Black Orchestra
← All Black Orchestra questions
If an event says you may do X to do Y, can you still do Y when X cannot be carried out?
Posters split on this, the rulebook text points both ways, and no designer answer exists.
- Triggersten · Community · 2025-06-11
- Adrian2 · Community · 2025-06-11
- NeedlesandPins · Community · 2025-06-11disagrees
- bad63rfx · Community · 2025-03-12
- Heegu · Community · 2025-09-25
- pietu85 · Community · 2025-04-12disagrees
- Tronin · Community · 2025-08-02
- Black Orchestra rulebook · Rulebook · Resolving Effectsdisagrees
Probably not. The stronger reading treats X as a cost: if you cannot pay it, Y is lost. The rulebook's general rule that an unresolvable effect does not block the others points the other way, and no designer ruling settles it.