Elder Sign
Can you choose a Desert Caravan Mythos option that you cannot fully carry out, such as discarding trophies you do not have?
The rules let players choose either option, but two posters argue the other way, so the reading is contested.
- Scarlet Witch · Community · 2018-03-02
- TaffyGuy · Community · 2018-03-02disagrees
- Kordalia · Community · 2026-05-06disagrees
Yes. Players may choose either option, even one that does nothing, so with no trophies you discard none and gain nothing. Some players argue that an option you cannot fully carry out voids the whole card, so the question is contested.