Here I Stand
Do Carlstadt's or Calvin's bonuses need a Publish Treatise action first, and must all three of their attempts be made?
The designer ruled that all three attempts must be made if possible, and the rulebook's Reformation Attempts section sets the zones and the three attempts.
- Here I Stand rulebook · Rulebook · 18.3 Reformation Attempts
- Ed Beach · Designer · 2011-11-29
- turbothy · Community · 2011-11-29
- turbothy · Community · 2011-02-09
- turbothy · Community · 2012-11-13
Yes to both. Their bonuses modify a Publish Treatise action, which must be taken first, and they make three attempts instead of two. Carlstadt's attempts must be in the German zone and Calvin's in the French zone. The designer ruled that once one of these bonuses is used, all three attempts must be made if possible.