Friday
Do the cards you used against the first pirate come back for the second pirate?
The publisher answered this on BGG, and the rulebook's pirate sequence agrees.
- Henning · Publisher · 2012-03-26
- Friday rulebook · Rulebook · The Final Showdown Against the Pirates
Not right away. After you beat the first pirate, your face-up cards go to the Robinson discard. If the Robinson stack still has cards, you do not reshuffle; you carry on with the second pirate. The discard comes back only when the stack runs out and is reshuffled.