Critter Kitchen
← All Critter Kitchen questions
If the tied chef who picks first takes only a consolation soup, do they still move to the back of the priority track?
Two designer replies say the first pick counts even when it is soup, and this matches the rulebook's tie section.
- PeterCHayward · Designer · 2025-03-20
- PeterCHayward · Designer · 2026-06-24
- Critter Kitchen rulebook · Rulebook · Breaking Ties During Shopping
- ColtsFan76 · Community · 2025-07-03
Yes. A consolation soup taken as the first pick still counts as the first pick, so that chef gives up priority. The first-pick rule applies whatever the first pick is, and a tie alone is not enough: the tied chef must be first to pick there.