If one card says the Berwick Sisters or Greg Gaffney might have passed through the Trophy Room, and two other cards say neither passed, are they innocent?

Question

Accepted Answer

Neither is the murderer, by the rulebook's logic: if either were, they would have had to pass through the Trophy Room, and the other two cards rule that out. They are innocent in the game's sense only once all three of their motives are dismissed.

Awkward Guests: The Walton Case

If one card says the Berwick Sisters or Greg Gaffney might have passed through the Trophy Room, and two other cards say neither passed, are they innocent?