Diplomacy
What happens in a convoy paradox, where convoys depend on each other?
Adjudicators disagree on this paradox and the rulebook does not resolve it.
- lkruijsw · Community · 2011-03-18
- Nikoda · Community · 2011-02-24
- quozl · Community · 2011-02-22
- Barticus88 · Community · 2015-03-19
The rulebook does not settle every paradox. Many adjudicators use the Szykman resolution: the convoy fails without dislodging any unit, the support stays valid, and the attacks bounce. Others argue that a convoy that could conceivably fail does fail, which dislodges the fleets. Both views exist, so the choice should be agreed in advance.