RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
The Battle of Five Armies thumbnail

The Battle of Five Armies FAQ

369 questions players ask · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · Full rulebook

Setup and ComponentsThe Game TurnThe Action DiceEvent and Story CardsFateCharacters and LeadershipArmiesCombatVictory ConditionsAdditional Rules

Setup and Components

  • Can Gandalf's Blast of Magic or Thranduil's archery target an army in a Goblin Mustering Point or Mountain Pass?
  • Can Shadow recruitment events target Goblin Mustering Points and Mountain Passes?
  • Does the Battle of Five Armies include cloth bags, and what should be used for the pile setup instead?
  • Did the revised edition change any rules or cards?
  • Are the unit reference tables a separate part of the game?
  • Are regions separated by a river adjacent to each other?

The Game Turn

  • In the Recovery Phase, which player draws the Event and Story cards first?
  • Can the Lord of the Eagles be activated on the turn the Fate track brings him in?
  • If a General is mustered without tokens, can his other effects still be used?
  • Does the Front Gate have a ford, so that attacks across its border take the ford penalty?
  • Can an army move adjacent to an enemy and then move away, and must it stop when it moves next to an enemy?
  • Does the restriction on stopping next to an enemy apply to fast moves that come from card effects?
  • With a Move and Attack card, can you move to an empty region and then attack, or only attack the adjacent region?
  • Can an army that moves into a region with a friendly army and then attacks combine both armies?
  • Can a Goblin army in a mountain pass reach the Front Gate, or must it use the Fallen Bridge?
  • Does an unused concentration token stay on the table at the end of a turn?

The Action Dice

  • When an Action Die shows both a Muster and an Army action, can you use both?
  • Can a Free Peoples army with an Action Die move one army a region and then attack an adjacent region with it, as in War of the Ring?
  • If you run out of units while recruiting, can you place a different unit type from the same recruitment token group?
  • Does discarding an Action die to clear Troubled Mind count as an action?
  • Can a Muster die result add new Recruitment tokens?
  • Can Palantir action dice be used to play Event cards?
  • Can two Armies using Strategic movement move into the same region?
  • Can Goblin armies be activated by an Army die or a Lidless Eye?
  • Can a pure Goblin army be activated with a regular Army die, not only a Lidless Eye?
  • Can a bat moved with a muster die attack, or move like a regular army?
  • Does the Lucky Number card require spending a die to play, and can it be used later without spending an action?
  • Can you flip two recruitment tokens in the same region with one muster action?
  • How does the Shadow get its Wargs and Orcs onto the board at the start?
  • Can the same Character die move the same character more than once in one turn?
  • Can a Will of the West die be used as a Character die, for example to activate Bilbo's Out of the Way?
  • Must you attack after moving when a card or action says to move and attack?
  • Is the 'attack' in a card's move-move-attack sequence the same as the Army attack action?
  • Can the Free Peoples use a General's ability without also using an action die?

Event and Story Cards

  • Does a Captain of War removal of Bilbo let the Free Peoples player bring him back with a Ring token?
  • Can Captain of War be played when the army takes no damage in the Apply Damage step?
  • How long are the Great Bats removed by Wirling Bats kept out of play?
  • Is the Event deck reshuffled when it runs out?
  • Can you move with a Sudden Assault card without making the attack, and must the army attack after it moves?
  • Does playing Orcs of Huge Size discard Howling Orcs?
  • Must you apply every effect on a card if it is possible to do so?
  • Can Encirclement move one Army and then attack with other Armies that did not move?
  • Can the Last Stand card remove Damage from a Broken Fortification?
  • Can Elven Charge be played when Thranduil leads only Dwarves?
  • Can Climbing Goblins open a mountain pass so the whole Army moves into it when three Goblins are in a Goblin Mustering Point?
  • Where does damage from Victory Vanishes from Hope go when the Army is in a Fortification?
  • After Great Dread or Whirling Bats, do the removed Recruitment or Leadership tokens leave the game or return to reserve?
  • Can Lucky Number be played when Bilbo is off the board but still in play?
  • Bilbo's Lucky Number story card: when can an action die be re-rolled, and how many dice?
  • Does it matter which nation's Recruitment tokens Gather and Marshal places into an Army?
  • What happens to Troubled Mind if the chosen General dies, or is brought back by He's Alive?
  • Does Dain or Thorin count as a dwarf for a card requiring an Army with dwarves?
  • Do Fate cards count toward the six-card hand limit?
  • What does the Shadow story card Orc Army require for the moved army's path?
  • Can the Shadow's Ill-Chance story card move ready characters off the Fate track back into play?
  • Can the Last Stand story card repair the Front Gate after Thorin has left the Fortification?
  • Can Redoubled Force heal an army and then move or attack it into an adjacent enemy?
  • Can you remove casualties and damage from an army, then use Flying Arrows and Wild Spears to place units into it?
  • Does Battle-fury's combat effect also apply to the Leader Re-roll?
  • Does the leadership icon on an Event card mean you need Leadership to play it for its combat effect?
  • Do Story or Event cards that say move or attack with that army override Mountain Pass movement restrictions?
  • Can a Troubled Mind card be discarded using a die result at any time?
  • Can the Shadow move the Troubled Mind story card to a different character after it has been used?
  • Does Last Stand's combat strength count beyond five dice?
  • If a card says to move an army one region, can it move two regions by fast movement?
  • Can the Orc Army story card move only part of the chosen army and leave the rest behind?
  • If a story card removes the last unit of an army to add a Bodyguard token, is the character with that army eliminated?
  • Can the Troubled Mind shadow story card target a General that has not yet entered play?
  • Does the Eagles' rule that each attack must target a different Army apply across the whole turn?
  • Are Event cards used in combat discarded after they are played?
  • Are the No Quarter and similar combat Event cards mandatory once played, and when are they applied?
  • Does move-or-attack on the Orcs from Gundabad card allow both a move and an attack?
  • How long does the combat effect of an Event card last?
  • If both players play an Event card whose effects occur at the same time, which one resolves first?
  • Can the Bat Cloud card move the army to any region in the territory, or only to an adjacent region?
  • Can the Great Goblin card be played on an army at a Goblin Mustering Point?
  • When does King of All Birds place an extra Eagle?
  • Can King of All Birds bring the Lord of the Eagles into play if he is not already ready?
  • Does the word 'attack' on an event or story card grant extra movement?
  • Does the Climbing Goblins card let an army move through the Mountain Pass before the pass is opened?

Fate

  • Does the Shadow still draw a Fate tile if the Free Peoples have no Generals to activate?
  • Can Damage be split between Thorin's Fate card and his Army, and can the card hold more than 5 Damage?
  • What happens when the Fate tiles run out?
  • Does Thorin attacking out of the Front Gate break the fortification?
  • Can a Fate card be played on a Character who has not yet entered play, and what happens if he is eliminated?
  • When Beorn enters play after Redoubled in Wrath, how many Wrath tokens does he get?
  • Does the Lord of the Eagles card also bring in the extra Eagle when he enters play?
  • If the Fate track drops below the Eagles' entry value after they came in by card, do they leave play?
  • Does Thorin's Mighty Stroke card become available without the Fate card?
  • Can Thorin's Call to Battle card be used before the first proper Fate card has been drawn?
  • Does Great Orcs' Call to Battle card cause Beorn to lose 2 wounds?
  • Are Fate cards one-and-done like event cards, or do they stay in play with their character?
  • If the Fate marker drops so a Ready character is no longer ready, is he removed from the Fate track?
  • After Ill-Chance makes Thorin not ready, does readying him again give the recruitment tokens again?
  • Is drawing Fate tiles mandatory for the Shadow player?
  • Can the Thorin Oakenshield maneuver card be played in combat when Thorin is not in the game?
  • Is the Arkenstone fate tile needed for the Free Peoples to reach the end of the Fate track?
  • Can Shining Armor protect a Front Gate, and is putting damage on the card optional?
  • Can the Eagles use a standard or enhanced attack with the same Muster die when Eagles Are Not Kindly Birds is in play?

Characters and Leadership

  • Can Beorn end his move in a region with Free Peoples army units, or pass through one?
  • Where does Beorn enter the board?
  • Can Beorn enter play in a southern region that only has a Shadow control marker?
  • How far does Beorn move, and can he attack without moving?
  • What happens when Beorn must retreat and has no legal region, or the only free region holds a Free Peoples army?
  • Does Beorn have to stop when he moves next to a Shadow army?
  • Can a retreating Shadow army retreat into a region holding Beorn?
  • Can Beorn recapture a Shadow settlement, or remove Shadow recruitment tokens, by moving through it?
  • Can Beorn move with a Character die when he has no Wrath tokens left?
  • Can Beorn come back into play after he is removed for losing all his Wrath tokens?
  • Does terrain superiority apply when Beorn is in combat, and which cards does he play?
  • Can Shadow battle cards change Beorn's combat rolls?
  • Does a card that cancels Leader re-rolls also stop Beorn's re-rolls?
  • Can Bilbo's Vanished from Sight remove damage from Beorn?
  • How does Bilbo return to the board after his Ring tokens have removed him?
  • Can Bilbo's Vanished from Sight prevent or remove damage on a fortification?
  • When can Bilbo's Vanished from Sight ability be used?
  • How many Ring tokens does Bilbo have, and what does each one do?
  • Is Bilbo still in play while he is off the board?
  • Does Bilbo get eliminated when he uses his last Ring token, or by any means other than his Army being eliminated?
  • Can an Army whose only character is Bilbo be moved with a Character die?
  • Can a character be eliminated to avoid Great Orc Fell Race damage, and can Bilbo do it?
  • Can Gandalf make a concentrated Blast of Magic every turn?
  • How does Gandalf's General ability work: the Concentration token or Blast of Magic?
  • How long does Gandalf's Concentration token stay on his card, and must it be used the next turn?
  • What happens to Gandalf's Concentration token if he is eliminated?
  • When must Gandalf's Concentration or Blast choice be made?
  • Is the Concentration token tied to the Will of the West action die result?
  • How often can a General use his ability in one turn?
  • Does using a General's special ability use up an Action die?
  • Can Gandalf's Blast of Magic reach any region on the map?
  • For Thranduil's archery and Gandalf's Blast, where is range measured from?
  • Does the plastic stand count when measuring Range Ruler range?
  • Is a target region in range when only the far tip of the Range Ruler touches it?
  • Can archers in the Ruins of Dale be used for Thranduil's archery?
  • Can Gandalf or Thranduil use their magic or archery abilities when alone, without an army?
  • Does Gandalf's Blast of Magic get Leader re-rolls from leadership?
  • Can a General restored by He Is Not Lost still use the activation token he held when he died?
  • Can a dead character receive an activation token?
  • What happens when all Generals are dead or eliminated?
  • What do the green icons on Thorin's and Beorn's cards mean?
  • When are Leadership tokens from Generals and cards removed?
  • Where can the Leadership tokens from activating Generals be placed?
  • Do Leadership tokens move with their Army, and can a token move alone with a Character die?
  • Can a Leadership token be placed in an Army that also has a Character?
  • Is a Leadership token removed from the game when it is killed in combat?
  • Can Leadership tokens go on Goblin armies in the Goblin Mustering Point or Mountain Pass?
  • Does a character's Leadership value count as a Leadership token?
  • Do Leaders or Characters add dice to an army's combat roll?
  • Are Characters counted as units for unit counts, casualties or damage?
  • How many re-rolls do Leadership tokens, Beorn and the Eagles give?
  • Can a Character alone in a region without an Army be attacked, or fight?
  • Can an enemy army move into a region holding a lone Character, and does the Character stop it taking a settlement?
  • When is a Character eliminated, and must a retreating Army take its Character along?
  • Does a character die when the army he is with loses its last unit, including to ranged attacks?
  • If an army retreats into a region with a friendly Character, does the Character become part of that army?
  • Are Great Bats removed when all army units in their region are destroyed?
  • Can the Eagles be eliminated permanently from the board?
  • Can one Bodyguard token absorb every Eagle attack?
  • Do Bolg's Bodyguards also prevent the loss of Leaders?
  • Can Bolg's Bodyguards cancel damage added during an attack, or damage the Shadow player inflicts on himself?
  • Can Bolg enter play from a Goblin Mustering Point or Goblin muster zone?
  • Does Bolg need a Shadow army in the Valley to enter play, and is his entry optional?
  • Where can Bolg's With Renewed Force recruitment tokens be placed?
  • Does Bolg's With Renewed Force need two Settlements, or can one Settlement and one Fortification count, including the Front Gate?
  • Does Thorin leaving the Front Gate break its Fortification?
  • If Thorin is eliminated in combat while defending the Front Gate, is the Fortification destroyed?
  • Can the Free Peoples player assign a general ability that a card forbids, hoping to roll Will of the West?
  • Is a Character in play before he is placed on the board?
  • Can a General that is not activated be moved?

Armies

  • Can Dismay target a Shadow army in a Mountain Pass when a Free Peoples army is in the region the pass connects to?
  • When recruitment pushes an army over the stacking limit, can you remove damage tokens along with the units you eliminate?
  • If the Free Peoples abandon a Fortification, is it broken when the Shadow takes it?
  • When can an army take casualties, removing units to discard Damage tokens?
  • Are units removed from the board available for recruitment again?
  • Can you retreat to or recruit from a settlement that was conquered from the other side?
  • Which Shadow armies can a Character die move, and which can an Army die move?
  • If a recruitment token's unit type has no figures left in the supply, what can be recruited instead?
  • If no Orcs remain, what can the Shadow recruit with an Orc token?
  • Is there a stacking limit in Goblin Mustering Points or Mountain Passes?
  • Can more than five units be moved into a Shadow Mustering region?
  • Are Goblin Mustering Points the same as Mustering Regions?
  • Can an Army use Fast Movement through or out of a Mountain Pass?
  • Does an enemy army inside a Mountain Pass stop a Fast Movement through the region the pass connects to?
  • Is a Goblin's move out of a Mountain Pass one-way, and can a Goblin attack after moving from a pass?
  • Do Goblin armies in a Mountain Pass or a Goblin Mustering Point count as Shadow Armies?
  • Can Bolg or newly recruited Goblins be placed in a Goblin Mustering Point or Mountain Pass?
  • Can recruitment tokens be placed in Goblin Mustering Points?
  • Can you flip two recruitment tokens in the same region in one Recruitment action?
  • Can the Free Peoples place a recruitment token in a captured settlement that has no protection?
  • Can Recruitment tokens discarded by a Great Bats card come from any region?
  • Does a settlement need units in it to stay under control, and does control lapse when its defenders are eliminated?
  • Can an army take an empty enemy settlement or stronghold just by moving into it, or must it attack?
  • Is the Front Gate a Settlement for card effects that refer to Settlements?
  • Can the Shadow place a Control marker on the Front Gate, and how are Fortifications controlled?
  • Can units move in and out of an intact Front Gate?
  • Does damage already on an army that moves or retreats into a Fortification go to the Fortification?
  • Can a Shadow army walk into an unoccupied, intact Fortification and keep its protection?
  • If a broken Fortification changes hands, does its protection recover?
  • Are Leadership tokens permanently eliminated when their army is destroyed?
  • How are Leadership tokens divided when an army splits, and is there a limit?
  • Can Leadership tokens be placed in a Goblin Mustering Point or Mountain Pass, and can direct damage or Eagles attack those spaces?
  • Can an army move and then attack in the same action, including moving one region and attacking an enemy next to its new position?
  • Must an army stop when it moves into a region next to an enemy army, and can a strategic movement enter or pass an enemy army?
  • Must Beorn stop his movement when he ends next to a Shadow army?
  • Can a Shadow army retreat into a region adjacent to Beorn?
  • Can Beorn retreat, and does retreating cost him Damage?
  • Where can Beorn enter play?
  • How are Beorn's eight Wrath tokens split when he enters play?
  • Can non-Goblin units be added to a Goblin Mustering Point, and can Event or Story cards recruit there?
  • Can Goblins move with a normal Army die, or only with the Lidless Eye die?
  • Can a card that says a friendly army moves also move Goblins?
  • Can a normal action die move Goblins still in their starting Mustering Point?
  • When two armies with Damage tokens merge, are the tokens resolved before or after merging?
  • What happens when armies that together exceed five units merge in one region?
  • When are stacking limits checked for an army that moves and then attacks, or for units placed and moved by a card?
  • Can units already in a region join an attack after an army moves in, or can a lone unit merge into a larger army and then attack in one move?
  • Can an army split and attack with only part of its units?
  • Can an army be split so that two parts move to different adjacent regions in one strategic move?
  • Can an army advance into a region after winning a combat, even if it moved next to the enemy before attacking?
  • Can Call to Arms send two Armies in different directions?
  • Can a Character join an Army during a multi-region move?
  • Can a single Army unit move or attack by itself?
  • Do Great Bats or Eagles affect army movement, for example by stopping a Free Peoples army?
  • Can Great Bats or Eagles be attacked?
  • Do Great Bats count as units for the five-unit limit or for combat strength?
  • Do the Eagles enter play when the Lord of the Eagles enters play, or do they need a separate trigger?
  • Can a Great Bat moved by a Muster die also attack?
  • Can newly mustered units be used to remove damage tokens from an army?
  • How does the Shadow get more Recruitment tokens?
  • If no Goblin figures remain, can the Shadow muster Goblins with a Lidless Eye die or substitute another unit?
  • Does a card that says to move an army let you move an army without Leadership?
  • Can Army units enter a region containing only enemy characters, and does that take control of its Settlement?
  • Is the Rally re-roll performed once for each of two armies, and does Leadership change that?
  • Can you remove a unit to heal Damage before a muster would push an army over five units?
  • Do recruitment tokens move with an army?

Combat

  • Can Beorn advance after combat when the enemy army retreats or is eliminated?
  • Can an army retreat into the Ruins of Dale in the rulebook's retreat example?
  • Can Character abilities or Event cards prevent or remove damage on a Fortification?
  • Can a Unit card's maneuver reduce damage on a Fortification?
  • If the Free Peoples retake a broken Fortification, is it active again?
  • Can a broken Fortification be repaired?
  • Does Last Stand limit a Fortification repair to removing five damage tokens?
  • Does Fury of the Dwarves add Combat Strength toward a Last Stand repair?
  • What roll is needed to hit a Fortification, and how do hits count against it?
  • How do Damage tokens on a Fortification relate to its protection value?
  • Does damage from an attack on an army inside a Fortification hit the Fortification first?
  • Do Eagle, Blast of Magic, Archery and Gandalf or Thranduil ability damage hit a Fortification first?
  • Does the Fortification's 6 hit requirement apply to Eagle, Blast of Magic, Archery or Gandalf and Thranduil attacks?
  • Do Bolg's Bodyguards or a Fortification stop self-inflicted damage from No Quarter or Goblin Charge?
  • Does damage from a non-attack Event card bypass a Fortification?
  • Does an army that walks into an undefended Fortification keep its protection?
  • If an Army carrying Damage tokens moves into an undamaged Fortification, does the damage transfer to the Fortification?
  • Does an Army inside a Fortification keep its protection when it attacks out?
  • What is the target number in the second combat round after a Fortification breaks in the first?
  • Can a Warg maneuver affect an Army in a Fortification, or defeat an undamaged one?
  • How many combat dice does an army roll, and is the five-die cap applied to the total Combat Strength?
  • Does Thorin's Mighty Strokes let the Free Peoples roll more than five combat dice?
  • When an Event card makes the opponent roll fewer dice, how is the reduction counted?
  • How many black dice does a unit maneuver use in a mixed army?
  • Does a unit's maneuver ability trigger once per black hit, or once per round?
  • Does a black combat die that hits count as a normal hit as well as triggering its special effect?
  • Does a unit maneuver need an actual hit to work, and does a cancelled hit still trigger it?
  • Can a player decline a unit maneuver's effect once its black die has hit?
  • Are combat effects of Event cards mandatory?
  • When a maneuver and an Event card take effect in the same combat, which resolves first?
  • When Great Orc Fell Race and Captain of War are both played, which resolves first?
  • Can Captain of War remove damage when the attacker's hits were all voided by bodyguards?
  • Does the Great Orcs card inflict 2 Damage when the defender has no Leadership token or Character to eliminate?
  • When Captain of War and a Great Orc maneuver both apply, how much damage results, and can one leader cover both?
  • Can a Goblin maneuver eliminate the Goblins' own last unit?
  • When a Goblin maneuver adds extra damage at the end of the round, is it applied after casualties?
  • How does the Warg maneuver force casualties, and does it need a black hit?
  • When a Dwarf Regular card and the Warg maneuver both apply, which effect goes first?
  • When does the Warg maneuver's effect apply during a combat round?
  • Does a Dwarf Veteran's maneuver effect need a black die hit?
  • Does the Lake-men maneuver card add its extra damage before dice are rolled?
  • Does a successful Lake-men Hail of Darts maneuver give two hits per success?
  • When is damage applied during a combat round, and do extra hits count separately?
  • When is damage taken as a cost for a battle card applied, and does it cause casualties?
  • Does a character count toward units when an army takes damage?
  • Does each Dwarf Regular eliminated in combat remove three Damage tokens?
  • Can a Dwarf Regular maneuver's damage removal be taken in a later round?
  • Does Marching Companies' Remove Leader Re-roll cancel every combat re-roll, and must a unit maneuver hit to trigger?
  • Can a Leadership re-roll be used on any dice, and how many dice can it cover?
  • Can a die be re-rolled more than once by Leadership re-rolls?
  • Can Gandalf's or Thranduil's ranged attacks, such as Blast of Magic or Archery, be re-rolled with a Leadership re-roll?
  • Can combat cards reduce damage from Archery or Blast of Magic?
  • How is terrain superiority decided, and does the Great Orc favored-terrain ability apply when defending?
  • Is terrain superiority checked once per battle, or before every combat round?
  • Who is the defender, and which region's terrain counts for terrain superiority?
  • Do Goblins lose the check for terrain superiority when they break out of a Mountain Pass?
  • What target number does the Shadow use when attacking Lower Slopes from a valley region?
  • Does the slope or ford penalty apply to the defender in combat?
  • When attacking a Fortification up a slope, does the slope penalty still apply after the walls fall?
  • Does the slope defense bonus apply to each attacking Army in a combined attack?
  • Can an army retreat across a ford?
  • Can an army retreat into a region adjacent to an enemy army if a friendly army is already there?
  • Where may a retreating Army go?
  • Can the Shadow retreat an Army into an empty Front Gate that the Free Peoples still control?
  • When a routed Army retreats, is the routing damage taken before the retreat move?
  • What happens when a defending Army routs with no Damage tokens, or with only one?
  • Must a routing Army leave its region, or can it stay where it is?
  • When a Shadow army next to a friendly army has taken casualties, can it rout into an empty region instead?
  • Can an attacking army rout or retreat once combat has started?
  • If an Army retreats after combat with one unit and one damage, is the damage applied before or after it moves?
  • When may a player take casualties to remove Damage tokens?
  • Can a combined attack be made with a card attack or an Eye result instead of an Army die?
  • Can the attacker switch back to an earlier army during a combined attack?
  • When the attacker switches armies in a combined attack, does he get back the maneuver cards already played?
  • Must every adjacent Army join a combined attack?
  • In a combined attack, do the attacking armies choose different defending armies each round?
  • In a combined attack, do both attacking armies' units count for a maneuver ability?
  • If the defender plays Dense Fog during a combined attack, does the whole attack end or only one army's part of it?
  • After Dense Fog ends a combat, does the attacker or the defender retreat or rout?
  • Can an Army attack an empty adjacent or enemy Settlement and then move into it, or move in for free?
  • Can an Army attack with only part of its units?
  • Can an attack move an Army into a friendly Army, merge them, and attack with the merged force?
  • Must an Army advance into a region after winning combat?
  • When an Army advances after combat, must the Characters with it advance too, and can Bolg be left behind?
  • How should Eagle attacks be resolved when Eagles are flown in with a Muster die?
  • Can Gandalf's ranged attack target an enemy Army in the same region?
  • When can a Regroup card be used to retreat from a battle?
  • If Regroup is played and every unit of one type is eliminated, does that Unit card still return to hand?
  • Does Determined Attack's recover-and-replay let you reach any discard pile, including the opponent's maneuvers?
  • How are unit and maneuver cards set up, and do they count toward the hand of six?
  • Are unused Event cards discarded after combat, or kept?
  • Must a card be played in every combat round?
  • Does Thorin's Special Maneuver card work only when Thorin is in the battle?
  • Can Howling Orcs stop the Free Peoples from using Dwarf and Men maneuver abilities when Great Orcs attack?
  • How is the Howling Orcs card discarded, and does it stop Thorin's special ability card?
  • Must the Range Ruler avoid black borders?
  • Is a region in range if the Range Ruler can reach it without crossing a black border?
  • Is a region still in range if the Range Ruler only just reaches it?
  • Does the far end of the Range Ruler need to be inside the target region for an Archery or Gandalf attack?
  • Can Gandalf's range ruler be used against an enemy Army in the same region he occupies?
  • Can Lake-men attack a Shadow army across a region using the Range Ruler in a normal attack?
  • Can Thranduil's Archery be used before measuring range, and does terrain matter?
  • Can Thranduil's Archery attack cross a black impassable border?
  • Can archers attack across a river with no Ford, using Thranduil's ability or Gandalf's Blast of Magic?
  • Does Vampire-like still trigger when Wall of Spears cancels the damage?
  • Does Vampire-like work against a Fortification, and does a hit on a Fortification count?
  • Do you roll black dice when playing Vampire-like?
  • Does a Vampire-like card return to hand if none of its bats scored a hit?
  • Can Beorn reroll combat dice in every combat round of a battle?
  • Can the winner of a combined attack move in with an army that did not take part in the fight?

Victory Conditions

  • When is the Beorn victory check made: when he enters play, or whenever he becomes ready?
  • How many Victory Points are Fortifications, Settlements and the Front Gate worth?
  • Does the Shadow lose Victory Points when the Free Peoples retake a Settlement or Fortification?
  • Does a Free Peoples army leaving a Settlement keep control of it, and can an enemy move into an empty Fortification and take control?
  • Does the Front Gate get a control marker even though it is not a Settlement?
  • Does holding the Front Gate count as a Settlement for Settlement-based Event cards?
  • Does capturing the Front Gate along with another Settlement in the same territory give the Shadow an extra Action Die?
  • Can the Shadow control a Valley region with neither Settlements nor Fortifications in order to bring in Bolg?
  • Can the Free Peoples or Beorn capture a Shadow muster point?
  • For the Shadow's 10-point win check, does a turn mean one action die or the whole action phase?
  • Can the Shadow capture the Front Gate by retreating into it, and does it need units there to keep control?

Additional Rules

  • Does Beorn need a 6 to hit a Fortification, even when a card strengthens him?
  • Can Eagles attack Goblin Mustering Points or Mountain Passes?
  • Does removing a Great Bat from play return it to the reserve?
  • Does a Fortification change the hit roll for an Eagle attack?
  • Can an Eagle attack remove Eagles from different regions and attack in each during one action?
  • Can the same Shadow Army be attacked again by a second Eagle attack in the same round?
  • Do the Eagles have to be in the same territory as the Army they attack with Eagles Are Not Kindly Birds?
  • Can Beorn move through a region that contains a Free Peoples army?
  • Does bringing Beorn into play with a Character die use up the whole die, so he cannot also attack that turn?
  • Can Beorn attack an adjacent Shadow army without moving first?
  • Can a Shadow Army attack Beorn?
  • Does a card that cancels the opponent's leadership re-roll also cancel Beorn's re-roll?
  • How many dice can Beorn or an Eagle re-roll in an attack?