Above and Below FAQ
123 questions players ask · Updated Nov 13, 2026 · Full rulebook
Setup and Components
- Which players get the extra starting coin?
- How does round one work in a four-player game?
- Why does the four-player setup start with only one usable villager each?
- Does every player start with one of each villager type, including a Quill villager?
- How many outposts are available at the start of the game?
- How can you tell the special villagers apart from the regular ones?
- With the Megaland bonus cards, how many star house cards go out at setup?
- What does the key house promo card let you do?
Player Actions
- How many villagers can you send on one harvest, labor, explore, build or train action?
- How many actions can you take in one turn?
- Can you take the same action, such as explore or harvest, more than once in a round?
- Must actions be taken in the order listed on the rulebook or player board?
- Is there a limit on how many villagers you can train in one round?
- Can you build or train more than once in the same turn?
- Must you use every ready villager before you pass?
- Can one harvest action use several villagers across several buildings?
- After buying a house or outpost, when is the empty building slot refilled?
Exploring
- Do you choose an explore option before rolling?
- Do you spend a coin for a bonus lantern before or after rolling?
- When an explore option says explore a number and spend a coin, do you pay before or after the roll?
- Do you hear an encounter's bonus text before you choose an option?
- Does a bonus modifier on an encounter apply to every choice, or only the one directly above it?
- When an encounter bonus counts hammers or resources, which ones count?
- How do "bonus +1 lantern per hammer" style lines work on an explore?
- Can you exert villagers to meet an explore target, even all of them?
- What happens if you still fail an explore after exerting villagers?
- Is there a maximum number of villagers you can send exploring?
- Can you roll for lanterns more than once in one explore encounter?
- Does a choice with no lantern target count as a success?
- When a choice points to another paragraph, when is that paragraph read?
- If a villager is put in a cage, do their lanterns still count on the explore roll?
- If you cannot pay a coin an encounter requires, do you still get the reward or the success?
- Does the keep exploring option let you roll and resolve another encounter?
- If a story tells you to injure a villager, must you injure one who did not explore?
- What happens when the cave card deck runs out during exploring?
- Can you build an outpost on a cave card you gained from a reward?
- Do caverns and outposts need an above-ground building?
- Do you roll one die per explorer and leave each die on its villager?
- Can you wait until every explorer has rolled before using rerolls?
- Is there an extra penalty for the failure text 'unable to find a safe place to build'?
Encounter Book
- Is the duplicated encounter number on one cave card a misprint?
- In Adventure 31, do you pay a coin for both Trade With the Man options?
- Does the make an offering option in encounter 166 require giving anything up?
- What do the asterisks next to some encounter numbers mean?
- Does the story carry over between games?
Free Actions
- When can you take free actions, and must they come before your normal action?
- Can you put a good you just harvested or gained up for sale on the same turn?
- Can you remove a good from the sale spot, or swap it, outside your own turn?
- Can you pay for a good, cider or potion bought from another player with goods, or only with coins?
- Can you put a good and a cider or potion up for sale at the same time?
- Can other players negotiate or promise to buy during a goods sale, and are they bound to keep the promise?
- When you refresh a row of outposts or houses, where do the discarded cards go?
- Where does a harvested good go before you place it, and can you sell it at the start of your next turn?
2. End the Round
- When can you use potions and ciders?
- What does a potion or a cider do for a villager?
- Can one villager get both a potion and a cider?
- Can an injured villager use a potion and a bed, or a potion and a cider, in one night?
- Do you have to put an injured villager in a bed, or can he stay in the injured area?
- Can you use more villagers than you have beds for, and how do beds restore them?
- Can a potion from potion income heal a villager in the same round?
- When do villagers become ready again after being bought or trained, at the end of each turn or only between rounds?
- When you refill the villager row, do unbought villagers slide left and new ones fill the right, or do they stack?
Other Rules
- Can the cheapest villager be removed from the village if nobody takes a villager that turn?
- Do villagers you gain from encounters or cave finds arrive exhausted?
- Does the Fishfolk special rule apply to the frog villager?
- What is a fishfolk villager, and where is the term explained?
- Can the Metal Man be exerted, and can he use a bed, potion or cider?
- What happens if the cave cat's roll fails?
- Can you use a reroll symbol on the cave cat's assignment roll?
- What happens to reputation gained beyond the end of the reputation track?
- If you cannot move back the full distance on the reputation track, do you still get the coins?
- Is the money you hold hidden from other players?
- How are Islebound characters added to the villager row in Above and Below?
- How do Near and Far adventurers work in Above and Below?
Game End
- Do buildings score one village point each at game end, including the starting house?
- Does a star house that pays 2 points per above-ground building count the starting house and itself?
- Does a villager-points symbol count every villager, including starting and special ones?
- With three players, does the player with the least reputation get 2 village points at game end?
- When players tie for reputation, how do you split the combined reward?
- Is income collected after the final round?
- Can a good still up for sale be moved onto your track at the end of the game?
- Does the empty-cave village-point symbol count caves that have an outpost?
Goods
- Do goods on the advancement track count as owned for end-game points and quests?
- Do goods in your personal supply count for income, and for bonus points on goods cards?
- Which fish count toward a bonus for fish?
- Can only goods, not ciders or potions, be placed on the advancement track?
- Can you place a good on your advancement track at any time, including on another player's turn?
- Do goods from an explore reward go straight onto the advancement track?
- Are goods, ciders and potions limited to the number in the box?
- What do you get when a resource runs out during a reward?
- How much income do ore and amethyst give, and must they be on the track?
- What do the goods icons down the left side of the main board mean?
- Can you sell or move a good that is already on your advancement track?
Symbols
- Do ciders and potions count as coins for a tie-break at game end?
- Can you pay another player, or buy a building, with ciders or potions?
- Does a hand symbol with potions on a key house card give you the potions when you buy it?
- Do income symbols on buildings pay every round, or only once when built?
- Does a villager with a quill+ or build+ symbol get a discount?
- Can you reroll the same die more than once with several reroll symbols?
- Does each reroll symbol let you reroll one die, or any number of dice?
- Can you use a building's re-roll ability on every explore action in the same round?
- What does a village-points icon with an outpost picture count?
Above and Below: GrovesExpansion
- Do you declare which Grove reward you are aiming for before rolling?
- Does a Grove's person symbol let you recruit a villager for free?
- Does a potion symbol on a building count for the Grove potion adjacency bonus?
- Can you rearrange your buildings, or slot a Grove between two buildings you already have?
- Can Grove cards be placed next to below-ground buildings?
- Can a Grove be placed next to another Grove?
- Can you see only the top Grove card, and must you wait for it to be taken before the next is revealed?
- Does a Grove card score the one-point-per-building bonus at game end?
- Do you need to send at least two explorers to a Grove?
- How do Grove cards score at game end?
- Does the coin after a successful exploration apply when you explore a Grove?
Above and Below: Expanded Edition ExclusivesExpansion
- Once you earn a quest token, do you keep it if you later drop below the requirement?
- Can a Basket harvest from two different buildings in one action?
- When do quest tokens that require goods count as fulfilled: when you buy the good, or only after you harvest it?
- Do supplies still score end-game points if you spend them?
- Can a status such as poison be removed from a villager once gained?
- What are tools and quests in the Expanded Edition, and what do they do?
- Do items count for an explore bonus only when they are on your advancement track?
- How do you identify the Expanded Edition villagers?