Here I Stand
In a later debate round, does the attacker still get +3 dice while a committed defender gets only +1?
The rulebook's attacker and defender dice rules match this reading, and the posts agree.
- Here I Stand rulebook · Rulebook · 18.5 Theological Debates
- Philip Thomas · Community · 2008-04-01
- Ed Beach · Designer · 2008-04-01
- tabpub · Community · 2019-01-25
- Statalyzer · Community · 2019-01-31
Yes. The attacker keeps the debater's value plus 3 in every round, because the attacker pays for the action. A committed defender rolls the debater's value plus 1. A debater bonus such as Eck's extra die does not apply if that debater was already committed before the round.