Rivals for Catan FAQ
112 questions players ask · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · Full rulebook
Introductory Game and Setup
Game Turn
- How does the basic 3-for-1 trade work, and where do the three resources come from?
- What is the trade rate for gold, and how do Gold Ships and Mints change it?
- Can gold stand in for any other resource when building or trading?
- What happens when a region already holds 3 resources and produces another?
- When you build a settlement, can you choose which new region goes above and which below?
- Does building a city increase production from the adjacent regions?
- How many action cards can you play in one turn?
- What does the 1x marking on a card mean?
- Can a production booster or large trade ship sit on the second building site of a city, above or below it?
- Can I build a city on top of an existing city to deny the last city?
- Can I build a road above or below a settlement?
- Can you still build roads, settlements or cities once their cards run out?
- Is there a limit on how many heroes you can have in your principality?
Hand Limit and Drawing Cards
- When does your hand refill if it drops during your opponent's turn, or after a Spy takes a card?
- When refilling your hand, can you look at each card as you draw it before choosing the next stack?
- Can you pay resources to look through a whole draw stack and take the card you want?
- Can I pay to search a stack when refilling my hand, or only when exchanging a card?
- After exchanging a card, can I draw the replacement from any draw stack, not only the one I returned to?
- After paying to search a draw stack, must you shuffle it before returning it?
- Where do discarded cards go, and may a draw stack run empty?
- Are the draw stacks shared, or does each player have their own?
- Where do played action cards and removed buildings go: the discard pile or a draw stack?
- If a card lets you draw up to two cards while you already hold three, can you keep and play the extra cards this turn?
Other Rules
- If strength totals are tied, does the hero token change hands?
- Which resolves first, the production die or the event die?
- Do events such as Brigand Attack or Plentiful Harvest affect both players even when only one player rolled the dice?
- Who receives resources when the Celebration event is rolled?
- Where do event cards go after they are played, and how is the event deck rebuilt when Yule comes up?
The Goal & End of the Game
General Rules (Theme Games)
- Can you build a face-up expansion card without first drawing it into your hand?
- Does a card marked 1x mean it is a face-up expansion card?
- How many city expansion cards can a city hold, and where can they go?
- How many buildings or units can you remove from your principality in one turn?
- If a building is removed or destroyed, do the buildings that needed it keep working?
- Can I rearrange my starting region cards after I choose my starting cards?
- How do players choose their starting cards in a Theme Game?
- When I add a Theme Set, which event cards come with it?
- Which draw stacks are used in a Theme Game, and can you draw from any of them?
- When a card lets you take or pay two resources of your choice, can they be different types?
Theme Games, Special Rules and the Duel
Card Index: Basic Set
- How does a production booster such as the Brick Factory work?
- When must you discard the extra card after losing an Abbey?
- If you draw a second Abbey while one is already in your principality, must you discard it?
- How much gold does the Toll Bridge give when Plentiful Harvest is rolled?
- How does the Marketplace work, and can you build more than one?
- Does Year of Plenty help both players when an Abbey or Storehouse is next to a region?
- How does the Relocation card work, and can it move a card into an empty site?
- Does Merchant Caravan need two matching resources to discard?
- What does the Parish Hall do?
- How does the Feud event work, and which cards count as buildings?
- With Fraternal Feuds, do I choose the cards from the opponent's hand, or are they picked at random?
- Does Invention's maximum of 2 resources apply to the whole event or to each player?
- How do you play Brigitta the Wise Woman, and can she change the opponent's roll?
Card Index: The Era of Gold
- How is the Gold Cache played, and what does it need?
- Can gold already on a region move into the Gold Cache, or gold in the cache move back?
- Can the Gold Cache swap places with another region expansion through Relocation?
- With the trade advantage, how many resources do you take when Trade is rolled and you hold the Moneylender?
- Does Salt Silo keep doubling commerce for trade ships gained or lost after it is built?
- How does Reiner the Herald work with a Celebration event?
- When you play Merchant, must the resources your opponent gives you be ones they can store?
- How much gold does Gudrun, Terror of the Seas take, and can you play it with no Pirate Ships?
- Is the gold from a Pirate Ship given in addition to the normal Plentiful Harvest resource?
Card Index: The Era of Turmoil
- Do the Lookout Tower or Heinrich the Sentinel protect you against an Archer, Arsonist or Traitor, and how do they combine?
- Can you discard a Drill Ground to make room for a hero and still use its discount?
- Can the Arsonist destroy a building on any of a city's four building sites?
- Where does a building destroyed by the Arsonist go?
- Does Fire Brigade stop an Arsonist from removing an unwanted building in the same city?
Card Index: The Era of Progress
- Can Guido the Ambassador or Gustav the Librarian let you choose any card in the discard pile, and can you play it right away?
- When you build the Library, can you look through a draw stack and play any card you choose?
- If an Arsonist targets a Town Hall built on a Parish Hall, are both buildings destroyed?
- Do production boosters such as the Lumber Camp or Grain Mill double what Benjamin the Traveling Scholar gives?
- Which regions get resources when the Doctor is played through a Bath House?
- Does Plague cost a region that borders two cities more than one resource?
- Can I upgrade a Parish Hall to a Town Hall while the Parish Hall sits in a settlement?
Rivals for Catan: Age of DarknessExpansion
- Does the Lighthouse's directly adjacent trade ship mean only the single ship on the same side of the city?
- When you remove a Brigand Camp with Tactical Retreat, does the road it was placed on stay?
- Which cards are the face-up expansion cards for the Era of Intrigue?
- When you buy a resource from your opponent with the Trading Station, who receives the gold?
- Does Gero let you take just one resource from the bank instead of two?
- Does the extra gold from the Bishop come from your opponent or from the bank?
- Does the Brigand Camp pay you gold when your opponent gains a resource through the Marketplace but cannot store it?
- How often can I use the Secret Brotherhood's discard-for-a-resource ability?
- What does Judith protect, and does she guard the Church against Religious Dispute?
- When Marie the Shieldmaiden's demand resolves, does the incoming hero need an empty building site?
- Can I trade resources to pay for taking over Wolfgang the Street Performer?
- When the White Raven Tavern lets me roll the dice for gold, does the event die also take effect?
- When Olaf, Bera, Courthouse, Merchant or Trade Monopoly lets me choose resources to take from an opponent, which resources may I pick?
- What happens in a Barbarian Attack when my units equal the victory points from my cities, or when I have no city?
- Does a city count as two points when comparing victory points with units in a Barbarian Attack?
- Where is the Barbarian Stronghold placed, and does it change the units needed against a Barbarian Attack?
- When I use the Trading Post to buy a resource, does my opponent get the gold I pay?
- Are stockpiled strength or commerce points on region expansions like the Cloth Merchant's Residence available every turn?
- Must I downgrade a Residence when I use the Commercial Harbor?
- Can The Duel of the Princes combine three eras that include the Age of Darkness?
Rivals for Catan: Age of EnlightenmentExpansion
- Do Explorer ships count as units against city victory points for the Barbarian Attack?
- How does the Hospital's star and resource option work each turn?
- Does Public Feeling give stars when its adjacent region is rolled?
- Can you rotate a Pirate card right after discovering it, or only after winning the contest?
- Can Cartographer swap two islands that are already discovered, and does the swap change which one is face up?
- Can the Council of Sages owls or resources be split among several sages or regions?
- Does Robert, Herald of the Sages, let me win ties against pirates?
- Can I take a pirate to level 2 for the bounty after my opponent has rotated that pirate to level 3?
- Where are the Manifesto of Humane Conduct cards placed in the Era of Sages, and how do you get one?
- Can I discard an action attack card instead of paying two owls for the Manifesto of Humane Conduct?
- What can City Palace retrieve from the discard pile?
- Do sages' wisdom points replace or add to a region's resource production?