CATAN
After paying with fish, do the tokens go back into the supply?
One poster explains the discard-pile rule, which matches the rulebook text, but no second post confirms it.
- churchmouse · Community · 2012-03-19
No. Spent tokens go to a face-up discard pile and are reshuffled into the supply only when the supply runs out. Reshuffling early would change the odds of drawing the Old Boot.