the Round Table?
  • What happens if the White and Black Swords are tied when the game ends?
  • Does reaching 7 Black Swords end the game at once, even if White Swords are the majority?
  • If the Round Table already holds 12 or more Swords, does a seventh Black Sword still end the game as a loss?
  • If the 12th Siege Engine and the 12th Sword are placed together, who wins?
  • If 12 Siege Engines surround Camelot while the Traitor is still hidden, does he flip two White Swords?
  • If the last living Loyal Knight dies on the turn the game ends, is it a loss?
  • Can the Loyal Knights deliberately lose a quest to end the game faster?

Advanced and Optional Rules

  • In a three-player game, when can players look at their Loyalty cards?
  • Does a player who joins a game in progress receive the starting Merlin card?
  • Can an eliminated Knight rejoin the game as a different Knight?

Shadows over Camelot: Merlin's CompanyExpansion

  • Can a Knight draw a free White card when Merlin is on his quest?
  • Are the Seven Witches Special Black cards?
  • When does the 7th Witch take effect, and which Knights lose a Life point?
  • Does the 2nd Witch last until a quest is won after it is revealed?
  • If Sir Gareth draws the Vision card, does he still draw a White card?
  • Must Divine Favor be played before the tie it is meant to break, and does playing it cost a Heroic Action?
  • Does Sir Bors's card-sharing ability work on a solo quest?
  • Is a captured Knight still affected by Special cards, the Progression of Evil and black cards?
  • How many Loyalty cards are in play in an 8-player game with the Traitor cards?
  • Does a Squire chosen at the start of the game get his Knight figure and Coat of Arms before being knighted?
  • In Merlin's Company, can a Knight on Merlin's quest draw White cards when already holding 12?
  • Does a Charged! travel card require discarding a matching pair of Fight cards?
  • If Sir Tristan has already used his free move and the Vision sends him to another quest, must he take another Heroic Action?
  • Can a captured Traitor reveal himself or flip White Swords at game end?
  • Can Sir Bors take part in sharing White cards from a quest he is not on?
  • When Ambushed! places a Siege Engine, must the Knight fight it, and does losing cost a Life point?
  • Does a Knight who moves to Camelot draw a Travel card, and can Merlin travel with him?
  • Where does a Knight stay when he is Captured!, and who can free him?
  • Where does a Knight go when freed from the Captured! card?
  • How does Merlin move around the board, and does he leave a completed quest?
  • Can Sir Lamorak use his ability when he loses 2 Life points at once?
  • Can Sir Lamorak's power prevent Life loss he spends, or apply when he spends Life for a second Heroic Action?
  • How does Sir Geraint's power differ from Sir Lamorak's?
  • Are Sir Bedivere or Sir Caradoc the new Knight when Knights are distributed at random?
  • If you have no matching pair when a Charged! travel card is drawn, what must you do?
  • Is Merlin a playable character in Merlin's Company?
  • Does Merlin's Company add new Knight figures?
  • How many White cards does Merlin's Company add to the game?
  • Is the basic Merlin card a Special White card in Merlin's Company?
  • Can Sir Gaheris search the discard pile for Merlins?
  • Can Merlin's Company Knights be mixed into the base game?
  • If a Knight fails a Travel card's challenge, does he still reach the new location?
  • Can a Fight-? White card be played face down on a quest?
  • When is the value of a Fight-? card set when it is played face up on a quest?
  • How many Merlin cards are needed to remove a Witch drawn in the Progression of Evil?