Bridge
Can a claim depend on which card a defender's partner chooses to discard?
The rulebook's contested-claim law addresses this directly, and an ACBL bulletin ruling agrees.
- Bridge rulebook · Rulebook · Law 70 — Contested Claim or Concession
- Bankler · Community · 2012-06-07
- Bankler · Community · 2012-06-20
- mfrench1 · Community · 2012-06-07superseded
No. The director does not accept any part of a claim that depends on the partner selecting a particular play from among normal alternatives. Discarding an obvious winner is not a normal play and is not required. The older 1963 rule that made the partner's cards penalty cards no longer applies.