Deception: Murder in Hong Kong
← All Deception: Murder in Hong Kong questions
If the Forensic Scientist replaces a clue tile, does the removed clue still count?
Several experienced players agree the rules are silent; no official ruling covers it.
- eateng300 · Community · 2025-12-09
- paschott · Community · 2025-11-25
- iNano78 · Community · 2025-11-25
- patcon · Community · 2025-11-26
- Cordwangle · Community · 2016-06-18
The rules do not say, so it is up to the group. Players commonly treat a removed clue as still relevant, though the Forensic Scientist usually removes the tile they judge least helpful, and investigators can reason from which tile was removed.
More Deception: Murder in Hong Kong questions · Full rulebook