RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Shadows of Brimstone: City of the Ancients thumbnail

Shadows of Brimstone: City of the Ancients FAQ

934 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook

Components and SetupCreating a HeroOld West Hero ClassesThe Game TurnExploration and Map TilesThe Depth Track and DarknessWinning and LosingGritHealth, Sanity and HealingCorruption and MutationEncounters and Skill TestsGear and ArtifactsEnemiesFightsHero AttacksEnemy Movement and AttacksGates and OtherWorldsThe Targa PlateauCampaign PlayAdvanced and Optional RulesGeneral QuestionsShadows of Brimstone: Allies of the Old West

Components and Setup

  • Should Loot and Scavenge decks, or Exploration tokens, from different core sets be combined?
  • Can you mix cards and components from different core sets?
  • How many Revive Tokens does a two-Hero party start with?
  • Must all decks be reshuffled after each adventure?
  • Which cards are discarded after use, and which go back into the deck?
  • Does the Hero Posse level change how tough enemies are?
  • Should you draw Epic Threat cards when playing with only one or two heroes?
  • How do the two core sets and future expansions combine?
  • When adding enemies from a mission pack, do you roll on the special enemy chart?
  • Can Shadows of Brimstone be played solo with just one hero?
  • Does a hero count as adjacent to other heroes while traveling or in town?
  • Are Heroic Effort cards drawn at random or chosen by the player?
  • Can a Hero buy a starting item, such as a starting upgraded weapon, in town?
  • What happens when you need to draw from a deck that has run out, such as Growing Dread or Darkness?
  • If you skip an Adventure, do you still shuffle its Encounter cards into the main decks?
  • Do supplement cards get mixed into the base game decks?
  • When combining two core sets with Frontier Town, which decks and tokens are combined?
  • When is the number of Heroes counted for the Threat level?
  • How many exploration tokens are used per adventure when expansion encounter tokens are mixed together?
  • Can a Revive Token be used to save a hero, and do revive tokens reset between adventures?
  • Which threat cards are used for a five or six player posse?
  • Can an ally such as a Mule carry the lantern?
  • What does 'skip over' an occupied square mean when placing monsters in the checkerboard setup?
  • When a Scavenge or Loot card is discarded under the Drifter's Resourceful ability, where does it go?
  • How are 40mm monster bases placed on the square grid?
  • How do you deal out loot cards in a 5-6 player game once all 12 loot cards have been handed out?
  • Which base size goes with which enemy?
  • What size bases do the Mule and the Dog use?
  • Can more than one player choose the same hero class?
  • Are Harrowfern Fungus tokens side bag tokens?
  • Does Void Lair's Remains in Play card make the Hero roll the d6 every turn?

Creating a Hero

  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman keep maintaining Call Down the Storm while in Animal Form?
  • Does Call Down the Storm roll the lightning check once for all enemies, or once per enemy?
  • When you pay the upkeep to keep a spell going, does it refresh every effect of the spell?
  • Can the Monk's healing abilities target the Monk himself or Allies in a true solo game?
  • Can you buy an alt-gender hero pack without owning the expansion it comes from and still play that hero?
  • When a stat is capped, is the cap applied before or after penalties?
  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman in Animal Form be healed by another hero?
  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman spend Dark Stone for extra casting dice after the first casting roll and then Grit those dice?
  • Are allies (henchmen) treated as Heroes, and do they count toward posse size?
  • Can the Gambler's Let It Ride re-roll dice the Gambler rolls for other heroes or for enemies?
  • When a Ulfsark Skinwalker transforms back to human with more wounds than the human maximum, what happens to its damage?
  • Can I reroll a level-up upgrade, or must I reroll a result that repeats an earlier one?
  • Does the Wandering Samurai work with the Old West core sets?
  • Does the Ulfsark Skinwalker lose anything if I only own the western core sets?
  • How much XP does a Preacher earn from casting healing sermons?
  • How does a Preacher gain additional sermons on level-up?
  • Can a skill test go above 6 dice or a skill value go above 6 through items?
  • When can a hero spend Grit on Battle Plan?
  • Does an enemy controlled with the Voice of Command sermon fight as a hero or stay an enemy?
  • Does a Rage or Ambition bonus from an item work on a hero who does not normally have Rage?
  • Does a personal item carry over between adventures in a campaign?
  • Did the revised Nun and Preacher hero boards change an ability name?
  • How do the Priest's sermons or the Samurai's battle tactics get chosen at creation and when a new one is gained?
  • Can a Samurai who wields two katanas with the two-handed ability get the two-handed bonus twice?
  • Do Arrows count as tribal items for the Jargano Native's Tribal Warrior health bonus?
  • Can the Gambler's Blow for Luck upgrade combine with High Roller to gain unlimited Fortune tokens?
  • Can a Gambler use tricks like Cheat or Tip the Scales to reroll an Orphan's discovery roll?
  • Can a Drifter who is Law and then becomes Outlaw keep the Law keyword?
  • Does the Sorceress's Bound Demon let a Random Spell be cast for free as a Ranged Attack, and does it replace the spell text?
  • Does Buffalo Charge move through other models, and where must the Dark Stone Shaman end?
  • How many dice does the Dark Stone Shaman roll when casting a spell?
  • How many dice must be assigned to cast a spell of a given Power Level?
  • Does a Gunslinger's starting Combat value differ from other heroes?
  • How does the Saloon Girl's Rapid Strike upgrade give its extra die?
  • Do you gain the first upgrade from the upgrade tree at creation or at level 2?
  • Does collateral damage from a Samurai's weapon, such as the Void Hammer, generate Fury?
  • When a Mouse-form Shaman is attacked, can enemies move into the Mouse's space and trigger the Growth Attack?
  • What happens when a Trederran Veteran with unlimited max Grit recovers max Grit?
  • Does a Preacher's or Saloon Girl's 're-roll one defense or to-hit roll' ability re-roll a single die or the whole roll?
  • Can a non-Preacher hero gain Sermons, such as from the Holy Book or Conversion?
  • Can an Orphan who grows into a Prospector regain the Heavy Pick Axe in town?
  • Does gaining the Law keyword remove the Outlaw items, such as a Scafford Bandana?
  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman avoid a Darkness Surge by failing a spell?
  • How does the Dark Stone Shaman's animal form (Wolf, Bear, Mouse) work?
  • How does the Preacher's Revitalize sermon roll work?
  • Does 'All of your Attacks are +1 Damage' add +1 to every hit of an attack?
  • Can Sermons be cast outside your turn, and do they replace your attack?
  • Does Quick Draw trigger once for each group of monsters that appears at once?
  • Can Knock Out Punch's doubling apply to a Dynamite or Hellfire damage roll?
  • Does the Bandido's Twin Guns ability remove the dual-wield penalty for both guns?
  • Can a Preacher use the Hell Fire Pistol and still cast Sermons on the same turn?
  • When do you gain XP for gear, artifacts and spells?
  • Can a hero save XP and spend it later to level up?
  • When can Ability Tokens like bandages or tonics be used?
  • When an Orphan grows up, does he gain a starting skill card from the other class?
  • Can a Sermon such as Cure be used only for its Sanity recovery?
  • Does a Marshal still get XP for a kill when the healing part of the card does not apply?
  • How many upgrade abilities can a hero choose, and does a new hero start with one?
  • Are the health and sanity bonuses from leveling up permanent?
  • Do you start each adventure with a free whisky, bandage or dynamite token?

Old West Hero Classes

  • Can Guns Blazin' be used on 6s while dual wielding Outlaw Pistols?
  • Does Quickdraw still let a Gunslinger fire at enemies placed by an Exploration token after the 2016 errata?
  • How many extra Shots can the Rancher's Rapid Shot add per turn?
  • When does the Saloon Girl's Comforting Presence take effect?
  • Can a Piano Player use the Saloon Girl-only items and abilities?
  • Does the Bandido's Swingin' Fists hit Heroes as well as Enemies?
  • Does the Gunslinger's Call Your Shot count as a Hit when the chosen number misses?
  • How many special Gunslinger bullets can be used on one Hit?
  • Can a Dead-eye Shot be combined with Darkstone Bullets on the same shot?
  • When does a Gunslinger choose which special bullet to use?
  • Do Silver Bullets follow the same rules as other special Gunslinger bullets?
  • Do the Gunslinger's Dead-eye Shots reload at the start of each Adventure?
  • How many of one shot type can a Gunslinger reload into the Six-Shooter Template?
  • Does a Hellfire Shot double the damage before or after flat bonuses like Catch Phrase or +1 damage?
  • Does the Prospector's doubled damage include flat bonuses added to the damage?
  • After the 2016 Quickdraw errata, does the Gunslinger still need a free hand for the first-turn shot?
  • Can a Gunslinger switch to dual-wielding when monsters appear from an Exploration token?
  • Can Quickdraw be used to make a dynamite throw?
  • Do Quickdraw and Through Shot count as Free Attacks, limited to one per turn?
  • Can a dual-wielding Gunslinger trigger Through Shot more than once per attack?
  • Can a Gunslinger with Cool Hand apply the extra shot to both guns while dual-wielding?
  • Does Cool Hand's initiative cut and extra shot last the whole fight or only one turn?
  • Does Cool Hand need a free hand, like Quickdraw did?
  • Does Pistol Fanning double only the printed shots on the gun, or also shots from bonuses and upgrades?
  • Can the Hold-Out Pistol be fired every turn of a fight?
  • Can the Saloon Girl's Hold-Out Pistol be used as a regular weapon?
  • Does the Piano Player count as a Saloon Girl for the Saloon tables and the Saloon Girl's custom town upgrades?
  • Can the Saloon Girl's starting healing ability heal herself?
  • Does the Saloon Girl's Fast as Lightning free attack use her weapon's damage or add damage bonuses?
  • Does Dirty Fighting's +1 damage apply to the Saloon Girl's Spinning Kick?
  • Can the Marshal's Badge be readied more than once per Adventure by spending Grit?
  • Can the Marshal's Badge be used at any time, or only during the Hero's activation?
  • Does the US Marshal's extra shot after a kill stack, and can it happen more than once per turn?
  • Does the US Marshal's starting Grit carry from Travel into Town, or can it be spent twice?
  • Does using a Dark Stone in place of Grit discard the Dark Stone for the Marshal?
  • Are the Lawman and Sheriff badge bonuses cumulative?
  • Can a Bandido throw any dynamite with the Explosives Expert Free Attack without spending 2 Grit that adventure?
  • Does Swingin' Fists make a separate attack roll against each adjacent model, and can its dice move between targets?
  • Do item combat and damage bonuses apply to Swingin' Fists?
  • Can the Bandido's Charge combine with Swingin' Fists?
  • Does Whirling Strike use gear bonuses, unlike Swingin' Fists?
  • Can Swingin' Fists be combined with the Cavalry Sabre's ranged attack?
  • How often can Voices of the Ancestors be used?
  • Does Gambler's Tell cancel one success per enemy model when attacked by a group?
  • Does the Prospector's Expert Miner double gold and Dark Stone for the whole posse, or only for the Prospector?
  • Can an Outlaw collect Frontier Outpost bounties?
  • If the Jargono Native re-rolls a 6 that carried Hail of Bullets, does he lose all three extra hits?
  • When can a Preacher cast a Sermon, and can it be cast outside the Preacher's own turn?
  • Can a Preacher's Judgment replace the ranged attack?
  • Can the Preacher cast a Judgment Sermon and also attack in the same turn?
  • How does a Preacher's Faith token total work?
  • How do you gain Faith tokens for the Nun?
  • Can a Preacher cast Weaken after the damage roll?
  • Can a Preacher re-roll dice to avoid Corruption on a Sermon roll?
  • Can a Preacher use a bow?
  • Does the Preacher's +1 Damage against Undead apply to each hit or to the attack as a whole?
  • How does a Preacher get a new Sermon on level-up?
  • Does Faith Healing follow the same adjacency rules as bandages and whiskey?
  • Does Scourge of the Dead's +1 damage against undead apply to Cleansing Fire, Shockwave or Smite?
  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman visit the sorcerer's location and learn spells?
  • When can a Dark Stone Shaman cast Shapeshifting Magik, and can it be combined with Cougar Strike?
  • Can Devotion be combined with Magik casting dice, and does it raise the dice cap?
  • Does a Gambler's Double Down apply to each damage die or to the whole damage roll?
  • How often can a Gambler use Blow for Luck to trade Grit and Fortune?
  • Does rolling double 1s on Outlaw movement give two Grit?
  • Can Quiet Traveler's one-handed melee rule combine with Control Discipline's D8 damage?
  • Does a Samurai's two-handed blade discipline still apply when the blade is wielded in one hand?
  • What gear and starting items does a Frontier Doc start with, and what do his talents add?
  • How often can the Drifter's Sage Advice re-roll?
  • Is the Drifter's Bad Ass extra attack a single die roll or a full attack?
  • Can a Drifter shake off a Transformation Curse like the Vampire Bite?
  • Does an Orphan keep the Young ability after growing up, and can a grown-up Orphan dual-wield guns?
  • Does Laying Down the Law let a Lawman re-roll all dice for an attack, or just one?
  • Can a Lawman use Motivate more than once in the same turn?
  • Can a Lawman re-roll both a Boot Knife attack and a pistol attack in the same turn?
  • Does Cowboy's Trick Shooting still require hitting with the same gun?
  • Does Who Wants to Live Forever count horror hits that were blocked by Willpower or Spirit Armor?
  • Can Gambling Tricks, which are once per turn, be used during town?
  • Can a Dwarf's Rune Smith +1 Shot apply to a free-attack weapon such as the Targa Finger Laser?
  • Do you pay for a Blessed Aura if the Hero fails the Spirit Test?
  • Which hero class is the Showman?
  • Does the Outlaw's Charm path heal other heroes or the Outlaw?
  • Does Master of Killin' let a Gunslinger use special ammo with two-handed guns?

The Game Turn

  • What is the difference between a Turn and an Activation?
  • Do you roll Hold Back the Darkness every turn, including during a fight?
  • Can Grit be used to reroll a Hold Back the Darkness test?
  • If the Hero carrying the Old Lantern is knocked out, does the Hold Back the Darkness check still happen?
  • In what order do effects that start a turn resolve, such as Fear, Grit and a Brimstone Ash token?
  • When does the Saloon Girl's Comforting Presence heal: after her own activation or at the end of the turn?
  • Must a Hero move before taking any other action during their activation?
  • Must a Hero roll for Movement even when they stay in place or cannot move?
  • If a movement roll of 1 is followed by spending Grit to add a D6, does the Hero get a second move?
  • When can items, Side Bag tokens and abilities that are not attacks or moves be used?
  • Can Side Bag items be used during another Hero's activation without using up an attack?
  • When can a Hero change the items in their hands or equip gear during a fight?
  • Can Heroes trade items or Side Bag tokens, and can they do it during a fight?
  • Does the Old Lantern have to pass between Heroes each round?
  • Can a model's initiative change during the turn, and does its activation still finish?
  • Do Heroes act in initiative order outside combat?
  • If enemies appear mid-turn, does the turn end and a new turn begin?
  • Does a fight last through several turns, and does each fight turn still count as a turn?
  • Can a Hero search or scavenge during a fight, or on a Map Tile with an unrevealed Exploration token?
  • When do enemies from a newly revealed tile first act?
  • When is a face-down Exploration token revealed after the Heroes move?
  • Does casting a spell or Sermon use up the Hero's action or attack?
  • Can Judgment Sermons be cast on someone else's turn?
  • Do spells need line of sight to target?
  • When does a spell with a lasting effect, such as Call Down the Storm, take effect?
  • What is the difference between a once-per-turn ability and a once-per-attack ability?
  • Can a Dark Stone Shaman move, spend Grit and make a Growth Attack in the same activation?
  • With two dice for movement, must you pick the 1 to recover Grit?
  • During a Final Fight, do you still roll Hold Back the Darkness and resolve Darkness and Growing Dread cards?
  • When can the Marshal's Badge bonus apply to a Hero's next activation?
  • With no enemies on the board, do I have to search, or can a Hero just move and stop?

Exploration and Map Tiles

  • Can a Gunslinger with Quickdraw fire at enemies placed by an Exploration token when a hand is free?
  • Is a Scavenged marker placed after every Scavenge attempt, or only after a successful one?
  • How many times can a Map Tile be Scavenged, and is there a once-per-turn limit for each Hero?
  • If the first Hero rolls no 6s while Scavenging, can another Hero scavenge the same tile?
  • Can a Hero scavenge the tile at a connection half-space instead of looking through the door?
  • Can passage tiles be Scavenged, and do rooms without an encounter still advance the Depth Track?
  • When adding an Otherworld's Mine map cards, do you include its passage cards too?
  • Do the Interior symbols on Targa map cards have any rules effect?
  • Does a Steam Clouds card that limits ranged attacks also stop melee hits on a Map Tile?
  • How do the ongoing and one-time parts of the Steam Clouds mine encounter work?
  • Is there ever a reason to backtrack or explore a second tile exit?
  • Does a Barrier that extends past a corner block diagonal movement, and does it block line of sight?
  • What counts as a wall for movement and shooting on a Map Tile?
  • What happens if a drawn Map Tile is already in play, such as the Mine side of a double-sided tile?
  • What do you do when a new Map Tile would overlap tiles already on the table?
  • Is it OK to remove earlier Map Tiles from the table as you explore new areas?
  • Can Heroes explore a door or reveal Exploration tokens during a fight, including after an ambush?
  • Does a Unique Room's Advanced Encounter happen every time that room is explored?
  • How do Pit Areas count for enemy placement, and what do they cost to enter?
  • Does an Exploration token marked Darkness or Growing Dread also produce an Encounter, and does a token naming both Darkness and Encounter produce both?
  • Does every room get an Exploration token, or is an Encounter token a different component?
  • Are Exploration tokens reshuffled back into the stack after they are resolved?
  • How many Map Tiles are in a standard Map deck?
  • Can a model be pushed or kicked through an unexplored doorway or gate?
  • After looking through a door, can the Hero keep moving or reveal a tile mid-move and enter it?
  • Can two Heroes at the same junction each look through a door in one turn?
  • How are doors and end caps placed when an Exploration token is revealed?
  • Does the Flooded Passage movement penalty apply to monsters as well as Heroes?
  • How does the Flooded Passage work while Heroes stay on the tile, and does its D6 roll happen once?
  • Does the Old Lantern light only the holder's space, or the whole Map Tile and adjacent tiles?
  • Can a Hero look through a door from a tile whose Exploration token is still face down?
  • Can another Hero use Lantern Oil to reroll the lantern holder's failed Hold Back the Darkness roll?
  • Can Heroes move onto a new Map Tile before its Exploration token is revealed or explored?
  • If two Exploration tokens are revealed at once, in what order are their encounters resolved?
  • Can Adventures exploration tokens be mixed with the core exploration tokens?
  • Can an encounter that needs open doorways be placed on a fixed map?
  • After moving one square from a tile edge and rolling a 6, can you move, search and move again?
  • Can Heroes split up in the mine, and what changes for initiative or exploration?
  • How much XP do loot and scavenge tokens give?
  • If the next Encounter token automatically has a clue, does it get an extra clue when it already has one?
  • How are Exploration token stacks set up at the Blasted Wastes entrance?

The Depth Track and Darkness

  • Is the Sanity lost to the Cosmic Insignificance Growing Dread card permanent?
  • Does Cosmic Insignificance's Sanity loss count as Sanity Damage, so Spirit Armor or other Sanity Damage prevention can stop it?
  • Must every Hero spend their own Grit to cancel a Growing Dread card, or can one Hero pay for the whole party?
  • Can a Growing Dread card be cancelled while it is still face down, and how many cards does one Grit cancel?
  • When a Growing Dread stack is revealed, must you decide whether to cancel each card before the next one flips?
  • When are Growing Dread cards revealed and resolved?
  • Are Growing Dread cards drawn after the Objective is reached resolved as soon as they are drawn?
  • Do you keep rolling Hold Back the Darkness and drawing Growing Dread and Darkness cards during the final fight?
  • Are Growing Dread cards resolved before the final fight's Enemies are placed?
  • Who rolls Hold Back the Darkness, and what number do they need to roll?
  • What happens when you roll doubles on Hold Back the Darkness?
  • Does the Encroaching Shadows -1 apply to the total or to each die on Hold Back the Darkness?
  • If the Darkness moves two spaces at once, does it trigger a Blood Spatter or Growing Dread space it passes?
  • Does placing a Map Tile move the Hero Party marker on the Depth Track, even when no Map card is drawn?
  • What happens when the Hero Party marker reaches the Darkness Start space at the end of the Depth Track?
  • Do duplicate Darkness cards in play stack their effects?
  • If a Growing Dread card draws an Ambush Darkness card, is that battle fought before the final battle?
  • When a Depth Event makes every player take D6 hits, does each player roll?
  • Is a fight one big turn, or do you still roll Hold Back the Darkness during combat?
  • Does a Face Off with the Undead Gunslinger count as a new turn for Hold Back the Darkness?
  • Can Grit cancel Darkness cards, or only Growing Dread cards?
  • Do Allies count toward the Grit needed to cancel a Growing Dread card?
  • If a successful encounter cancels a Growing Dread card before any has been drawn, does the cancel carry forward to a later draw?

Winning and Losing

  • What happens if the party runs away from a mission?
  • Can the party flee the mine while enemies are next to the heroes?
  • If you fail a mission and replay it, does its failure consequence change?
  • With two or fewer Heroes, is the final threat High instead of Epic?
  • In Last Stand, how do you count the enemies that advance the Posse depth marker?
  • Does a fight with several enemy types give one Loot card per type?
  • Do you still draw Loot and Catch Your Breath after the final fight of a mission?
  • What happens if the Darkness marker reaches the Mine Entrance end of the Depth Track?

Grit

  • Can Grit be used to reroll a chart roll, such as an Injury, Mutation, town event or travel hazard?
  • If a chart result makes you take a skill test, can Grit reroll that test?
  • Can Grit reroll dice the game or enemies roll against your Hero, such as enemy attacks, to-hit rolls or damage?
  • Can Grit reroll a Hold Back the Darkness roll, or any die on it?
  • Can one Grit reroll every die from a roll, such as all the dice of a multi-target attack?
  • Can a die that was already rerolled be rerolled again with Grit or another ability?
  • Does an ability that lets you reroll a roll, or a single roll, let you reroll every die?
  • Do you have to pay Grit for an extra movement die before you roll it?
  • What happens when you gain Grit while already at Max Grit?
  • If a card lowers your Max Grit, do you lose the Grit above the new maximum, and does it come back when you leave the tile?
  • How much Grit does each Hero start a mission with, and does leftover Grit carry over?
  • Do you still gain Grit from rolling a 1 on Move if you don't move, or if the Move gets bonus movement?
  • Can Grit reroll the break roll for an item such as the Old Map, Deputy or Rope?
  • Which of your Hero's own rolls can Grit reroll?

Health, Sanity and Healing

  • Can an Injury or Madness roll kill a Hero, and does the -1 penalty matter?
  • When does a Revive Token take effect if a Hero is knocked out mid-attack?
  • Does using a Revive Token make a Hero roll on the Injury or Madness chart?
  • Is a Revive Token used automatically when a Hero is KO'd, or can the group keep it?
  • Do Revive Tokens reset for each adventure, and is there a reward for unused ones?
  • Does a KO'd Hero roll on the Injury or Madness chart when they recover?
  • Can a KO'd Hero recover in the middle of a fight, and who can heal them?
  • Can monsters or other Heroes move through a space with a KO'd Hero?
  • If every Hero is KO'd, do the party keep its XP, gold and loot?
  • Do KO'd Heroes keep their Corruption Points when they are revived?
  • Are Poison and other status markers removed when a Hero is KO'd?
  • Do KO'd Heroes lose gold or Dark Stone, and do they still roll for Dark Stone Corruption?
  • What happens when a Hero rolls an Injury or Madness they already have?
  • What happens if a Hero rolls a Mutation they already have?
  • Do Injuries and Madness from a mission stay on a Hero after the mission ends?
  • Does a resurrected Hero keep their Injuries, Madness and Mutations?
  • What happens to a dead Hero's gear, and does a resurrected Hero keep it?
  • Can a dead Vampire Hero be resurrected at the Church?
  • If a Hero KO'd at a camp is carried off by demons, can they be brought back?
  • What happens if permanent Sanity loss drops a Hero's maximum Sanity to 0?
  • How can Corruption, an Injury or a Mutation be removed?
  • Does a Preacher's Cure blessing remove a Bitten marker from a Feral Vampire?
  • How many Surgery attempts are allowed at the Doc's Office?
  • Can Grit be used to re-roll a Surgery roll at the Doc's Office?
  • Is a botched Surgery result permanent?
  • Can you have one injection of each kind at the Doc's Office at the same time?
  • Can Grit be used to re-roll an Injury or Madness chart roll?
  • Can a Hero heal another Hero with a Side Bag token or an item?
  • When can a Hero use a Side Bag healing token during play?
  • Can a Hero heal to stop a Knock Out from a hit that would drop them to 0?
  • Can Bandages or Whiskey be used in Town to heal damage carried into the next adventure?
  • How much Health and Sanity do Bandages and Whiskey restore?
  • How do Heroes heal outside a fight, and can Catch Your Breath healing be split?
  • Do you get XP for healing yourself?
  • Do you get 5 XP for each Wound or Sanity healed?
  • Do Sermons, Faith Healing and similar card abilities add XP on top of the healing XP?
  • Does each adjacent Hero choose its own heal from Comforting Presence?
  • Can you heal an Advanced Ally, such as a pack mule or dog?
  • Do Allies take Injuries when the posse has to?
  • Does Armor still reduce damage when a hit ignores Defense or Willpower, or when no roll is made?
  • Does Armor apply to Hex Hits, and does Spirit Armor?
  • How much damage does a Hit do when a card does not say how much?
  • Can Defense or Willpower be rolled against Hits, Horror Hits and Corruption Hits from a card?
  • Is a Willpower of 5+ better or worse than 4+ against Horror Hits?
  • How does Soul Drain change the Sanity damage from a Night Terror's Terror hits?
  • Does Cover protect against Sanity damage, or only Wounds?
  • If a card makes all Heroes take D6 damage, is the damage rolled once or for each Hero?
  • Does Shrug it Off cancel the combined damage from a group of enemies attacking together?
  • How does Back From the Brink leave a Hero who is KO'd?
  • Does a Drifter's Secret or Immortal ability prevent a Knock Out as well as death?
  • Do Drifters keep Injuries and Madness between adventures, and what happens if a Drifter is killed?
  • Does Kleptomania's loot roll trigger once per loot card, or once each time the posse receives loot?
  • Can a Blacksmith's stabbing wound be healed as an Injury?
  • When does the Flag of the Fallen's healing happen?
  • What happens to a Hero who is KO'd by a town event such as Town Overrun or Void Twister?
  • Is Sanity lost to a card such as A Crack in Space or Hideous Discovery permanent?
  • Does leveling up or resurrection remove permanent Health or Sanity loss?
  • When permanent Health or Sanity is lost, does it reduce gear bonuses too?
  • Do Gain +X Health or Sanity effects heal damage you already have?
  • Does damage taken in Travel or Town heal before the next adventure?
  • Does a Hero start the next adventure KO'd if wounds carry over?
  • Do Injury or Madness results of 11 or 12 stay in effect after you roll them?
  • Is the Health lost to a Growing Dread KO penalty permanent, and does a Revive Token cancel it?

Corruption and Mutation

  • Can Corruption from Dark Stone be prevented by items that prevent Damage?
  • Can Grit be used to re-roll the dice for Dark Stone corruption hits?
  • How many Corruption points can a Hero hold before rolling a Mutation?
  • Are Dark Stone corruption rolls made before or after a Hero fully heals at the end of an adventure?
  • Do extra Corruption points carry over after a Mutation?
  • What happens if a Hero rolls a Mutation they already have?
  • Is the Mutation chart rolled as a D36 or a D66?
  • Do spent Darkstone Bullets count toward end-of-adventure Corruption rolls?
  • What happens to unused Darkstone Bullets when a Hero gets the Fused with Dark Stone mutation?
  • Is Corruption removed at the end of an adventure?
  • How is Dark Stone corruption rolled at the end of an adventure?
  • Do Items with a Dark Stone icon add dice to the end-of-adventure Corruption roll?
  • Can a Hero hand their Dark Stone to another Hero before the end-of-adventure Corruption roll?
  • Can Dark Stone be stored safely in a Tomb Chest?
  • Can heroes share one Tomb Chest and trade Dark Stone between them?
  • Does a Tomb Chest stop the Corruption Hit from the No Shame in It upgrade?
  • Does Eye Grown Over apply to a 6 when Dual Wielding stops it from being a critical hit?
  • How is the d3 roll for the Pack Mule's second head mutation resolved?
  • If a Soul Parasite roll of 1 is Gritted, does its Sanity damage still apply?
  • Can a Soul Parasite be removed by anything other than a double 6 on the Doctor's location event?
  • Can a Hero have two or more Parasites at once?
  • Does Prehensile Tail plus A Few New Tricks give a fourth hand?
  • Does the Mutant Quarter A Few New Tricks event apply to Tentacle or Tail mutations gained later?
  • Does Void Speech's +1 Initiative apply to each Hero's own activation?
  • If a Hero sells the item that let them use a fused weapon, must they still use that weapon?
  • Can a Preacher, who cannot use guns, equip the Child of the Void Pistol from a mutation?
  • If a monster dies to a Tail with a Mouth wound, do its hits still resolve?
  • Does a Corrupted enemy's Taint of Evil trigger once per enemy Hit or once per model?
  • What happens to a vampire Hero's stats and Health when the Vampire Curse is removed?
  • Can a Gambler use Fortune's Favor again on an end-of-adventure Mutation roll if it was already used in the last turn?
  • Can you roll for a Mutation or Injury and then discard a Rune of Regeneration to cancel the result?
  • Does Spirit Armor prevent Corruption Points?

Encounters and Skill Tests

  • Do encounters affect Heroes on other map tiles, or only Heroes on the same tile?
  • When a random or chosen Hero makes an encounter test, do the success and failure results apply to every Hero?
  • On an All Heroes test followed by a THEN effect, is the THEN part resolved once per Hero or once for the party?
  • Does every player roll for the Dark Stone Deposit encounter?
  • Does a Massacre encounter's Horror Hit happen once per activation or each time a Hero enters a space?
  • Can you mix Encounter tokens or Loot and Scavenge decks from several core sets?
  • How many dice do you roll for a gambling bet, and what pays out?
  • How does the Five Card Draw Poker payout work when you double your bet?
  • If an Undead Gunslinger Challenge is drawn with other Threat cards, does Hold Back the Darkness still happen during the Challenge?
  • What happens if you cannot pay an event's gold cost?
  • Are Badlands Encounters mixed into the normal Encounter deck?
  • What threat level does the objective fight use in 2-player and 4-player games?
  • Can you use several cancel-and-redraw abilities one after another on the same card?
  • How does the Shaft of Light encounter's cancel roll work?
  • Does the extra D6 roll in the Drone Hive encounter repeat each turn?
  • Do you get Loot for a Threat card that only draws more Threat cards?
  • Are Encounter tokens removed from the game once they are revealed?
  • Does A Crack in Space stay in play, and does it resolve again at the end of a turn?
  • If a Prospector is shot dead on the failed Cunning test, does the rest of the card still resolve?
  • Does a +1 to a Skill from gear add a die, or +1 to each die rolled?
  • Can you trade items to another Hero during an encounter, before a roll the encounter calls for?
  • When a Mining Lift tile adds a Broken Lift Encounter card alongside Exploration tokens, which resolves first?
  • Does the Biting Mites Strength 5+ test apply separately to each die rolled?
  • Do you take Wounds from Creeper Vines dice that pass the test?
  • After a Fallen Bodies encounter, does the Corpse token roll to rise at the end of every turn?
  • With the Explosives Encounter card, does a Hero get XP for Enemies killed by the blast?

Gear and Artifacts

  • Does the Trusty Pistol require the Frontier keyword?
  • Can an item marked 'Once per Turn' be used in Town?
  • Can a hero carry more than one copy of the same Gear or Artifact card?
  • Can a hero without the keyword buy or use an item sold in a keyword-only section of a town location?
  • How much do you get back when you sell an item you bought in town?
  • Can a hero sell an item card for gold in town?
  • Where can Dark Stone be sold?
  • How much damage do the Hits from a Gunpowder Keg do to heroes and enemies in the room?
  • Does Crushed Dark Stone double only your base Combat, or the Combat from items too?
  • Does a +1 stat from an item add a die, or raise the stat itself?
  • How much Weight can a hero carry?
  • Is there a limit on how much Dark Stone or gear a hero can carry out of a mine?
  • When can a Side Bag token be used, and does it cost the hero's action?
  • When can gear and artifact cards be used?
  • Can Side Bag tokens be stored in a Bag of Infinite Holding or moved onto other gear?
  • How many Side Bag tokens can a hero buy in one town visit?
  • How does a hero get a bigger Side Bag?
  • Can heroes give, trade, or sell items to each other?
  • Can Starting Gear be traded, given away, sold, or lost?
  • Can a hero lose starting gear to an event, and replace it?
  • Can Personal Items be traded, given away, lost, or discarded?
  • Can a hero wear more than one clothing item at a time?
  • Is a jacket the same clothing slot as a coat?
  • Do rings take up a clothing slot?
  • Can a hero wear more than one amulet at a time?
  • Do you need to equip an item to get its bonuses, such as a Holy Book's +1 Faith?
  • Do items without a hand icon, such as the Lantern or Pipe, use a hand slot?
  • When can a hero change the items in their hand slots?
  • Can a hero swap items after the final fight and before the Dark Stone corruption roll?
  • Can a hero dual wield weapons, and can a two-handed weapon be combined with another weapon?
  • Does a two-handed rifle keep the bonus from a Hatchet or Hunting Knife?
  • Can an upgrade be moved or removed, and is the Dark Stone spent to attach it returned?
  • Does attaching an upgrade or runestone cost anything, and where can it be done?
  • Can the same upgrade be applied more than once to one item?
  • Can a one-slot Shotgun take the Dark Stone Grip upgrade?
  • Do an item's upgrades or runes work when the item is not equipped?
  • Do weapon upgrades apply to all of your damage or only to the weapon they are on?
  • Can a skill that readies a Once per Fight item let you use it again in the same fight?
  • How often can the Hold-Out Pistol's free attack be used?
  • What does the Cheater's Hold-out Pistol's +3 Initiative free attack mean?
  • Can a hero carry more than one Hold-Out Pistol?
  • Can a hero benefit from more than one Badge in the same fight?
  • Can the Sheriff's or Marshal's Badge boost both a Hold-Out Pistol and a regular attack?
  • Does the Blaster's one-shot +3 damage option combine with the US Marshal's Badge shots?
  • Does throwing dynamite replace a hero's normal ranged and melee attacks?
  • How many dice does a dynamite throw roll?
  • If a thrown dynamite stick misses its target, where does its bounce start?
  • Does dynamite give XP for each enemy it kills?
  • Do Dynamite Satchel tokens recharge at the start of each mission?
  • Can a hero switch ammo types during an adventure?
  • Does purchased ammo last for one shot or the whole adventure?
  • Do Blood Rounds' extra shots carry over to the next activation?
  • Do you need two sets of Darkstone bullets to use two pistols?
  • What counts as a single source for damage-prevention items such as the Cigar, the Lucky Charm or the Amulet of Kotak?
  • Can the Cigar gear card or the Fine Cigar sidebag token be used during Travel or in Town?
  • What does the slash in 'Once per Adventure / Town Stay' mean on an item?
  • Can the Amulet of Heinghal's extra die be used on another hero's hit?
  • Does a once-per-adventure item keep its passive bonus after its ability is used?
  • Does Lucky Dice (+1 to one die roll) stop a Teleportation Bracelet from malfunctioning on triples?
  • Can Lucky Dice re-roll other heroes' rolls or monsters' rolls?
  • Does the Lucky Hat's once-per-Adventure re-roll apply to any die, or only to your hero's own rolls?
  • Can a Gold Ring reroll be used on a chart roll, and does it give a permanent upgrade?
  • If you own two items with the same triggering condition, do both effects apply when you pass a test?
  • What does Insulated Gloves' ignore-enemy-abilities effect cover when my hero's to-hit rolls trigger them?
  • Can a Hero reanimated by the Ring of the Revenant be reanimated again after dying?
  • Does a hero gain XP when a Snake Skin Belt transfers a hit that wounds or kills an enemy?
  • How often does the Valhallan Armor heal 2 wounds when enemies attack?
  • Do multiple armor items stack?
  • What does the Raptor Tooth Necklace's ignore-armor effect refer to?
  • Does the Butcher's Blade bonus damage apply to the Void Hammer's splash wounds?
  • Does the Eagle Feather Arrow replace the damage from the critical hit it is used on?
  • How does the Rusty Badge remove Corruption?
  • Can you choose to ignore an equipped item's bonus, such as the Orb of Ro'kal's damage bonus?
  • Does the Orb of Rok'al add damage or corruption to Sermons?
  • Do you lose the Orb of Rok'al's corruption hits if you are not holding it?
  • Does Void Swarm's Dark Stone eating also take an item that a Dark Stone upgrade is attached to?
  • Does an effect that makes a hero lose Dark Stone also take an item that has a Dark Stone icon?
  • Does Dark Stone hidden in a Tomb Chest count for effects that look for Dark Stone?
  • Does a Dark Stone Tomb Chest protect from Corruption?
  • Does a rune with a Dark Stone icon give you a free Dark Stone?
  • Does the Unique Rune from the Blacksmith add Corruption at the end of an adventure?
  • Does the Shadow Bracelet's +1 Initiative apply when it is not activated?
  • Can Deflection Field or Shadow Bracelet be activated outside a Fight so it lasts into the next Fight?
  • Can an encounter steal a Dark Stone Tomb Chest and its contents?
  • Does the Hunting Knife reroll apply to all melee to-hit dice, and can Grit be traded for it?
  • Does a Coach Gun critical hit get both its critical bonus damage and the Ignore Defense effect?
  • Can the Lost Army Musket's D8 damage apply to its +2 Combat bonus?
  • Do 'Uses D8 for Damage' weapons also roll a D8 to hit?
  • When two Boxcars hits are rolled against adjacent enemies, is the d6 damage rolled once or separately for each enemy?
  • How does the Stagecoach's 15 XP bonus work, and who gets it?
  • When can the Book of the Mad King be read, and does its wound ignore Defense on Tough enemies?
  • Can the Shaman Staff cancel a Darkness card that is already in play?
  • Does a Transfusion Kit's 'on the D6 roll of 3+ (except during a Fight)' condition apply to both options?
  • How many shots does the Scorch Pistol's fuel token allow?
  • Does the Trun Disintegrator have a Strength requirement?
  • Does the Trun Disintegrator's 1 Grit cost apply to every shot, including adjacent targets?
  • Does the Dark Stone Club's corruption hit apply when the club is not equipped, or with ranged attacks or dynamite?
  • Is the Bandit Sword's extra combat from taking Corruption hits mandatory?
  • Is damage capped at +3 when the initiative gap is large with the Kusarigama?
  • Do multiple Marks on equipped gear add their bonuses against a creature with several keywords?
  • Can the Extractor remove Corruption from another hero?
  • Can Animal Allies carry and use items, such as the Worn Saddle Bag?
  • Can more than one hero ride a horse, or use more than one transport at a time?
  • How many hands do allies need to use Blacksmith Tools or other specialist items?
  • Can a Harmonica's sanity restoration be used on another hero?
  • Does the Flag of the Fallen's heal-every-turn effect apply to allies, and does the carrier earn XP for it?
  • Does the Old Lantern stay with one hero, and what happens when its bearer dies?
  • Are you still covered by a Lantern's light while looking through a door into another tile?
  • Can a posse carry several lanterns, and can more than one light source be lit at a time?
  • Can you use a Hidden Darkstone item during an adventure and still count it as hidden toward the Tomb Chest limit?
  • Do gear and artifact cards go back into their deck when they are used, sold, or lost?
  • Do you gain the XP printed on a Loot or Scavenge card?
  • Can a hero buy any gear card from the deck, or only items listed on the Town sheets?
  • Can a hero buy multiple copies of the same item, such as two Pick Axes?
  • Does a Pick Axe's +1 Darkstone bonus apply to Darkstone found as loot when the Pick Axe is not equipped?
  • Can a Gunslinger's Outlaw Gunbelt be used while the hero has the Law keyword from an Otherworld badge?
  • Can a Preacher use a Spirit Bow, and what keyword is needed to use it?
  • How much carry weight do Clothing items save under Rancher's Dressed for Adventure?
  • Is the Darkstone Belt Buckle an upgrade that replaces another belt?
  • Does Scavenger's Hat heal one wound or one wound per 6 rolled when you Scavenge?
  • Do the Locket's or other D3-based bonuses add to the D3 result or to a D6?
  • Can a shotgun use Dark Stone bullets?

Enemies

  • Do Wounds that are not Hits, such as Dynamite or Call Your Shot, count for XP?
  • Does Dynamite ignore a Tough enemy's Defense?
  • Does Dynamite instantly destroy a Corpse Pile?
  • How much XP is an Elite enemy worth?
  • How is XP awarded for a large enemy that gives base XP plus XP per wound?
  • Are multiplied enemy values worked out before Elite and Darkness bonuses are added?
  • If you must place more enemies than you have models for, does each shortfall add another Elite ability?
  • Can enemy packs from other sets be mixed into one threat deck with the base game?
  • How many Elite abilities can one enemy have?
  • Does an Elite ability that duplicates one already granted by another effect get re-rolled?
  • Do Elite abilities get rolled again for each fight, or are they set once for the whole adventure?
  • Do you need a miniature for every enemy you might draw?
  • How does the Undead Gunslinger Challenge work?
  • When is the Undead Gunslinger a Challenge, and when is he a normal enemy fight?
  • Can you use a Wanted Poster when you win the Undead Gunslinger Challenge?
  • Can a Cursed Body from a Lumia Vampire be destroyed like a Corpse Pile?
  • Do Lost Army soldiers each fire shots equal to all Lost Army soldiers in line of sight?
  • Does an ability that ignores Defense also ignore Armor?
  • If another hero moves next to an enemy already fighting a hero, does the enemy switch to the new hero?
  • Are Cynder enemies immune to Hellfire tokens because they come from the Cynder OtherWorld?
  • Where does Colonel Scafford go in an enemy group, and what models represent the lieutenant?
  • How do I use the threat cards from the Scafford Gang deluxe enemy pack?
  • Does a Wasteland Scavenger get +Combat from anvils its target carries but has not equipped?
  • Is there a maximum number of dice an enemy can roll in one attack?
  • When does a Scafford Gang act and fire in a firefight?
  • Does an area attack hit an Extra Large enemy once, or once for each space its base covers?
  • Do enemies in a Roaring Challenge switch to the Sumo if they cannot reach it?
  • Is the Hell Cannon's damage rolled separately for each model in each square of its path?
  • Does the Dark Stone Hydra use its Low Threat health when drawn as a Low Threat?
  • How much damage does the Rats Nest deal when some rats cannot be placed?
  • Do Heroes earn XP for inflicting Bleeding markers?
  • Which enemies have Ranged attacks?
  • What do the numbers in brackets on enemy abilities, such as Terror (2), mean, and do several Terror sources stack?
  • How much damage does a Horror hit from the Necronauts' Hellbat ability do?
  • How are enemies placed on a new tile?
  • Can enemies be placed on map spaces that are less than half a space?
  • How many Serpentmen Tribe cards are in play, and when is one discarded?
  • Do Swamp Slugs have a ranged attack without the Spitting Acid elite ability?
  • At what posse level do monsters gain Elite abilities or switch to the Brutal side?
  • Do bounties and vendettas against Void Spiders also affect Ancient Spiders?
  • Do Poison hits always give Poison markers?
  • Does the Scafford Gang's Bitter Feud bonus stack with another enemy's Bitter Feud bonus?
  • Does an Elite ability gained from a Drifter upgrade give XP?
  • When Undead appear in the Lawman's scenario, do the extra Elite abilities apply to every group?
  • If an item lets me ignore Tough, does it also work on other abilities that make an enemy immune to Critical Hits?
  • When do Fear, Terror or Unspeakable Terror trigger?
  • Does a model with several Burning markers take 2 Wounds for each marker at the start of its activation?
  • Can a Large enemy push aside small and medium enemies?
  • Which enemies and abilities count as Spells for spell-related card effects?
  • Can Cougar Strike hit an Eye hit location on a monster?
  • Does Night Mist poison give a Poison marker?
  • Can a Hero use a Revive Token to remove Burning or other status markers?
  • Does a Void Hound's Defense change with the attacking Hero's initiative?
  • What does the Void Sorcerer's Void Magik ability do each turn?
  • What spell level are Void Magik spells cast at?
  • What does 'Draw 2 Elite Threat cards' mean on an Epic Threat?
  • What does the Fanatic keyword on a Wasteland Warband card do?
  • How do Elite Threat encounters set the threat level?
  • Do enemy trait cards apply to variants such as Bogbats?
  • Does a Centurion's ability still trigger if the Centurion is killed?
  • Do Bandit Reinforcements in the Village Raid get a free Elite ability when there are not enough models?
  • Does an enemy with Changes Targets Each Round pick a new target after its previous target?
  • Does Legendary give a monster extra stats for every model of the threat, or only one?
  • Does a Dark Stone Hydra threat card summon more than one Hydra?
  • Do you ever draw from a threat deck other than the one matching your hero count?
  • Do the Horror hits from several Corpse Piles add up together?
  • Does an enemy's Defense apply against damage from abilities such as Shoot Through?
  • Can monsters target a hero on a neighbouring map tile?
  • How do enemies divide their attacks among several heroes in range?
  • Do Elite abilities apply to enemies added by a Corpse Pile's respawn?
  • Does the Serpentmen Shaman have a ranged attack with a limited range?
  • Do critical-hit bonuses still apply against enemies immune to critical hits, such as Tough enemies?
  • Do regeneration effects stack, such as a mutation plus Colonel Scafford's Elite ability?
  • How many Wounds does a Hero take from Poison markers?
  • Can boss monsters such as the Harbinger appear in the mines?
  • Does a Bleeding marker reduce Wounds, and what happens to Health when it is removed?
  • When are Bleeding markers removed?
  • Does the Sheriff's Bounty use the brutal XP value for brutal monsters?
  • In what order do Custodians act: electroshock, then defense lasers, then melee?
  • How many copies of each enemy do you need for the threat cards?
  • If Void Spiders are in an OtherWorld and a new group of an OtherWorld variant such as Ancient Spiders enters play, what happens?
  • How much XP does the Dark Acolyte High Priest give when defeated?
  • Which level does a Werewolf use for its attacks against a Henchman?
  • Do Wasteland Scavenger Heavies work like Wasteland Warlords?
  • How many Void Venom markers does a Hero get when several Void Spiders hit at once?
  • What happens to a Hellfire token that has no enemy in its space?
  • Does a Flesh Stalker's Fiendish Goal 5+ wounds test count wounds from a single occurrence?

Fights

  • When does a Fight begin once enemies are placed on the board?
  • Does an Ambush during a Fight start a second Fight?
  • Does a Fight end only when every enemy on the board is defeated, even those far away?
  • What does 'Once per Fight' mean on an item or ability?
  • Are Ambush enemies placed in a checkerboard, and where do they go?
  • How are immobile enemies such as Corpse Piles and Targa Pylons placed when they ambush?
  • Which Heroes does an Ambush hit when the party is spread across tiles or split between Worlds?
  • If an Ambush adds Enemies to a Fight already under way, do the Enemies of that Type already on the board get the +2 Initiative?
  • Do Ambushing Enemies keep their +2 Initiative after their first turn?
  • What happens if an Ambush starts during Scavenging or from a Darkness card mid-turn?
  • Can Enemies be placed on a map space that is less than half a full space?
  • Do Fear and Terror Horror Hits stack per Enemy or per Enemy Type?
  • Who activates first when a Hero and an Enemy have the same Initiative?
  • Is a Horror Hit defended with Defense or Willpower, and does Spirit Armor stop it?
  • When adjacent to an enemy, do you roll for movement or make the Escape test first, and do you still gain Grit?
  • Do you roll a separate Escape test for every adjacent Enemy you pass?
  • If a Hero fails an Escape test while moving through occupied squares, where does it stop?
  • Does an ability that lets a Hero move through models also let it pass Escape tests?
  • Is an Enemy diagonal to a Hero adjacent?
  • How much do Heroes heal at the end of a Fight with Catch Your Breath?
  • Do Heroes who acted in earlier rounds still get the D6 Catch Your Breath reward?
  • Does the turn end when a Fight ends, before Catch Your Breath is resolved?
  • How many Loot cards does each Hero draw after a Fight?
  • Do the Heroes get Loot for a Threat card that only tells them to draw more Threat cards?
  • Do Enemies added by a Darkness card, an Encounter or a Depth Event give Loot?
  • Do you get Loot if the Darkness escapes or every Hero is KO'd during the final Fight?
  • How do you deal Loot when more Heroes draw than the deck has cards?
  • Do you draw Loot after defeating the Epic Threat that ends the game?
  • Do Base XP and per-Wound XP both apply when a Hero wounds a large Enemy?
  • Do Hits that cause no Wounds give any XP against a large Enemy?
  • Do you gain extra XP for overkill damage when an Enemy dies?
  • Does dynamite earn XP, and does its blast count as a Hit?
  • Do Free Attacks earn Base XP separately, and does Variable XP count Wounds across all of an Attack's Hits?
  • Do all the Enemies in a group attack a Hero at the same time, and does the Hero roll Defense together?
  • How do Enemies choose their target, and do they switch targets?
  • Do you still roll Hold Back the Darkness during a Fight, and does turn order still apply?
  • What are the steps of a turn during a Fight, and is there a separate Fight turn?
  • If Enemies are revealed in a room, can the Heroes explore instead of fighting?
  • Can the Heroes leave Immobile Enemies, such as Targa Pylons, rather than destroy them?
  • Can Heroes trade items or heal each other when enemies are elsewhere on the map?
  • Do you need an Escape test to drag a KO'd Hero away from an adjacent Enemy?
  • Can a Hero move again after attacking, for example after a Free Attack?
  • When a Threat card adds more models of an Enemy Type already in the Fight, do they get the existing Elite ability?
  • Do you still get end-of-Fight rewards when a Mission ends with a Fight?
  • Must Fast as Lightning's three hits be made all at once during a move?
  • Is it legal to block a doorway with Heroes so that only two Enemies can attack at once?
  • When can you redraw a Threat card with an ability or item?

Hero Attacks

  • What is the most dice a Hero can roll for one attack?
  • Does the Hero attack dice limit apply to enemies?
  • Do extra attacks and area abilities get their own 8-dice limit?
  • Can a Hero make a melee attack and a ranged attack in the same turn?
  • Can a Hero with no melee weapon still make a melee attack?
  • Does a ranged attack use Combat or Shots, and can a Hero choose the attack type before rolling?
  • Can the hits from one attack be split between two or more enemies?
  • In what order are to-hit rolls, hit assignment and damage resolved?
  • Can Grit re-roll the damage dice for hits assigned to one enemy?
  • When you re-roll with Grit, must you re-roll every die?
  • When several hits hit one enemy, is its Defense subtracted from each hit separately?
  • Does Defense reduce damage that is not a Hit, such as Dynamite or a card that just says damage?
  • Are Armor dice rolled once for all the wounds from one attack, or once per hit?
  • Does Armor stop wounds from critical hits and from Dynamite?
  • What does a Critical Hit do to an enemy's Defense, and do Tough enemies take critical hits?
  • Does a -1 To Hit modifier stop a natural 6 from being a Critical Hit?
  • How much XP does a Hero get for wounding a large enemy in one attack?
  • Does a free attack on a Large enemy earn the base XP again?
  • Can a Hero use a ranged weapon while an enemy is adjacent, and who must take the hits?
  • Does excess damage from one hit carry over to another enemy?
  • Do Heroes or other figures block line of sight for ranged attacks?
  • Are diagonal spaces adjacent for Dynamite and other adjacency effects?
  • How many Free Attacks can a Hero make in one turn?
  • Can a Hero make a Free Attack and a regular attack in the same turn?
  • When in its activation can a Hero make a Free Attack?
  • Do Combat bonuses from other weapons or gear add to a Free Attack?
  • Do item bonuses worded for Attacks apply to a Free Attack?
  • Can a Free Attack score a critical hit?
  • Can a Hold-Out Pistol make a Free Attack when no hand is free, or act as a regular weapon?
  • How often can the Saloon Girl's Hold-Out Pistol fire, and can it be combined with dual wielding?
  • Does throwing a Dynamite token use a To Hit roll?
  • Can you throw Dynamite when a monster is adjacent to you, or past an adjacent monster?
  • Can Dynamite be thrown at the space the Hero is standing on?
  • If Dynamite would bounce into a wall, does the cancelled bounce still count?
  • Does a Hero gain XP for kills made with Dynamite?
  • Can Dynamite damage an Extra Large enemy more than once when it covers several spaces?
  • Does a Marshal's Badge let a Bandido throw extra Dynamite?
  • Do damage bonuses such as +1 Damage apply to Dynamite?
  • Is there a penalty for dual wielding two melee weapons?
  • Can you get critical hits when dual wielding ranged weapons?
  • Does the off-hand gun take a to-hit penalty when dual wielding?
  • Can a Bandido or Outlaw ignore the dual-wielding penalties?
  • How many dice does a hero roll when dual wielding two pistols?
  • Must a Hero fire both ranged weapons when dual wielding?
  • Can a Hero with a Prehensile Tail fire three one-handed guns at once?
  • Can a Hero dual wield a one-handed gun and a two-handed gun?
  • Does the Prehensile Tail give a Hero an extra attack?
  • Does a Cavalry Saber let a Hero make a melee and a ranged attack, and can both crit?
  • Can a Gunslinger's six-shooter special shot be applied to each of two pistols' hits?
  • Is the Hell Pistol's extra damage added before or after the damage roll?
  • Is a Cerberus Shot a free attack, and what does it do?
  • Do flat damage bonuses get doubled by a Hellfire Shot?
  • Can a Ricochet Shot target an enemy that is out of range or not adjacent?
  • Must a Gunslinger spend special shots every time, and is ammo tracked?
  • Does a +1 Shot give an extra die or an extra attack?
  • How does the Saloon Girl's Rapid Strike +1 Combat work when she kills an adjacent enemy?
  • On what roll do D8 damage weapons, such as the Splitter, critical hit?
  • Does a +1 Combat bonus add a die to a melee attack?
  • If a card adds Damage to an attack, is the bonus added to each hit?
  • Do melee bonuses from several weapons and abilities add together?
  • Do several +Damage modifiers against the same keyword stack when they come from different sources?
  • Can a Sermon benefit from Righteous Fury or other bonuses to Hits?
  • Can a Sermon such as Weaken be cast between assigning hits and rolling damage?
  • Can you cast a ranged Sermon without line of sight?
  • Does a Sermon's damage still face the enemy's Defense?
  • Does the adjacent-enemy rule for ranged hits apply when a Preacher casts Smite on a farther monster?
  • Do Spinning Kick or a Sermon use up the Hero's attack?
  • Does Endurance's damage cap apply to Sermon damage such as Smite?
  • How does Sharpshooter work: which squares count as behind the target, and does Defense apply to its damage?
  • Do a Rancher's kills give extra shots, and does Trun Disintegrator cost Grit for each shot?
  • How does the Sword Master's extra combat die work after killing an adjacent enemy?
  • When Whirling Strike or Swingin' Fists hits every adjacent enemy, is each adjacent enemy a separate roll?
  • Does a Combat-raising item such as Tools of Science count toward Whirling Strike's full-Combat roll?
  • When Quake Smash hits extra targets, do those extra hits need their own to-hit rolls?
  • Does the Assassin's From the Shadow ability, which applies to any Hit, affect every hit made or only one?
  • Can Acrobatic Strike deal its Wound to every enemy space a Hero passes through in one turn?
  • How does Shoot Through work: which spaces count as behind the first enemy, and is a line of fire required?
  • Does an Outlaw Pistol's 6 become two critical hits against an adjacent target?
  • How does the Gunslinger's Call Your Shot bonus work with hits, re-rolls and damage?
  • How does Spectacles' once-per-turn re-roll work when you make several shots?
  • Does Entangling Vines' damage earn XP, and how is it calculated?
  • How much damage does the Sorceress's Tsunami spell deal to Heroes versus enemies?
  • Does Trederran terrain give Cover against melee attacks?
  • How many Quickdraw attacks does a Gunslinger get when several cards place monsters?
  • Does a combat-doubling effect double only base Combat, or also item and ability bonuses?
  • Must you decide to use Void Enhancement before rolling the damage?
  • Can a spell or healing item interrupt an attack to heal or kill?
  • Must you declare an ability that modifies a hit before rolling the dice?
  • Does range count to the square the monster stands on?
  • How is XP awarded when a Hero's hits overkill an enemy?
  • Does a Saloon Girl's Parry wound earn the base XP as well as +5 per wound?
  • In what order are a roll, its re-rolls, critical effects and modifiers resolved?
  • Does a spell described as a ranged attack need a ranged attack roll?
  • Do Sweeping Strike hits get the bonus damage from an Oni Club?
  • Does a bonus that applies only to ranged hits apply to the melee hits made by the same weapon?
  • How does Through-Shot's extra damage work, and can it critically hit?

Enemy Movement and Attacks

  • Does each enemy Hit get its own Defense roll, or can one roll cover all of an enemy's hits?
  • Does an enemy's Combat value apply to its ranged attacks?
  • Do enemies get critical hits on To Hit rolls of 6 or more?
  • If one enemy hit ignores Defense, do the other hits from the same attack still get Defense rolls?
  • Does Tentacles' Smash, which ignores Defense on a 6, also remove Defense against the 5s?
  • Do enemies roll for damage, or does each hit they land deal a fixed amount?
  • When an ability turns one roll into extra Hits, such as a Strangler's 6 or Night Terror Claws, how many Defense rolls do you make?
  • What counts as a single source of damage when an item prevents damage from one source?
  • When an ability triggers when a Hero takes Wounds from a Slasher, is each Slasher a separate source?
  • When several Slashers are adjacent to a Hero who fails an Escape roll, how many hits does Spiked Shell deal?
  • Do Fear or Terror effects from several enemies stack, and is each enemy model counted separately?
  • How many Willpower saves does a Horror Hit need, and what does each failed save cost?
  • When is a Terror effect's Willpower check made?
  • Do a Hellbat's Nightmarish Horror Hits still apply when its Combat Hits are defended?
  • Do enemies with Flight, or an ability that changes targets each turn, pick a new target every turn?
  • Do enemies already adjacent to their target move again on later turns?
  • If an enemy's target moves away or is KO'd partway through a turn, can the enemy switch to a new Hero that same turn?
  • How does an enemy choose which Hero to attack?
  • When different enemy types share a room, do their targets have to be spread across the Heroes together?
  • Do enemies deliberately pick targets so they can hit several Heroes at once?
  • When an enemy moves in to attack, does it stop at the first free space next to its target?
  • When a Large or Extra Large enemy moves through smaller enemies, which of them are displaced?
  • Can a flying enemy push other models out of the way when it moves?
  • Can enemies stack on one space, and what happens to extra enemies when a corridor is blocked?
  • Does an enemy with a Ranged attack move in to melee range?
  • Does an enemy's extra ranged attack stop it from moving and making its melee attack?
  • Do the Shots of a ranged enemy count as Hits for modifiers?
  • How do Shootout and Assault ranged enemies differ?
  • How does a Shootout enemy that starts next to a Hero act, and does it shoot Heroes out of range?
  • How does Cover work against incoming enemy attacks?
  • In what order are Cover, Defense, Armor and Endurance applied to incoming hits?
  • How many Burning Markers does Lava Men's Burning Fists add when they roll 6s?
  • Do enemy groups attack one after another or at the same time?
  • When one enemy's attack hits several Heroes, is the roll made once or separately for each Hero?
  • Does a once-per-turn ability that lets you reroll a failed Defense roll reroll one die or the whole roll?
  • Can a Hero use bandages or whiskey between the Hits of one enemy attack?
  • How do Goliath's Flailing Tentacles attack the Heroes within reach?
  • Can enemies with ranged attacks fire through other models to hit targets behind them?
  • Does an Enemy that is displaced, by a larger Enemy moving through it, need to choose a new target if it is still adjacent to its original target after being displaced?

Gates and OtherWorlds

  • Can you mix cards and tiles from different core sets, such as Swamps and City of the Ancients, in one game?
  • Are the item and encounter decks kept separate for each OtherWorld?
  • Do enemies move through Gate tiles like any other tile?
  • Can enemies attack Heroes who are in a different World?
  • How is the World behind a gate chosen, and what if the set has only one OtherWorld?
  • If you open a second gate while in an OtherWorld, where does it lead?
  • When does a World card go back into the deck?
  • If a gate leads to a World of the same type as the one you are in, does it count as a different World?
  • Must a Hero step through a gate after looking through it?
  • Can you enter an OtherWorld through a gate during a mission, and do you use the same exploration tokens there?
  • Are gates to other worlds used in your first game, or only in advanced play?
  • Do Gate icons on exploration tokens act as Doors in the basic missions?
  • What do you do when a drawn OtherWorld map tile cannot be placed, or when the tiles run out?
  • How does the Old Lantern's light reach through a gate?
  • In an OtherWorld, which Threat deck do Threat draws use, including lower Threats drawn by Epic Threats or Chest Portal cards?
  • Does the OtherWorld name and icon on an enemy's Threat card change how it plays?
  • Can a Hero scavenge in an OtherWorld?
  • Can clues for a mission be found in an OtherWorld?
  • Can a posse start a mission in an OtherWorld instead of the Mines?
  • If the World card drawn for a gate is the Mines, is it a normal Mine, and do you draw Mine Artifacts?
  • Can you play Forest of the Dead missions with only the City of the Ancients and Dark Stone core sets?
  • Does the Transporter Malfunction encounter take a Hero off a Derelict Ship mission when the No Gates rule applies?
  • When a Hero selects a random World, should the current World card be shuffled back into the deck first?
  • What happens if you look through a Gate while all of the World Cards are still in play?
  • Can a posse that enters an OtherWorld through a portal keep the original mission map?

The Targa Plateau

  • Are Targa Pylons enemies that you have to fight?
  • How does the Targa Pylon's Burning Laser roll its damage hits?
  • What does the Bandido's Wild Card do on the Targa Plateau?

Campaign Play

  • Can items or abilities that say once per Turn be used in Town?
  • How does the Saloon's Pickpocket location work?
  • Can curses and parasites be removed at the regular Church or Doc's Office?
  • What does Unwanted Attention do during a Town Stay?
  • Can a Holy hero such as a Preacher become Law at the Sheriff's Office?
  • Can heroes trade items in Town if they are not in the same location?
  • Can you wait to spend XP and level up until later in an adventure?
  • When you level up mid-adventure, do you fully heal and gain a Grit?
  • Do higher maximum Health or Sanity heal you on level-up, and does a higher max Grit give extra Grit?
  • Can a Saloon Girl use every once-per-visit Saloon service during one town stay?
  • Can you use Grit to reroll a Town Event roll?
  • Does the darkness counter move when a town day has no event?
  • Must heroes travel and stay in town between adventures?
  • Do Gear and Artifacts stay with a hero between adventures?
  • Can a hero visit town more than once before the next adventure?
  • Are a Mission and an Adventure the same thing?
  • When do Health and Sanity fully heal between adventures, and does damage from town carry over?
  • Can a new player join or leave a campaign between sessions?
  • Does Frontier Town replace the town stay rules?
  • When are Archive Markers discarded?
  • Can you use a stagecoach or horses bought in town after travelling to a new world?
  • When heroes split up in town and visit the same location, how are location events rolled?
  • When you level up, does your experience go back to 0?
  • Do level-up upgrades from the random chart stack with each other?
  • In a one-big-fight mission, do heroes also draw normal post-fight loot?
  • After a failed or fled adventure, do 'at the end of each adventure' item effects still trigger?
  • Is there a limit to how many days a posse can stay in Town?
  • If Mr. Scratch's deal comes up again, who is taken away?
  • Does a Remains in Play effect stay in play for the whole campaign?
  • Do you reshuffle every deck between missions?
  • How does the Stagecoach handle travel hazards for the posse?
  • Can the posse flee a mine, and what happens if it does?
  • If a Travel Hazard roll repeats the same hazard, do you face it again?
  • What is the order when arriving in town after a mission?
  • Are destroyed Frontier Town buildings still destroyed on the next visit?
  • When do you roll for travel hazards, and is it once per hero?
  • Does a repeated Mr. Scratch hazard result cause the penalty?
  • Can heroes that have leveled up be brought into expansions?
  • Does the reward roll for A Fistful of Dark Stone happen once for the group or once per hero?
  • Does riding a horse to the mine count as traveling for the mount's bonus XP?
  • Are Specimen Jars reusable, or must you buy a new one for each specimen?
  • If a Darkstone explosion hits the Frontier Outpost, do heroes already there lose their day?
  • Can heroes in the same posse each buy the same item in Town?
  • Where and when can you sell items in Town?
  • Can you sell Item tokens such as herbs or tonics in Town?
  • How much can items bought in Town be sold for?
  • Must all heroes stay in town for the same number of days?

Advanced and Optional Rules

  • Can a party of one or two Heroes fight Epic Threat enemies, and which deck is drawn instead?
  • Under the Fixed Hero Move rule, can you claim 4 Move and still roll for Grit?
  • Can Grit be used to reroll a random stat gain on the Upgrade Chart?
  • Does a hero immune to Weather also ignore cards that carry the Weather keyword, such as Blood Rain?
  • In Up Against the World mode, can unused Heroic Efforts cards be kept for later fights?
  • Is using a map tile's special encounter mandatory?
  • In a fixed-map mission, when do the Advanced Encounters trigger?
  • What does the Advanced Encounters icon in the bottom-left corner of a map tile mean?
  • With Advanced Encounters on, are the room's encounters ignored in a mission's objective room?
  • If an Exploration Token and an Advanced Encounter both produce enemies, are they fought separately or together?
  • Is there a special rule when the Darkness marker passes the Hero marker on the Depth Track?
  • Can a hero help a knocked-out hero recover, and what does it cost?

General Questions

  • Can the revised rulebook be used with first-edition or original core set components?
  • Are the latest FAQs still needed alongside the revised rulebook?
  • Can card decks from different core sets and expansions be combined?
  • Can expansion darkness and Shadow Magik cards, and enemy packs from other expansions, be mixed with the core sets?
  • Is adjacency diagonal as well as orthogonal?
  • Does 're-roll a single roll' mean one die or the whole roll?
  • How does the Ambition mechanic differ from Grit?
  • When are Frontier Outpost bounties collected?
  • Do bounty payouts go to every Hero or get split between Heroes?
  • When Gambling, does a Gold bonus from an item or location apply once per Gamble event or once per successful roll?
  • Are Outlaw heroes barred from staying at the hotel or inn during the town phase?
  • Are Serpentmen Tribe cards discarded after a fight?
  • For the Last Stand mission, if an entry point already has a marker, do monsters still appear when the D6 shows a 1 or 2?
  • Can a Law hero use an item bought at the Smuggler's Den, such as illegal ammo, if a non-Law hero buys it and trades it over?
  • How does selling Dark Stone at the Frontier Outpost work with its d6 roll?
  • How do flying models and teleporting movers count spaces across a rooftop?
  • Where is the Plan of Attack token used?
  • Can the tutorial mission be replayed as many times as you like?
  • How does the Bandits travel hazard resolve?
  • What does a hero learn from Hellfire Markers referenced by the Cleansing Fire sermon?
  • Is the XP from a Loot or Scavenge card gained per card, and does Faith Healing also give XP for healing?
  • Does the Town event 'all prices are +$50' raise the cost of services and gambling as well as goods?
  • Can a hero give an item bought in Town to another hero?
  • What does Days since last event mean on Town boards?
  • Can you visit the Camp Site location in the Blasted Wastes Barter Town?
  • Is cancelling a card different from discarding it?
  • Does the Darkstone Horseshoes owner count the Dark Stone it carries toward the Badland Expedition Dark Stone damage threshold?
  • Are the Rulebook and the Adventure Book the same for both core sets of City of the Ancients?
  • Can the game take five or six players, and how do you play with one core set?
  • In 5 Card Draw, do you get your bet back if you win?

Shadows of Brimstone: Allies of the Old WestExpansion

  • Do allies count toward posse size for threat level and revive tokens, and how?
  • When buying an ally, can I choose between the Basic and Advanced versions?
  • Do Advanced Henchmen have to be paid again each adventure, and does resurrecting one cost extra?
  • Can an Advanced Henchman's owner also bring two basic Henchmen on a mission?
  • Can the same Ally Specialty be taken more than once in a Hero posse?
  • Do Allied XP and Hero XP interact when an ally kills an enemy?
  • Does a Growing Dread card count as 'played' for the Henchman's Check It Out roll?
  • Do Animal Allies roll for Lava spaces, and what happens when an ally must make a skill test?
  • Can side bag tokens such as bandages be used on animal allies?
  • Can a hero sell items belonging to an ally while in town?
  • Can Allies roll skill tests on encounter cards, and can they be chosen as the random hero?
  • What is the Faithful Dog's Runs Ahead ability for?
  • Does the Followers of the Faith ally's healing work only during a fight?
  • Is the Henchman sheet misprinted, since the advanced Henchman costs less than the basic one?