CATAN
If several ships point at the same fish shoal, who gets to catch the fish?
Several experienced players in the threads agree; there is no official ruling.
- WilbertK · Community · 2016-02-07
- RedPiranha · Community · 2018-01-08
Fish are caught on the active player's own turn. That player has the first chance to catch the fish, and if they decline, the other players may catch it. A shoal placed by a roll goes to whoever catches it on their own turn, even if someone else is better placed.