CATAN
Can you trade with another player on better terms than the bank offers?
Several repliers cite a relayed FAQ answer, but the rulebook is silent and one reply disputes it.
- WilbertK · Community · 2024-09-15
- RedPiranha · Community · 2017-07-01
- WilbertK · Community · 2016-05-31
- jorganos · Community · 2024-09-20
- Der_cripple · Community · 2021-05-11disagrees
Disputed, and the stronger view is no. The rulebook sets no ratio for player trades, but repliers quote the publisher's FAQ saying a trade may not beat the bank's rate, so 5 Clay for 1 Stone in one trade is not allowed. The same result spread over several trades is the loophole people discuss.