Here I Stand
If an attacker loses an assault on an island fortress, do its forces retreat by sea or get eliminated?
The designer's later reply that attacking leaders are never captured in the siege rules replaces his earlier reply on captures.
- Ed Beach · Designer · 2008-10-18superseded
- Ed Beach · Designer · 2009-03-18
- Here I Stand rulebook · Rulebook · 15.1 Assault
They are eliminated. A besieging force cannot retreat into a sea zone, and an island has no adjacent space to retreat to, so the force is lost. Surviving attacking leaders are not captured by the siege rules, according to the designer's later ruling.