RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Hammer of the Scots thumbnail

Hammer of the Scots FAQ

192 questions players ask · Updated Nov 14, 2026 · Full rulebook

Game Turns1.0 Mapboard2.0 Armies3.0 The Cards4.0 Movement5.0 Battles6.0 Kings7.0 Wintering8.0 Scenarios9.0 VictoryGeneral

Game Turns

  • How many Game Turns are in a year?
  • In what order do the card, movement and battle phases run within a Game Turn?
  • Are all movements in a Game Turn completed before any battles are fought?
  • Can a player swap the card they committed for another one after it is revealed?
  • What happens when both players play Event cards in the same Game Turn, including Truce?
  • Is Wintering the last step of each year?

1.0 Mapboard

  • Does a Cathedral raise the Scottish castle limit for both wintering and Replacement Points?
  • Do cathedrals add to the castle limit for the English too?
  • Does a noble still get the home-area defence bonus after it has switched sides?

2.0 Armies

  • Is there a red (English) Moray block, and does Moray ever switch sides?
  • Do nobles ever go into a draw pool?
  • Which blocks start in the draw pools?
  • Do the French Knights stay in the Scottish draw pool if the Scots drop below 8 nobles?
  • When do the French Knights join the Scottish draw pool?
  • What happens if the Norse or French Knights are drawn for an inland area such as Badenoch or Lanark?
  • Do blocks drawn from the draw pool enter at full strength?
  • What is the movement rating of the French Knights?
  • Are there Irish units in the game, and do they ever refuse to fight?
  • Which blocks are exempt from castle limits?
  • Are blocks drawn from the Scottish draw pool random and face-down?
  • How does a noble defending its home area fight?
  • Can both players have a noble of the same name in play, such as two Bruces?
  • What happens to Wallace's block if he is eliminated in combat?
  • How can you tell which nobles belong to Bruce and which to Comyn?
  • Must both of Bruce or Comyn's home areas be enemy-occupied for them to switch sides?

3.0 The Cards

  • If a Pillage card reduces an enemy noble to zero strength, does it switch sides?
  • Are the Pillage card's two hits split across each enemy block, or applied to the whole group?
  • How are the hits from a Pillage card taken, and where do the stolen steps go?
  • Can Pillage be played against an enemy block when all your adjacent blocks are at full strength?
  • Does the opponent see which blocks took hits or gained steps when Pillage is played?
  • Can Pillage permanently remove a black-cross block such as Wallace?
  • Is a battle caused by a Herald defection fought immediately, before the opponent moves?
  • When a Herald card turns a noble, does it keep its current strength?
  • How does the Herald card work?
  • Can the Herald card eliminate Moray?
  • Can a noble turned by a Herald card retreat?
  • Can Scottish blocks raid into an empty England during a Truce?
  • If one player plays Truce, can either player still attack that turn?
  • If a Herald defection and a Truce are both played, does the battle still happen?
  • Must blocks be in coastal areas at both ends of a Sea Move?
  • Can one Sea Move gather blocks from two areas into one, or swap two blocks?
  • Can the English use Sea Move to move blocks out of England?
  • Can a Sea Move end in a neutral area, and can it reach Mentieth?
  • Do card values decide who moves first, and who goes first on a tie?
  • Does a player finish all moves from a higher-ranked card before the opponent acts?
  • Can a player play a movement card after an Event card in the same turn?
  • Does the card played to decide Player 1 return to the hand?
  • When Pillage turns a noble, which side is the attacker?

4.0 Movement

  • Can a block move more than once in a Game Turn, or move again later in the same movement phase?
  • Are border limits counted per border or per region, and do they apply to each player?
  • Do border limits reset each combat round?
  • Are the Buchan–Angus and Buchan–Mar borders one border or two for border limits?
  • Do blocks stop moving when they cross a green border or the black Anglo-Scottish line?
  • Must a block stop when it enters England, whichever border line it crosses?
  • What does crossing the Anglo-Scottish border cost, and does a crossing block lose movement?
  • How does an English Move 3 card work across the border?
  • Must a Norse move be declared with both its origin and destination?
  • Does the Norse block have to attack when it moves by sea?
  • Do the Norse attack during movement or in the battle phase?
  • Can the Norse move inland, enter England, or be moved by the Sea Move card?
  • Can the Norse sail to any coastal area, attack there, and hold it for the Scots?
  • Do border limits apply to the Norse block?
  • Can a pinned block be freed, or can reinforcements replace it?
  • Does pinning stop a block from retreating once a battle has started?
  • Can the defender move unpinned blocks out of an area the attacker entered, and across the border the attacker used?
  • Does pinning apply to the player who moves first?
  • Can the opponent move into an area that the attacker just vacated, to attack another area or occupy it?
  • What is the control status of an area that holds both Scottish and English blocks?
  • Can a group move through an enemy-occupied area without stopping if it avoids pinning?
  • Must you fight when you move into an area occupied by enemy blocks?
  • Can a player pin part of a group that is moving into an area?
  • Can the blocks of one group go to different destinations in a single group move?
  • Can a moving group pick up extra blocks along its route?
  • Do blocks moving together share one movement allowance?
  • What do movement points on a movement card pay for?
  • Is a block's movement allowance checked, or is movement on the honour system?
  • Is there a limit on how many blocks may stand in one area when not wintering?
  • Can a block move out of an area and then back into it in the same turn?

5.0 Battles

  • When a noble is eliminated in combat, does it switch sides at strength 1 or at its current strength?
  • Can a noble switch sides more than once in a single battle?
  • If a block cannot retreat when required, is it permanently removed or returned to the Draw Pool?
  • Are black-cross blocks permanently removed when they are killed in combat or cannot retreat?
  • Is a block eliminated by a Pillage card permanently removed from the game?
  • Is a non-noble block at one step eliminated when it takes a hit?
  • How are battle hits assigned when several land on the defenders?
  • In what order do blocks act in a combat round?
  • Why would a block pass in battle instead of fighting or retreating?
  • Can defending blocks retreat before the attacker makes its first combat roll?
  • Can a block fight in one round and retreat later in the same battle, while the rest of its group keeps fighting?
  • Can a defending block always retreat before the attackers roll?
  • How far can a retreating or regrouping block move?
  • Can a retreating block go back across the border it entered by?
  • Can a block retreat through a border the enemy used to enter the battle?
  • If both players used the same border to enter a battle, who may retreat through it?
  • How many blocks can retreat across a border, and do the limits reset each round?
  • Must the attacker retreat after the third combat round, and does the defender get a shot at it?
  • When does a battle end, and who is the victor?
  • If the attacker eliminates every defender in Round 1, who fights as attacker in Rounds 2 and 3?
  • Do reserves still fight in Round 2 if the main force retreats or is eliminated in Round 1?
  • Can reserve blocks fire, retreat or take hits in Round 1?
  • Which blocks make up the Main Attack Group, and which go into Reserve?
  • Do blocks the defender moves into a contested area fight only from Round 2?
  • Can a defender move reinforcements into a battle for free when attacked?
  • Which moves close borders for retreats?
  • Can the Norse join the main attack together with other blocks?
  • Where can a Norse block retreat or regroup?
  • Can the Norse retreat into an area emptied in the same battle?
  • Can the Norse retreat into an area that other blocks in the same battle just made Friendly?
  • When is the Celtic Unity loyalty roll made, and can a Welsh or Ulster block avoid it by retreating?
  • Does Celtic Unity apply to every Welsh or Ulster block in every battle, alone or with others?
  • How does the optional Schiltrom rule work?
  • When attackers outnumber defenders, which defenders are pinned?
  • Is there a cap on how many blocks can fight in one battle?
  • After a battle, can victorious blocks regroup into different areas?
  • Can victorious blocks regroup into an area where a battle is still pending?
  • Can other players see where retreating or regrouping blocks go?
  • Does a noble that defects during a battle get its home-area defence bonus?
  • Does a noble that marches back to reinforce its home area get the home-defence bonus?
  • What happens when Scottish blocks raid into England?
  • How are English blocks removed while Scottish blocks occupy England?
  • Can English blocks retreat or regroup into Scotland?
  • Can Scottish blocks retreat or regroup into England, even when England is empty?
  • Can Scottish raiders that entered England retreat back into Scotland?
  • Can English nobles retreat from a Scottish battle into England?
  • Can a block retreat into an area that was just emptied by another battle or a forward move?
  • Do units that moved into the battle area count for retreat options?
  • Do blocks from England and blocks from Scotland entering one battle form one group?

6.0 Kings

  • What does it take to crown Bruce or Comyn as King?
  • When a king is crowned, which nobles defect to the English?
  • In what order are several defection battles fought?
  • Where and at what strength does the Scottish King enter play?
  • What happens when Edward I is killed in battle?
  • Can Edward winter in Scotland, and can he winter two years running?
  • If Edward disbands voluntarily, does he return to the Draw Pool?
  • Does Edward start the game in the Draw Pool?
  • Can the Scots win by killing Edward twice, and does disbanding count as dying?
  • Does losing the last step of the Scottish King or Edward II to a Pillage card end the game?

7.0 Wintering

  • In what order do nobles go home at Wintering, and what happens if their home area is held by the other side?
  • Do nobles count against the castle limit at Wintering, and can a noble be disbanded to make room?
  • Must blocks disband at Wintering if they are over their area's castle limit, and what if a noble defects into the area?
  • Can the Scots disband a non-noble block at Wintering even when it is within the castle limit?
  • Which nobles can be disbanded at Wintering, and can a noble ever go into the draw pool?
  • What can Moray do at Wintering, and what happens when he is redrawn?
  • Where can the Scottish King go at Wintering, and does he count against castle limits?
  • Can Bruce or Comyn winter in either of its two home areas, whatever area it starts the year in?
  • What happens to Bruce or Comyn when both of its home areas are held by the enemy at Wintering?
  • If Bruce or Comyn winters in one home area, can other blocks winter in its other home area?
  • Can a noble that returns home for Wintering use its area's replacement points, and does the castle limit cap them?
  • Can Replacement Points build or draw in an empty area, such as an empty home area or cathedral?
  • Do blocks drawn or built at Wintering come in at full strength?
  • Can a block disbanded during Scottish Disbanding be drawn back for Scottish builds in the same Winter?
  • Can Replacement Points add steps to blocks already in an area that is at its castle limit?
  • Does a cathedral raise an area's castle limit and its replacement points?
  • Which blocks can the English strengthen with winter replacement points, and can Edward I receive them?
  • If the Norse or French block is drawn for an inland area such as Lanark or Badenoch, where does it go?
  • Does a Norse block still count against castle limits in winters after its first one?
  • What happens to the Norse block during Wintering?
  • When Edward I winters in Scotland, which blocks may winter with him and ignore the castle limit?
  • Is there an English Feudal Levy in a year when Edward I winters in Scotland?
  • Must Edward I be revealed before he winters with a levy?
  • Where do the English kings go at Wintering, since neither may winter in England?
  • Do English blocks left in England disband at Wintering, including archers, knights and Hobelars?
  • If Wallace or another Scottish block is in England at Wintering, must it disband, or can it move to Selkirk?
  • Are the Irish and Welsh mercenary blocks regular infantry that can winter in Scotland, and do they return to the pool when wintering removes them?
  • How many blocks does the English Feudal Levy draw each year after setup?
  • When do the French Knights enter the Scottish draw pool, and do they leave if the Scots drop below eight nobles?
  • Are blocks in the draw pool kept face down and drawn at random?
  • Where do disbanded blocks go, and is the black cross only for battle deaths?
  • Can the Scots or Edward leave the map during the year to avoid being killed?
  • Can Wallace winter in Selkirk Forest, and do English blocks there stop him?
  • What does Wallace gain by wintering in Selkirk Forest, and is he exempt from the castle-limit disband there?
  • What can Wallace do at Wintering if he is over the castle limit or cannot reach Selkirk?
  • Can any block other than Wallace winter in Selkirk Forest, which has no castle?
  • Does a noble going home at Wintering need to be within its movement rating?
  • What happens when both players play an Event card in the same Game Turn?

8.0 Scenarios

  • Which blocks start off the map or in the draw pool in Braveheart?
  • Where do the starting blocks go in each scenario, and at what strength?
  • How many blocks does England draw in the first year of each scenario?
  • Can Edward II appear in Braveheart?
  • Who is the Scottish King in The Bruce scenario, and is there a crowning?
  • Can Edward I winter in Scotland in 1306, and what happens to him in 1307?

9.0 Victory

  • Who wins if both sides control seven nobles at the end of Braveheart?
  • How does Moray change the noble count, and can the count tie?
  • When are victory conditions checked during a campaign?
  • Is a Winter Turn played after the final year, before nobles are counted?

General

  • Are Schiltroms a core rule or an optional rule?
  • Is the Schiltrom the only official optional rule in Hammer of the Scots?
  • Are there rules differences between the second and third editions of Hammer of the Scots?
  • Did the second edition change any block values from the first edition?
  • Is there an official mulligan rule in Hammer of the Scots?
  • Is there an official errata for the 2.3 rules?
  • Are the spare noble blocks placed in the draw pool during setup?